2500 to 70

Homeoskeptic said:
per the instructions in the Organon.
That would be instructions dated back to the time before bacteria and virus was discovered, right?

Oh, by the way, an old relative of mine has a very nasty bacteria infection, originating from a hip-joint problem. The infection makes her tired, that’s it, nothing more. According to Homeopathy, the correct remedy would be a diluted substance that in normal dose would make her tired, right? Or have I misunderstood somehow?
 
Homeoskeptic said:
Since when have I ever said that alcohol was a homeopathic remedy?
Well, I can't remember the exact details of every thread. Maybe it was one of your esteemed colleagues. Someone did declare very definitely that alcohol is a homoeopathic remedy, though. I bow to your superior knowledge of the matter. Has alcohol been proved as a homoeopathic remedy or not?

Anders said:
According to Homeopathy, the correct remedy would be a diluted substance that in normal dose would make her tired, right? Or have I misunderstood somehow?
That's what you'd think, isn't it. But it's much more mystical than that.

Firstly, the "provings" of the remedies on healthy subjects are done using the molecule-free magic water, not a "normal dose", contrary to what you read in many commentaries. So what you get isn't so much a list of genuine symptoms as a slew of self-obsessed psychological ramblings. Second, when a homoeopath takes a case, they ask about far more than the obvious presenting signs and significant abnormalities. Matters of temperament and demeanour and all sorts of subjective things are given a lot of prominence and influence the choice of remedy. Hans has a wonderful case record taken from the Homeopathy Home BB where the clinching factor in deciding the right remedy was that the child concerned liked sausages!

If you want to see some really amazing provings diaries, take a look at this site here. This url was given to BSM when he asked to be shown an example of the rigorously controlled, scientific, double-blinded provings that are allegedly being carried out these days. A bigger pile of New-age manure would be difficult to find, I think.

Rolfe.
 
Homeopathy is a lot more complext than that.

BSM, what a shame noone has bothered to reply to your thread. O, well. Top marks for effort though!! Hah, hah.
 
Homeoskeptic said:
Homeopathy is a lot more complext than that.
Good thing then that science is quite simple. My relative was treated with antibiotica and is now healthy, her bacteria (for you Homeoskeptic, bacteria is, as the Oragono doesn't mention bacteria, one cell organisms with DNA), count from her blood has gone down from an unhealthy level of over 100 to a healty singeldigigt level.

But to find out that is was a bacteria infection they had to do a number of different tests, among others taking blood samples.

So, Homeoskeptic, I'd like to know how a Homeopath would pursue that problem, how would a Homeopath find out that i was a bacteria infection?

Regards
Anders
 
Homeoskeptic said:
Also, remedies are normally made with distilled water and Vodka is used as a preservative.
Distilled water? Is that what Hahnemann used? How come we see references in so many texts to "spring water"? Quite a bit of difference so far as dissolved salts goes, I would have thought. And what happened to the elusive "nuclear grade water", anyway (whatever the hell that is)?

So we have some water of an undecided level of purity, with an undisclosed amount of vodka in it. All these subtle "memory of water" effects we keep being asked to believe in. Wouldn't the exact composition of this solvent be a bit relevant when examining this sort of phenomenon?

Rolfe.
 
Originally posted by Homeoskeptic
Homeopathy is a lot more complext than that.
Is it? Or did you lot just make it more complex so it wouldn't seem like you're just leafing through a shortlist of 70 remedies, while at the end handing the patient just 1: water.
From my point of view, homeopathy is really simple:
1. You see the patient, talk to them for a much longer time than an MD would.
2. Give them a bottle of water or a sugar pill, and let nature take its course.
3. If they get better, score another one for homeopathy, if they get worse, score another one for homeopathy (aggravation), if there's no change whatsoever, make them buy another remedy and repeat step two.
all the other added complexities are just there to camouflage the fact that homeopathy is nothing but quackery.

BSM, what a shame noone has bothered to reply to your thread. O, well. Top marks for effort though!! Hah, hah.
Oh, that should be no one, but who am I to teach you English.
It seems the reason no one replied is because the topic has been closed. No doubt the H'pathy mods thought it contained a little too much common sense, and decided to avoid that common sense by suggesting a new thread be used to continue the discussion. Sadly, an often used tactic on H'pathy :rolleyes:
 
exarch said:
It seems the reason no one replied is because the topic has been closed. No doubt the H'pathy mods thought it contained a little too much common sense, and decided to avoid that common sense by suggesting a new thread be used to continue the discussion. Sadly, an often used tactic on H'pathy :rolleyes:

I have reopened the topic and they have moved it to another forum

http://homeopathyforums.hpathy.com//forum_posts.asp?TID=1500&PN=1&TPN=1

Next it's close the topic. Next it's ban the poster.

Apparently I called someone a name, but as usual "F*ck off, troll" remains acceptable, because Divina's potty-mouth remins there for all to see.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom