2-27-12 Another high school shooting.

3.98 gun homicides per 100k in USA (2001)
0.15 gun homicides per 100k in England/Wales (2002)
0.06 gun homicides per 100k in Scotland (2002)

Gun control works. Anyone who says differently is trying to sell you a gun.


5.24 gun homicides per 100k in Northern Ireland (with laws similar to England)

0.76 gun homicides per 100k in Canada (with laws similar to the USA)


Culture and enforcement of the laws play a huge part as well.
 
Last edited:
I call it sensationalism when they report on these incidents with such a magnitude of depth. It becomes a national news incident immediately with sometimes hundreds of reporters converging on the scene and a cycle of week long reports attempting to give as much detail as can possibly be gleaned. It's not exactly an over hyped portrayal of what happened, but it is an over hyped level of coverage. Perhaps the distinction makes it wrong to call it sensationalism, but I think it is.

Sensationalism or not, I think the behavior is encouraged by this. It becomes a shocking sort of social event unto itself with an air about it which causes it to seem like something that we expect to see happening again, it becomes a sort of common man made disaster, akin to a tornado or forest fire with elements of drama and soap opera hybridized into the incident.

Just as with running amok, or the Chinese knife wielding attackers, or postal workers killing everyone in their workplace, these incidents are something akin to a cultural tradition almost, or rather a psychological tradition, marking a point or frame of mind that may possibly even be natural in our species in a sense (akin to infanticide during post partem depression), a form of nervous break down triggered by certain stresses. And these acts are how they think they should behave when that point arises in those predisposed to acting on this bizarre urge.

It really does seem that many cultures have a well known act that certain people do when they "snap". I hesitate to call it a tradition, but it seems the closest thing in my mind to compare it to.
Good points. I'd add that part of making such a social artifact can be the media's sensationalizing such things beyond the point needed to simply report the news.
End result seems to be that when someone is considering options they may go with one that has a higher profile.
 
I think most of us foreigners have sympathy for the kids and families involved, and feel dismay to see another of these.

That was my initial reaction too (my second reaction was to be reminded of a school shooting in germany). I am not even sure why this thread suddenly went south with "US vs the world".
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom