Reality Check
Penultimate Amazing
What is your evidence for a difference in dark/bright filament eruption distribution
Lots of things that are quoted and so are your own personal words:
But there is a serious question:
Michael Mozina
First asked 2 Oct 2010
You seem to be asserting that
!).
Thats funny - I see plenty of bright filaments in SDO images. But that is the danger of "I see bunnies in the clouds": someone else may be doing "I see fairies in the clouds"
.
Well, that is PART of their value, sure. The other part of the equation is that the "dark" filaments are the ones that "erupt" anywhere from the surface, whereas the "bright" filaments tend to be concentrated around "active regions" and only "circuit reconnection" causes them to blow.
Lots of things that are quoted and so are your own personal words:
- What does "erupt" mean?
- What does "active regions" mean?
- What does "circuit reconnection" mean?
I hope this is not the same thing that discussed in the Plasma Cosmology - Woo or not thread.
But there is a serious question:
Michael Mozina
First asked 2 Oct 2010
You seem to be asserting that
- filament eruptions for dark filaments happen anywhere on the solar disk.
- filament eruptions for bright filaments tend to happen around active regions.
The definition of a dark filament is that it appears dark in some wavelengths against the body of the Sun. So you are using the term in the correct way (no need for quotesIf I can't watch it real time as a 'bright' filament, can you really blame me for calling it a "dark filament" to at least note it's visual quality which makes it unique?
Thats funny - I see plenty of bright filaments in SDO images. But that is the danger of "I see bunnies in the clouds": someone else may be doing "I see fairies in the clouds"
Last edited:
!