3 Cornerstones of the Truther Movement

The OP, said this cornerstone, I was giving an example when this clearly is not the case.

No sir, you gave an example of why this clearly is the case (to everyone but you).
 
No whatever this guy's motivation was, it was clearly not the "fog of war" as to why he is mistaken. He is clearly lying. I've never said every eye witness account is wrong. Will never say it. So let me use your logic, perhaps all the witnesses that saw a commercial plane were lost in the "fog of war" I mean you can't have it both ways. The OP, said this cornerstone, I was giving an example when this clearly is not the case.

As for why "they" would want to do it. Remember this was FOX many times FOX (like any of the big stations) share their local news. What I mean is, you could be living in Boston and they will show you a snip-it of the D.C. broadcast for different reasons. They could (I stress could) have been trying to sell a lie to as many people as possible. I don't know what the motivation would have been I wouldn't have been in on the plot, this assumes he was something other than a nut. I do know you can't blame this witness on the "fog of war", which is why I gave it.

Yes, you do in fact stress and overstress the "could".
You don't know of course.

Your argument breaks down on every step:
- You don't even know if Aziz' estimates for the timeline are correct
- You don't know if he reliably remembers his location at various instances
- You don't know if you imterprete his wording correctly
- You don't know if the man in the Ingersoll photo is really Aziz or just another man with similar features
- You don't know exactly when that photo was taken
- You don't know if that piece is from a plane or not
- If it's not, you don't know if Aziz is mistaken or lying
- But even if you know it all, and every step of your argument is correct: It does not change at all what we know about 9/11!

For the sake of argument, tmd, please explain to us how what we know about 9/11 would be different if Aziz had never walked into that TV studio!
 
No sir, you gave an example of why this clearly is the case (to everyone but you).

Fine than I guess the witnesses that identified it as a commercial A/C were also under "the fog of war". You can't have it both ways.
 
Yes, you do in fact stress and overstress the "could".
You don't know of course.

Your argument breaks down on every step:
- You don't even know if Aziz' estimates for the timeline are correct
- You don't know if he reliably remembers his location at various instances
- You don't know if you imterprete his wording correctly
- You don't know if the man in the Ingersoll photo is really Aziz or just another man with similar features
- You don't know exactly when that photo was taken
- You don't know if that piece is from a plane or not
- If it's not, you don't know if Aziz is mistaken or lying
- But even if you know it all, and every step of your argument is correct: It does not change at all what we know about 9/11!

For the sake of argument, tmd, please explain to us how what we know about 9/11 would be different if Aziz had never walked into that TV studio!

It's clear nothing will change what you guys think of 9/11. Nothing can interfere with your dogma. But on that day, talking to an already traumatized audience, perhaps someone coming in with a piece of what he says was the plane, would have some affect on some people/
 
It's clear nothing will change what you guys think of 9/11. Nothing can interfere with your dogma.

So says the one who came here to spread his cult's infallible "truth" to us. We aren't the ones running around the internet and public trying to convince everyone of their dogma and delusions, that's you and your cult.
 
Last edited:
So let me use your logic, perhaps all the witnesses that saw a commercial plane were lost in the "fog of war" I mean you can't have it both ways.

And how much will those witnesses' statements be questioned after looking at reams of evidence that backs up what they saw?
 
Well, why is it so difficult to be told what it was? You're always saying "I don't Know" yet you flat-out ignore when people fill in these blanks for you. Are you like this with everything? How is it you can learn a skill? One of these days you're going to need to have a skill - to make a living and hopefully support a family. You're not going to be able to do that unless you want to actually learn something.


I'm waiting, TMD
 
Fine than I guess the witnesses that identified it as a commercial A/C were also under "the fog of war". You can't have it both ways.

No, but we can analyse the information rationally and examine which way the preponderance of evidence points. If a large number of witnesses identified the object striking the Pentagon as a commercial aircraft, that's strongly suggestive that that's what it was. If we know from radio traffic and phone calls that a commercial aircraft was hijacked as part of a plot to crash commercial aircraft into major US landmarks, that conclusion is strengthened. If parts of a commercial aircraft are found at the crash site, including a flight data recorder that shows the path of that aircraft from takeoff at an airport where it is known from other sources to have taken off, if remains of all but a few of the passengers on board that aircraft are identified from DNA testing, and if the aircraft is known not to be anywhere else it might be expedted to be, then the perponderance of evidence becomes overwhelming. If a few eyewitness accounts differ in a few minor details, then that's exactly what we would expect; that is the "fog of war", but the convergence of evidence allows us to determine, to a reasonable precision, the major events.

So enough of the truther act of sticking your tongue out, jeering, and pretending that we have to ignore a mountain of our own evidence if we ignore your insignificant detail. The two cases are in no sense equivalent.

Dave
 
Kind of hard to blame this doofus on the "fog of war"

His name is Aziz El Hallan.
Many people are not aware of him, but late in the afternoon on 9/11 he showed up to the local Washington D.C Fox with an actual piece of what he claimed to be flight 77, as seen here (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WpBH6YwXYnU) If that isn't strange enough, he claims to have been on the road for 15-20 minutes (after the attack), yet there is a picture of him at the latest 8 minutes after the attack, taken by an official military photographer, as seen here.( http://pilotsfor911truth.org/forum/index.php?showtopic=8818) It is at the Navy annex. Very strange indeed, also this photo was omitted from the official DOD release.
Not a match. Nose is different.
 
It's clear nothing will change what you guys think of 9/11. Nothing can interfere with your dogma. But on that day, talking to an already traumatized audience, perhaps someone coming in with a piece of what he says was the plane, would have some affect on some people/

Forget about "us" here.
I meant the world.
The world that recognizes that there is a wealth of physical and documentary evidence to the fact that AA77, a Boeing 767, crashed into the Pentagon with innocent passengers and crew aboard.
Evidence that is corroborated by almost all of the eye witnesses. Including Aziz.
Eye witnesses that all the world understands to be prone to error of perception and memory. Even prone to some degree of making stuff up.

In this world - the real world of facts - what difference does it make if Aziz is right or mistaken or lying or non-existent?

Would it change the way the DNA evidence is read?
Would it change the assessment of the destruction inside the building?
Would it somehow change the nature of the plane debris that was found both inside the building and on the lawn?
Would it change what radar saw and recorded?
Would it change the contents of the Flight Data Recorder?
Would it shut up Al Qaeda bragging about the attacks?
Would it change what is seen, and not seen, on the parking lot cam stills?
Would American Airlines suddenly wake to the possibility that they didn't lose a plane at the Pentagon?
Would it alert AA's insurers?
Would it put into perspective even one other witness testimony?
 
Here are two photos taken at the Navy annex. It is obvious that they were taken only a few seconds apart. You can recognize many of the same people. It is not clear in the second photo which the guy in question, but it seems that it could be either the man with the briefcase walking away from the camera on the left, or the person to whom the man in khaki is speaking. The man with the briefcase is likely not Aziz because he has on a short-sleeved shirt. The other person appears to be holding something that resembles a file box. Perhaps something he grabbed as he evacuated his office in the annex.

http://i40.photobucket.com/albums/e207/Mercury2/DSC_0404.jpg

http://www.flickr.com/photos/26734831@N00/1308056424/in/set-72157601830559455/lightbox/

It does not sound from the tv interview, as if Aziz left the immediate area of his car.

I liken the CT claims about this individual as similar to the claim that Lloyde England is somehow a lynchpin of the official story - without his claim that the plane knocked a lightpole through his windshield, the whole thing falls apart. :rolleyes:
 
Fine than I guess the witnesses that identified it as a commercial A/C were also under "the fog of war". You can't have it both ways.

Indeed, they may have been mistaken. However they were the only witnesses nor piece of evidence, the Radar data says it was AA77, The forensic say it was AA77 so we know they were correct.

If you are claiming (correctly) that eye witness evidence is problematical then you just destroyed what tiny case CIT had left..........In the UK for example its now rare that anyone gets convicted on eye witness evidence alone.
 
Here are two photos taken at the Navy annex. It is obvious that they were taken only a few seconds apart. You can recognize many of the same people. It is not clear in the second photo which the guy in question, but it seems that it could be either the man with the briefcase walking away from the camera on the left, or the person to whom the man in khaki is speaking. The man with the briefcase is likely not Aziz because he has on a short-sleeved shirt. The other person appears to be holding something that resembles a file box. Perhaps something he grabbed as he evacuated his office in the annex.

http://i40.photobucket.com/albums/e207/Mercury2/DSC_0404.jpg

http://www.flickr.com/photos/26734831@N00/1308056424/in/set-72157601830559455/lightbox/

It does not sound from the tv interview, as if Aziz left the immediate area of his car.

I liken the CT claims about this individual as similar to the claim that Lloyde England is somehow a lynchpin of the official story - without his claim that the plane knocked a lightpole through his windshield, the whole thing falls apart. :rolleyes:


I can't see anyone on those picture who anyone but a nut could claim as being the same guy as on the TV.
 
No, but we can analyse the information rationally and examine which way the preponderance of evidence points. If a large number of witnesses identified the object striking the Pentagon as a commercial aircraft, that's strongly suggestive that that's what it was. If we know from radio traffic and phone calls that a commercial aircraft was hijacked as part of a plot to crash commercial aircraft into major US landmarks, that conclusion is strengthened. If parts of a commercial aircraft are found at the crash site, including a flight data recorder that shows the path of that aircraft from takeoff at an airport where it is known from other sources to have taken off, if remains of all but a few of the passengers on board that aircraft are identified from DNA testing, and if the aircraft is known not to be anywhere else it might be expedted to be, then the perponderance of evidence becomes overwhelming. If a few eyewitness accounts differ in a few minor details, then that's exactly what we would expect; that is the "fog of war", but the convergence of evidence allows us to determine, to a reasonable precision, the major events.

So enough of the truther act of sticking your tongue out, jeering, and pretending that we have to ignore a mountain of our own evidence if we ignore your insignificant detail. The two cases are in no sense equivalent.

Dave

Yes you're right, but the only thing that conclusively says what it was, is the witnesses. The DNA would be the strongest corroborating evidence. Albeit a little far fetched there are other ways the DNA could have got there. The passengers could have quickly been herded in a military plane. It could have been planted, it would only take a few people, and you don't need the whole body. This is of course assuming the DNA tests are real, another possibility. Seems difficult but it's not impossible.

As for Aziz, he's clearly lying. He's photographed somewhere else. He doesn't have his girlfriend with him, he doesn't have the piece of the plane with him. But you forget the most important part. This guy actually showed up to a News studio with crime scene evidence from the biggest crime in U.S, history, with no repercussions. At least I couldn't find any. The fact he was let into the studio, and not arrested gives me pause. Now it could be they determined he was just a nut, and decided not to do anything. But he is clearly lying.

I know what the real problem is. If that isn't flight 77, if it's anything else...that's it the official story is false. Aziz casts doubt to the whole situation. If he his lying it doesn't mean the official story is false, but it will give people pause. So you have no choice but to relentlessly defend it. Everything about Aziz is patently absurd, and you know that. You see, me on the other hand, that could very will be flight 77, and an alternative theory could still be correct. It doesn't make much of a difference. You however are left defending the absurd.
 
Last edited:
Forget about "us" here.
I meant the world.
The world that recognizes that there is a wealth of physical and documentary evidence to the fact that AA77, a Boeing 767, crashed into the Pentagon with innocent passengers and crew aboard.
Evidence that is corroborated by almost all of the eye witnesses. Including Aziz.
Eye witnesses that all the world understands to be prone to error of perception and memory. Even prone to some degree of making stuff up.

In this world - the real world of facts - what difference does it make if Aziz is right or mistaken or lying or non-existent?

Would it change the way the DNA evidence is read?
Would it change the assessment of the destruction inside the building?
Would it somehow change the nature of the plane debris that was found both inside the building and on the lawn?
Would it change what radar saw and recorded?
Would it change the contents of the Flight Data Recorder?
Would it shut up Al Qaeda bragging about the attacks?
Would it change what is seen, and not seen, on the parking lot cam stills?
Would American Airlines suddenly wake to the possibility that they didn't lose a plane at the Pentagon?
Would it alert AA's insurers?
Would it put into perspective even one other witness testimony?

Yes I do believe it could make a difference, a small one but it could. The people that would have done this are brilliant evil of course but brilliant. They are masters of psychology. They knew that at that time, remember this was only at 4:40 or so on that day, the public was so traumatized, they wouldn't be thinking rationally. No one would be thinking, how does he have that piece. This subconsciously could stay with an individual, and when they here evidence that there may not have been a plane, on a subconscious level, they were already assured that it was a plane, and it makes it all the more difficult to think it is something other then a plane.

Now of course I don't think Aziz by himself would do this, but you add up several messages like this, it could have an affect. At least I think so. Whether you like to admit it or not, there is some evidence that a plane didn't crash there. No tail section, no fuselage, no parts serial numbers traced back. If (and I stress if) there wasn't a plane that hit the pentagon, things like Aziz would have made it more difficult to believe.
 
Here are two photos taken at the Navy annex. It is obvious that they were taken only a few seconds apart. You can recognize many of the same people. It is not clear in the second photo which the guy in question, but it seems that it could be either the man with the briefcase walking away from the camera on the left, or the person to whom the man in khaki is speaking. The man with the briefcase is likely not Aziz because he has on a short-sleeved shirt. The other person appears to be holding something that resembles a file box. Perhaps something he grabbed as he evacuated his office in the annex.

http://i40.photobucket.com/albums/e207/Mercury2/DSC_0404.jpg

http://www.flickr.com/photos/26734831@N00/1308056424/in/set-72157601830559455/lightbox/

It does not sound from the tv interview, as if Aziz left the immediate area of his car.

I liken the CT claims about this individual as similar to the claim that Lloyde England is somehow a lynchpin of the official story - without his claim that the plane knocked a lightpole through his windshield, the whole thing falls apart. :rolleyes:


Remember he said he was heading to work. You're right it doesn't sound like he left the immediate area of his car, which wouldn't be a good thing, since he was photographed at the Navy Annex.
 
Well, why is it so difficult to be told what it was? You're always saying "I don't Know" yet you flat-out ignore when people fill in these blanks for you. Are you like this with everything? How is it you can learn a skill? One of these days you're going to need to have a skill - to make a living and hopefully support a family. You're not going to be able to do that unless you want to actually learn something.


I'm waiting, TMD

I don't like being told what to and what not to believe. It's as simple as that. I want to check it all for myself.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom