Dr. Phil Show Showcases Psychics

Thanks for the kind words and research rjh. I wasn't invited on, but they wanted me to find families who would go on the show. Their research on us was either non-existent or close, otherwise they'd know our ethics would clearly rule out an appearance on a pro-psychic show of any sort.

Shows the quality of the show. If they cannot do such basic checks then the guests on the show could be anyone. That would be fun. Have someone on the show claiming to be x and then afterwards reveal that they are not x and any basic check would show that. Only is this fraud? Could it be done without it being fraud?
 
I'm tempted to email them and tell them to invite Shawn Hornbeck's family on to discuss Sylvia Browne's "success".
 
Psychics are low life slime who like to receive dogs internally(IYGMM). So are the evil tirds who give them time in media other than pointing out their lies, mistakes and generally skewering them with prejudice.
 
The other alternative is to interview the people after they appear on the show. Find out what they thought. Then put the answers on some website. Were their missing relatives found? Or maybe talk to them beforehand. Give them bingo cards.


Edit. They can floor everyone during the show when one of them yells "BINGO".
 
Email sent.

"Re: Psychics and Missing People

I suggest that you include Kelly Jolkowski's reply to your associate producer in your upcoming show.

I quote it in full:

<snip Kelly's email>

===
It would be very biased of you to produce a show about this issue and not include the other side of the argument (which has all the truth, morality and evidence on its side).

No psychic has ever solved a missing persons case. Instead, they take money from and give false hope to vulnerable people.

It would make Dr Phil look incredibly gullible and heartless if he recommended missing people's loved ones sought help from psychics."
 
Kelly! Nice to see you back no matter the unfortunate circumstances. I figure they aren't going to do much beyond tally the pros and cons so I kept mine short and sweet bitter.

I understand you are having psychics on your October 15th program. I object in the strongest possible terms. There is no such thing as a psychic and those who claim to be one and to help find missing children do untold damage to parents, friends, law enforcement and others.

You are aiding and abetting that damage. Have you no shame?
 
Well done Kelly. Shame that ratings are more highly considered than the feeling of thos who have missing loved ones.
Hugs!
 
It's so good to see you back here! I've had a little respect for the good Doctor in the past. It has just evaporated.

ETA: Here is what I sent the show:

I am extremely disappointed that Dr. McGraw, who often cites science in his advice, has chosen to follow pseudoscience in conjunction with missing people. These so-called "psychics" are most often predators preying on the weak and defenseless. When they are not predators, they are self-deluded. Please take a look at this link and reconsider your decision: http://whatstheharm.net/psychics.html.
 
Last edited:
Here ya go. Typos and all....


Nongprue, Pattaya, Chonburri, Thailand
12 October 2012

Dear Staff of Dr. Phil Show,

I understand that you folks recently inadvertently contacted Kelly Jolkowski of Project Jason, thinking she'd be a good source of psychic-fodder for an upcoming show on psychics. (If you did not intend to pander to their nonsense, I apologize for leaping to conclusions, but the show's previous history seems to indicate you're leaning that way.)

I know you've heard from a few of us - we're a limited skeptical community and Ms. Jolkowski, in spite of living through the unthinkable (to me) horror of dealing with a missing child, has done some rather terrific work in countering the evils that these people do. And if you'd have taken the time to research her organization, I think you'd possibly agree - they are evil. The exploit grieving families at the most vulnerable times imaginable.

Now, in addition to being a skeptic, I'm a bit of a pragmatist. You guys have to for ratings. I mean, may Oprah forbid that Dr. Phil loses his vaunted #1 in category rating for even a day, so you're going to go ahead with selling this pap to the masses. But, why don't you consider a real OSDP (old school Dr. Phil) story. You guys remember when he was the darling of the networks because he actually cared about people? Read up on Kelly and Project Jason. Check out what she's actually doing for the families to assist them. Now that'd be a helluva show. Hell, Dr. Phil's one of the best chicken-soup-for-the-soul type councilors out there. Maybe he could get involved in this great cause and do some good. It'd be nice to see THAT Dr. Phil again.

Sincerely,
 
I am so, so "feeling the love" of my JREF family. There have been many times over the years when I've been attacked by these predators, but I didn't want to come running for help each time. This time, it was a full assault on the families, so I felt compelled to ask for your assistance and you delivered.

Orphia, Chill, Garrette, Tim, SezMe, Library Lady, and all, I do miss you more than you will know. This place was very hard for me to give up, so to speak. I could say "You can take the girl out of JREF, but you can't take JREF out of the girl." :cool:

Foolmewunz, your letter touched me with it's message.

Thank you all again.
 
Absolutely sickening. I just sent the following:

Dr. Phil,

I just read that you are going to have psychics on a show related to missing persons that is airing on October 15th.

I would expect something this awful from Montel Williams or Jerry Springer but not from a therapist who should feel an obligation to care for the mental well-being of people who are suffering. Instead you are bringing predators on the show who add tremendously to the misery of people with missing family members by giving them false hope. These creatures also waste valuable time and resources during missing person investigations by sending police and other searchers on wild goose chases.

Perhaps some people aren't smart enough, educated enough, or wise enough to know that psychic abilities do not exist, however you should be.

Everyone at your show should hang their heads in shame if you air this program. This is an utter and complete disgrace.
 
Absolutely sickening. I just sent the following:

Dr. Phil,

I just read that you are going to have psychics on a show related to missing persons that is airing on October 15th.

I would expect something this awful from Montel Williams or Jerry Springer but not from a therapist who should feel an obligation to care for the mental well-being of people who are suffering. Instead you are bringing predators on the show who add tremendously to the misery of people with missing family members by giving them false hope. These creatures also waste valuable time and resources during missing person investigations by sending police and other searchers on wild goose chases.

Perhaps some people aren't smart enough, educated enough, or wise enough to know that psychic abilities do not exist, however you should be.

Everyone at your show should hang their heads in shame if you air this program. This is an utter and complete disgrace.

Good angle, Vic with the responsibility of the therapist in question.

I'm pondering writing them again and asking if they're enjoying the letters...just deciding how to phrase it, if I do.

Thanks!
 
Good angle, Vic with the responsibility of the therapist in question.

I'm pondering writing them again and asking if they're enjoying the letters...just deciding how to phrase it, if I do.

Thanks!

You could just send them a link to this thread. There's probably more said in here than you could put in any single message, plus it includes copies of everything that everyone's sent and your own explanation and commentary.
 
Inspired by Foolmewunz...

I just heard about your upcoming show on psychics and missing children, for which you made the mistake of contacting Kelly Jolkowski of Project Jason. I know you've received a number of emails expressing disappointment that you're giving air-time to psychics who claim to find missing kids, so rather than merely adding my voice to that chorus, I also have a suggestion: after the show has aired, do a follow-up show on missing kids from Project Jason's perspective. Let them explain their strategies for helping families, their reasons for their position on psychics, and what they consider more helpful alternatives. Consider it an opportunity to exceed expectations and do something other than the tired old formula of a pro-paranormal episode with 45 seconds grudgingly given to a token skeptic near the end, for the purpose of giving the audience someone to boo.

Kelly, it's good to see you back here. I selfishly hope that the positive responses you've gotten will rekindle your addiction to this place.
 
I'm not terribly optimistic, but certainly worth a shot:

me said:
It has come to my attention that you are planning to do a show Monday, Oct. 15, promoting the use of psychics to help in cases of missing persons. I strongly urge you to reconsider.

There is no reason to believe that so-called "psychics" have any ability to help locate missing persons. There is every reason to believe the only ability they have is to delude people - including themselves often enough - and bring about real harm.

The harm should the psychic's guesses be believed, of diverting searchers' time and efforts from useful clues, is, of course, very real; the harm, emotional and financial, when families become dependent on a psychic's messages of false hope and bogus information, is, of course, very real; the harm by doing this show, of advertising these sociopaths as legitimate options for vulnerable families, is, of course, very real.

But, so is the potential for good a show like yours could do by exposing them.

Please, for the sake of all the families out there who will surely be harmed by it, do not do this show. Run a rerun or something instead Monday. Then get in touch with projectjason.org and the James Randi Educational Foundation: there are plenty of folks here ready and willing to work with you to put together a show on the reality of missing persons and the dangers posed to them by psychic predators. Wouldn't that be a great show, and wouldn't that do some real good for these families, instead of the harm the show you're planning is sure to do.

I think these families have suffered enough. Please choose good over harm.

p.s. Because I have exactly as much psychic ability as the psychics you have invited to your show, I am going to make a bold prediction: that, in spite of this email and others condemning it, you will go ahead with the show. Please prove me wrong. :)
 

Back
Top Bottom