My favorite YouTuber on humanoid evolution,
Kaleigh, just posted a video on the evolution of language. A tad outside her wheelhouse, but her video is nicely centered on her particular specialty, focusing on the timing of language emergence and the probable species. Still, thought I'd check back with my go-to expert on languages and linguistics to get her take. I think
JuLingo wins this one, and think her scenario toward the end is pretty spot on.
Not sure I agree with Chomsky's idea that language emerged with a single individual as a whole skill via genetic mutation. Highly unlikely, especially since there isn't one single gene involved (FOXP2 isn't the only one). Much more probable that our direct ancestors started it all (ie, use of a complex symbolic system), H. Erectus being in fact a real champ at most of the tools we used to survive and prosper, and was the longest to reign supreme. In short, a combo of the two analyses would be my take.
Of all the examples given by JuLingo of animal communication, the most impressive is that of the parrot, not a primate, and that is my tidbit for today.