2500 to 70

Badly Shaved Monkey

Anti-homeopathy illuminati member
Joined
Feb 5, 2004
Messages
5,363
All you budding homeopaths, can take reassurance from this. Never mind the 2500, or whatever it is, proved remedies. If you use a restricted range of 70, you can cure 99% of your cases.

http://homeopathyforums.hpathy.com//forum_posts.asp?TID=1493

1. That's a nice big cure rate. I could say it is literally incredible, but then I would wouldn't I. That's such a high percentage it should be unmistakable in even the most simple of clinical trials. Oops.

2. If you were to take the claimed principles of homeopathy seriously, 70 remedies could not possibly match all the patients. It is absolutely impossible to encompass all (well, 99% of) human variation in 70 treatments. Does this engender a critical enquiry into the claim's veracity? No, only the usual cow-eyed, slack-jawed credulity.
 
Are there any substances which cause cow-eyed, slack-jawed credulity? Perhaps we could market a homeopathic remedy.
 
Martin said:
Are there any substances which cause cow-eyed, slack-jawed credulity?

No, I don't think substances are required. I think it's in the Nature of those doing it, Nurtured by whatever pseudo-college they attended.

Sibling marriage might be a risk factor of course, so should we ask whether homeopaths derive from areas with long winters and poor transport links?
 
Huntsman said:
Perhaps if we diluted a remedy made from the ashes of a cremated homeopath?

Cremated homeopath? I thought they were immortal thanks to the supernatural power of homeopathy.
 
Huntsman said:
Perhaps if we diluted a remedy made from the ashes of a cremated homeopath?
I think he's talking about Kumar's little obsession.

Rolfe.
 
Badly Shaved Monkey said:
Never mind the 2500, or whatever it is, proved remedies. ....
Yes, and that's another point. Have they ever tried to prove a substance and said, well, that one does absolutely nothing at all?

Of course not.

Positronium, a latex condom, Welsh slate, you name it, it produces symptoms in a proving. Anybody else think this is highly implausible? Real medicine, now, drug companies spend millions testing out promising compounds, then have to write off the money when either it turns out that the hoped-for effect isn't showing up, or there are undesirable side-effects that make the product unusable.

But homoeopaths, they just dilute'n'shake anything that takes their fancy, and hey presto, instant healing, instant revenue! Of course it must be quite convenient not actually having to prove efficacy or anything like that.

Rolfe.
 
Homeoskeptic said:
Well, the thing is that it sure as hell works for all our patients though doesn't it!!

But that's the really funny thing isn't it? The acolyte whose comments form the basis of this thread claim 99% of patients cured by just 70 remedies. That's not very individualised is it? How come homeopathy does not achieve perfect cures in 99% of patients when individualised remedies are compared against placebo?

This is another one of the glaring inconsistencies that you don't even seem to understand, never mind deal with.
 
Re: Re: 2500 to 70

Rolfe said:
Yes, and that's another point. Have they ever tried to prove a substance and said, well, that one does absolutely nothing at all?

Of course not.

Positronium, a latex condom, Welsh slate, you name it, it produces symptoms in a proving. Anybody else think this is highly implausible?

I never realised drug discovery could be so easy, but what if a random piece of peregrine falcon could make you feel all floaty and like you're flying. woo..wooo..woooo

Let's take a bit and find out....


http://www.hominf.org/falc/falcintr.htm


◊◊◊◊ me, it works. Amazing.


Now, for the homeopathic proving of bovine faecal material, I am going to waft a bottle of water beneath the image on my screen of a page from Hpathy..................................... Dilute it a couple of hundred times with more water. Give it a little shake each time. Next, has anyone got the number for Boiron, so I can get this onto the market.
 
Homeoskeptic (better known as Naturalheath) said:
Well, the thing is that it sure as hell works for all our patients though doesn't it!!
Prove it.

As I'm tired of saying, given the allegedly dramatic and self-evident "cures" you lot boast about, it should be a piece of cake to demonstrate an effect in a controlled trial. This is the sort of trial that's capable of showing up some quite subtle effects, things not even suspected on an anecdotal basis, but evident once the proper statistics are done.

But hell, for something this great, you shouldn't even need the statistics! All you have to do is show that a group of people who got their individualised remedy, on average, did better than a comparable group of people who only thought they got their prescribed remedy. Funny nobody can find a damn thing as soon as all participants are blinded to who took what, isn't it?

Well, no funnier than the hordes of people that were persuaded that Perkins' tractors worked, or any one of the innumerable quack cures that have come and gone over the centuries.

(BTW, the stock answer to this, as patented by Bach, is that you're trying to measure weight with a ruler and that if the scientific controlled trial can't find any effect of homoeopathic remedies, then it must be the trial that's at fault, because it's quite inconceivable that you lot are a bunch of quacks and fraudsters. Next, please?)

Rolfe.
 
Huntsman said:
Actually, I was trying to think of a homeopathic remedy for homeopathy :D
Well, yes, that too, but you do know that Kumar's obsessed with the Tissue Remedies homoeopathic system, which is something to do with drawing unwarranted and highly quacky conclusions from an 1870s analysis of whole-body crematorium ash?

Rolfe.
 
Badly Shaved Monkey said:

Sibling marriage might be a risk factor of course, so should we ask whether homeopaths derive from areas with long winters and poor transport links?

My sister and our 12 children take great exception to you denigrating comments on our relationship and reliance on Homeopathy! We have been almost completely satisfied with our experiences, the one possible exception being the Homeopathic birth control.:p
 
Rolfe said:
Positronium, a latex condom, Welsh slate, you name it, it produces symptoms in a proving. Anybody else think this is highly implausible? Real medicine, now, drug companies spend millions testing out promising compounds, then have to write off the money when either it turns out that the hoped-for effect isn't showing up, or there are undesirable side-effects that make the product unusable.
And don't forget alcohol! I've done an alcohol proving, and I am now selling a homeopathic treatment for dehydration. It turned out that the best carrier was water, interestingly enough. Want to become one of my reps?

~~ Paul
 
Given that the standard homoeopathic solvent appears to be an alcohol/water mixture (proportions unstated, and while we're at it what does that do to the alleged memory of "water"), this one simply boggles my mind.

But Naturalhealth tells us that alcohol is a proven homoeopathic remedy and who are we to contradict her. However, if the proving was conducted on ultramolar potencies, as is their habit, it's entirely possible that inebriation, pink elephants and hangovers appear nowhere in the repertorisation.

Rolfe.
 
Rolfe said:
Given that the standard homoeopathic solvent appears to be an alcohol/water mixture (proportions unstated, and while we're at it what does that do to the alleged memory of "water"), this one simply boggles my mind.
Rolfe.
Hmm ... Maybe water's memory improves when mixed with alcohol?

I have the opposite experience myself, however. :) More testing is needed!
 
Since when have I ever said that alcohol was a homeopathic remedy? It can be given, however, its use is not homeopathic, but is however isopathic. There is a difference.

Also, remedies are normally made with distilled water and Vodka is used as a preservative. I normally make up my own LM potencies as per the instructions in the Organon. I use a little Vodka and then fill with distilled water and all these remedies work perfectly.

Actually, alcohol is not needed at all and water will do on its own just as well. I have made up LM's with just water and no alcohol, but this does not matter, as a patient on LM's will get through the remedy quicker anyway, as they are taking it on a daily basis.
 
Badly Shaved Monkey said:


But that's the really funny thing isn't it? The acolyte whose comments form the basis of this thread claim 99% of patients cured by just 70 remedies. That's not very individualised is it? How come homeopathy does not achieve perfect cures in 99% of patients when individualised remedies are compared against placebo?

This is another one of the glaring inconsistencies that you don't even seem to understand, never mind deal with.

Perhaps we'll treat you with some seriousness after you deal with big problems like this one or accept or resolve the many problems presented by provings. Until then, your wishful views of the effectiveness of homeopathy do not count for very much.

Moth, candle. Candle, moth. I smell your wings burning already.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom