2-27-12 Another high school shooting.

I think the big difference is that this incident was not carried out by a school child, but by an adult. And that is the only school shooting in Britain that I'm aware of. It was much more similar to the Michael Ryan and Derrick Bird incidents, where adult gunmen went on the rampage, than a classic "school shooting" in the US mould.

These three incidents are the only gun rampages I know about, ever. The first one was over 25 years ago.

The phenomenon of a school pupil taking a firearm to their own school and opening fire does seem to me to be a particularly US thing.

Rolfe.
Well, they couldn't put it on TV if it wasn't true, right?

However, they can lump 20 and 21 year old gang member who haven't been inside a classroom in years, and shootings during crimes within a 1 mile radius of any school, and kids who bring guns to school to show off, which then are mishandled, and use these incidents to incessantly replay the handful of actual schoolyard shooting sprees over, and over, and over, and over, while intoning how horrible this epidemic is.

Meanwhile in China, the cases of older men coming into elementary schools and slashing up the children keeps growing to the point where psychologists are studying it as a possible syndrome.

http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/asia-pacific/8653827.stm
 
However, they can lump 20 and 21 year old gang member who haven't been inside a classroom in years, and shootings during crimes within a 1 mile radius of any school, and kids who bring guns to school to show off, which then are mishandled, and use these incidents to incessantly replay the handful of actual schoolyard shooting sprees over, and over, and over, and over, while intoning how horrible this epidemic is.

However, the media does not actually do this. Gun violence that happens to occur in or at a school which is considered to be an extension of gang or drug violence is almost never associated by the media with manic shooting sprees such as this one.
 
Meanwhile in China, the cases of older men coming into elementary schools and slashing up the children keeps growing to the point where psychologists are studying it as a possible syndrome.

http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/asia-pacific/8653827.stm


That's much more comparable to what happened at Dunblane, although of course Hamilton had guns. There was also an incident in England where an adult man did exactly that, went on a slashing spree in a primary school with a machete. The teacher was awarded a medal for bravery, but it's hard to find reports about it because nobody was killed.

It's the phenomenon of boys (nearly always boys I think) who are actually pupils at the school or left only very recently going on a school rampage with a gun that seems particularly American.

Rolfe.
 
However, the media does not actually do this. Gun violence that happens to occur in or at a school which is considered to be an extension of gang or drug violence is almost never associated by the media with manic shooting sprees such as this one.
Horsecrap. Did you even read the link?The media lives by the rule of senationalizing things to the max.
 
Regardless of whatever "rule" the media lives by, it remains a fact that gang-related shootings at schools are rarely reported on with the same atmosphere as shooting sprees. Even the community's reaction is different; school is still open the next day, law enforcement does not hold press conferences for the next several days, and so forth.
 
For what it's worth, gun violence is gun violence. It's not "sensationalism" if the incidents are accurately reported.
 
Yes, 'going out in a blaze of glory' is now firmly associated in the popular culture with taking a gun to school.

You know, as one of the people who should have been prime "idolizing the school shooters" fodder, (disenfranchised, oddball highschool student, who was rather mercilessly teased on just about every aspect of my personality.) my friends and i could just never jump on the bandwagon for one simple reason.

The school shooters weren't evening up any scales, they wern't righting wrongs, or even getting revenge on those who wronged them, they were just going out by being the ultimate example of the kind of people the supposedly hated, someone who spewed random hatred because they wanted power.

And that always bugged me whenever similar minded folks praised their actions. This wasn't some Falling Down esque situation, where their targets were scum, but receiving over the top punishments, these ******** killed anyone, they just wanted to kill. And to put a point on it, these knobs , much like hitler ruined his mustache, ruined looking spooky for about a decade. Their only effect on those who praised them was to make their lives just a bit more crap, by giving the world another thing to call them, and creating a panic, that could get any kid not wearing campus crew and nike hassled at the drop of a hat.

I support vigilantism, from a pragmatic standpoint ( the social premise that just maybe that person you are treating like ****, or harming may just toss aside social repercussions , is a great limiter of dick moves, be they small or large scale.), but the problem is, i have yet to see an example of it, that isn't just the person succumbing to an already existent bloodlust, mental instability, or petty revenge.

There is a vigilante i could stand behind, but to the best of my knowledge , that person has yet to exist.
 
It's the phenomenon of boys (nearly always boys I think) who are actually pupils at the school or left only very recently going on a school rampage with a gun that seems particularly American.

It has happened in other countries, but there are probably several social factors that make it more common in the US. The primary reason may be that it's easier for a teen to acquire firearms here than in the rest of the developed world.
 
On a related issue, is there any evidence that school lockdowns protect students?

Common sense dictates that students barricaded in a classroom can't be shot by a gunman roaming the halls; at least not easily. When there's been a shooting, there's really no reason not to lockdown until its verified the shooter isn't still walking around the building.

...unless you can come up with one?
 
Last edited:
Common sense dictates that students barricaded in a classroom can't be shot by a gunman roaming the halls; at least not easily. When there's been a shooting, there's really no reason not to lockdown until its verified the shooter isn't still walking around the building.

...unless you can come up with one?

The other side of the coin is that locked doors make it hard to run away from the gunman. And that doesn't even consider what might happen if a fire is started. They are locking doors that are never supposed to be locked while the building is occupied.
 
http://news.blogs.cnn.com/2012/02/27/shooting-reported-at-ohio-high-school/?hpt=hp_t1

I wonder what the rest of the world think of the US when they see events such as this on the news.
If we think anything at all, it's that you reap what you sow when you feed your kids Ritalin and Prozac like candy and then give them access to guns. :boxedin:

Seriously, this kind of stuff doesn't look good to the ROTW, America.

Gun control, we like that here in the UK, as regular readers of this forum will know.
 
The other side of the coin is that locked doors make it hard to run away from the gunman. And that doesn't even consider what might happen if a fire is started. They are locking doors that are never supposed to be locked while the building is occupied.

The fire code mandates that all locked doors in public buildings, including schools, be able to open from the inside while locked. It is only the case that people outside the door cannot get in. So if there was a fire, or if a teacher for some bizarre reason locks the door while the gunman is inside their classroom, escapes can be made with no problem whatsoever. It's not an issue.
 
If we think anything at all, it's that you reap what you sow when you feed your kids Ritalin and Prozac like candy and then give them access to guns. :boxedin:

Seriously, this kind of stuff doesn't look good to the ROTW, America.

Gun control, we like that here in the UK, as regular readers of this forum will know.

3.98 gun homicides per 100k in USA (2001)
0.15 gun homicides per 100k in England/Wales (2002)
0.06 gun homicides per 100k in Scotland (2002)

Gun control works. Anyone who says differently is trying to sell you a gun.
 
For what it's worth, gun violence is gun violence. It's not "sensationalism" if the incidents are accurately reported.

I call it sensationalism when they report on these incidents with such a magnitude of depth. It becomes a national news incident immediately with sometimes hundreds of reporters converging on the scene and a cycle of week long reports attempting to give as much detail as can possibly be gleaned. It's not exactly an over hyped portrayal of what happened, but it is an over hyped level of coverage. Perhaps the distinction makes it wrong to call it sensationalism, but I think it is.

Sensationalism or not, I think the behavior is encouraged by this. It becomes a shocking sort of social event unto itself with an air about it which causes it to seem like something that we expect to see happening again, it becomes a sort of common man made disaster, akin to a tornado or forest fire with elements of drama and soap opera hybridized into the incident.

Just as with running amok, or the Chinese knife wielding attackers, or postal workers killing everyone in their workplace, these incidents are something akin to a cultural tradition almost, or rather a psychological tradition, marking a point or frame of mind that may possibly even be natural in our species in a sense (akin to infanticide during post partem depression), a form of nervous break down triggered by certain stresses. And these acts are how they think they should behave when that point arises in those predisposed to acting on this bizarre urge.

It really does seem that many cultures have a well known act that certain people do when they "snap". I hesitate to call it a tradition, but it seems the closest thing in my mind to compare it to.
 
Last edited:
The fire code mandates that all locked doors in public buildings, including schools, be able to open from the inside while locked. It is only the case that people outside the door cannot get in. So if there was a fire, or if a teacher for some bizarre reason locks the door while the gunman is inside their classroom, escapes can be made with no problem whatsoever. It's not an issue.

I have heard of local cases where exit doors were chained during lockdowns.
 
3.98 gun homicides per 100k in USA (2001)
0.15 gun homicides per 100k in England/Wales (2002)
0.06 gun homicides per 100k in Scotland (2002)

Gun control works. Anyone who says differently is trying to sell you a gun.
It does work. And we like it, don't we, Skepticemea?

Yes, we have some knife crime in our big cities here in the UK, - but without wanting to state the bleedin' obvious - the difference is if you want to kill someone with a knife you have to get really close to them and make some stabbing actions. It takes a bit more effort and determination than pointing a loaded gun at someone and pulling a trigger.
 
As Halfcentaur said. I did a bit of research and found there were a couple of "mass killings"
in the US back earlier in history, in both cases no reporting to speak of outside of local papers.
When Charles Whitman did his Texas Tower thing in '66, it was not only covered live by local news, but became a huge cultural sensation. Songs were written ( Harry Chapin's "Sniper" for one) and the incident became a cultural "meme" which lives on today.
Now, it seems to resonate with all manner of desperate people.

Yes, Whitman seems to be the first incident here in the US that I can think of which made this a sort of element of pop culture. Meme also works to describe this sort of thing better than tradition I think.
 
I have heard of local cases where exit doors were chained during lockdowns.

Well, those are what they are; I can't say anything about them. In the traditional sense of merely pulling all children out of hallways into classrooms and locking the doors, lockdowns are pretty unassailable.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom