• Quick note - the problem with Youtube videos not embedding on the forum appears to have been fixed, thanks to ZiprHead. If you do still see problems let me know.

Banned Book:The Hoax of the Twentieth Century

Status
Not open for further replies.
I can't remember exactly who said it, and this isn't an exact quote, I'm paraphrasing here, but I can tell you it's from the book "Auschwitz" by Laurence Rees. The quote was from a general, I can't remember if he was American or British, who was personally involved in the liberation of the camps.

I think this is the most apt statements I have ever heard regarding Holocaust denial:

"The Holocaust is one of the most witnessed and documented events in the whole of human history. If one is to claim that the Holocuast is not true, than nothing in history can be claimed to be true."
 
With the matter of the holocaust films I stand by what I wrote. Before the "Holocaust" mini series, that is 1945-1977, you'd be hard pressed to come up with a dozen titles. ( I was referring to Hollywood and other US productions so European movies such as The Night Porter don't count). After publication of Did Six Million Really Die? www.zundelsite.org/harwood/didsix00.html and The Hoax of the Twentieth Century http://vho.org/GB/Books/thottc/ and the resultant attention given to holocaust revisionists there was the "Holocaust" mini series in 1978 and since then there have been hundreds of holocaust films and there is no end in sight. Why aren't there hundreds of movies about the mass murderers Lenin, Trotsky, Stalin, Mao and Pol Pot? Why is the suffering of Jews supposed to be more important than the suffering of anyone else? The holocaust propaganda is used to try and stifle the work of holocaust revisionists (www.codoh.com) and is also used to deflect attention away from and criticism of Israeli war crimes and crimes against humanity (www.deiryassin.org)
 
Mondial said:
With the matter of the holocaust films I stand by what I wrote. Before the "Holocaust" mini series, that is 1945-1977, you'd be hard pressed to come up with a dozen titles. ( I was referring to Hollywood and other US productions so European movies such as The Night Porter don't count).
Click to expand...

How much do those goal posts weigh?
 
Mondial said:
With the matter of the holocaust films I stand by what I wrote. Before the "Holocaust" mini series, that is 1945-1977, you'd be hard pressed to come up with a dozen titles.
Click to expand...

this is NOT...what you wrote. do you know what it means, to move goalposts?

"There were no holocaust movies in the 1940's, 50's or 60's and then circa 1974 'Did Six Million Really Die?' was published."
 
Last edited:
Mondial said:
With the matter of the holocaust films I stand by what I wrote. Before the "Holocaust" mini series, that is 1945-1977, you'd be hard pressed to come up with a dozen titles.
Click to expand...

None, dozen, not six million... numbers really aren't your strong suit, are they?

Mondial said:
there was the "Holocaust" mini series in 1978 and since then there have been hundreds of holocaust films and there is no end in sight.
Click to expand...

Hundreds? I gave you this Wikipedia link earlier. Can you find hundreds of post-1978 Hollywood Holocaust films in there? I'll even let you count films like Valkyrie, even though there's nary a word about the Holocaust in it. Hell, you can even add one to the total because the list doesn't include Inglourious Basterds.

In case 'hundred' is a foreign concept to you, it's the same as the total number of the fingers and toes of five pre-war SS men.
 
Last edited:
Mondial said:
There were no holocaust movies in the 1940's, 50's or 60's
Click to expand...

Mondial said:
With the matter of the holocaust films I stand by what I wrote. Before the "Holocaust" mini series, that is 1945-1977, you'd be hard pressed to come up with a dozen titles.
Click to expand...

That's some impressive goal post moving. Keep it up! It's one sure fire way to be respected around here.
 
Mondial said:
in 1978 and since then there have been hundreds of holocaust films and there is no end in sight.
Click to expand...

How are chances of seeing the evidence that Hollywood has produced hundreds of holocaust movies since 1978?


ETA: I think we can all agree that some Jews were sent to camps in the early 1940's. Here's a quick question, Mondial, what did those Jews do to deserve being sent to camps?
 
Last edited:
ddt said:
How much do those goal posts weigh?
Click to expand...

You know what, i will do everyone a favor and post all of the rest of this thread in fast forward.

There were no films, there was maybe less than a dozen films, the films were propaganda.

The book is banned, the book is hard to get , the book i symbolically banned.

Holocaust deniers are harassed by evil jews, holocaust deniers are ridiculed by mainstream media, holocaust deniers are not respected enough.

Now everyone has an extra hour or so in their life, you can thank me via pm.
 
Bob Blaylock said:
When people are subjected to murder, physical assault, arson attacks, intimidation, censorship and imprisonment for expressing a belief or opinion with which you agree, then perhaps you'll understand.
Click to expand...

Well, to be fair, I don't actually think murder, assault, arson, censorship or imprisonment are appropriate for holocaust deniers. Being regarded as somewhat more disgusting than the stuff you scrape off your shoes after walking through a barn that hasn't been cleaned recently is.
 
Ladewig said:
How are chances of seeing the evidence that Hollywood has produced hundreds of holocaust movies since 1978?


ETA: I think we can all agree that some Jews were sent to camps in the early 1940's. Here's a quick question, Mondial, what did those Jews do to deserve being sent to camps?
Click to expand...

As near as I can figure, the position of holocaust deniers is that, rather than being a monster who murdered 6 million Jews, Hitler's a really nice guy who imprisoned several million Jews for no reason and murdered a mere few hundred thousand of them.
 
Mondial said:
Why aren't there hundreds of movies about the mass murderers Lenin, Trotsky, Stalin, Mao and Pol Pot?
Click to expand...
I thought this was answered already. Americans fought in WWII and were heroes to those they helped liberate. Of course they're going to focus on that story -- it was a moment of glory, saving people from the monstrous Nazis. It's not anyone else's fault that the Nazis played the part of monsters so well.

The Nazis became classic modern examples of how people can be incited to mad, inhuman actions by a sociopathic leader. No one claims that this is the only time this ever happened. Of course many other leaders and regimes were horrible as well, but this doesn't erase the example of the Nazis.
 
Mondial said:
With the matter of the holocaust films I stand by what I wrote. Before the "Holocaust" mini series, that is 1945-1977, you'd be hard pressed to come up with a dozen titles. ( I was referring to Hollywood and other US productions so European movies such as The Night Porter don't count). After publication of Did Six Million Really Die? ****** and The Hoax of the Twentieth Century ****** and the resultant attention given to holocaust revisionists there was the "Holocaust" mini series in 1978 and since then there have been hundreds of holocaust films and there is no end in sight. Why aren't there hundreds of movies about the mass murderers Lenin, Trotsky, Stalin, Mao and Pol Pot? Why is the suffering of Jews supposed to be more important than the suffering of anyone else? The holocaust propaganda is used to try and stifle the work of holocaust revisionists and is also used to deflect attention away from and criticism of Israeli war crimes and crimes against humanity *****
Click to expand...


****** asterisks denote book-burning - I deleted your reprehensible links. Now you have more censorship to whine about. (I refuse to repeat those links as it's quite obvious that that's the only reason you're maintaining this fiasco of an argument line - to keep including links in the hopes that you'll suck in some other confused angry young man. That's the thing with all these discussions on the intertubes. Where goest the defenders of Zundel or apologists for Adolf, so goest the links to the HD and white supremacist sites.)

As to the meat (and I do use that term loosely) of your post, sorry, but it doesn't work like that. Are you just another xenophobic American so only American films count? That's ridiculous. Why shouldn't we count the Polish films? They suffered more under the nazis than any country other than Russia (and arguably, Germany, itself). Why shouldn't we count British films? Weren't the part of the JFA (Jewboy Financed Alliance) that deprived that nice man and his party from the rightful position in history as the masters of the universe? How about France? They're in the west. Their films don't count, either? Italy? Germany?

Even if we allowed you the moving of the goalposts, let's throw down the second challenge. List for us the "hundreds of holocaust films" since 1978.

Or did you mean 1978 in base 4? Or maybe you meant 1978 according to the Chinese calendar? What other convenient dodge are you going to come up with, next.

You're just copying crap over from dubious web sites, aren't you? You don't actually know a thing about the topic that you haven't gotten from some (other) frothing at the mouth racist on a hate site, right?
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

Back
Top Bottom