• Quick note - the problem with Youtube videos not embedding on the forum appears to have been fixed, thanks to ZiprHead. If you do still see problems let me know.

Please give evidence for all religions except Christianity

Doc, I agree with the others who think that it would probably be a lot more effective if you started this thread in another forum, and perhaps linked to it from here. The number of religious members of this forum is very low. Most of us can, at most, give devil's advocate arguments for various religions. Also, those arguments are likely to be restated versions of the arguments you have given for christianity. You will be much more likely to get earnest replies if you find some forum for religious people and ask your question there. I would very much like to see what responses your OP would get.
 
DOC said:
There is no religion X it is something you just made up. Give a real religion similar to religion X other than Christianity, because this thread is about all religions other than Christianity.
Click to expand...

If x doesn't exist, as you claim, then you should be able to disprove my evidence pretty easily. If you cannot disprove x then I shall add an extra proof.

6/ Someone who passed a logic course with flying colours was unable to disprove it.
 
Filippo Lippi said:
In my just over 0 posts in this thread I have shown that

1/ some people were prepared to die for religion x
2/ somebody famous believed it
3/ somebody famous said it was quite good
4/ umpteen presidents of country y believed in x
5/ I can't believe that x isn't true

Now DOC, what is wrong with my evidence?
Click to expand...

You haven't shown 1, 2, 3, 4, anywhere so your first statement is a falsehood.
 
DOC said:
What is your evidence that the Flying Spaghetti Monster exists?
Click to expand...

Evidently you haven't been creamed by his touchy goodness.
Only last night I partook of the sacrament of Fettuccine Alfredo, followed by nine bottles of Peroni.


Note to detractors, no fountains were involved in the production of said beer.
 
DOC said:
Hi, I currently have the below thread in the History and Literature forum.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=124603

In that thread which has over 14,000 posts I give some historical and other evidence why I believe Christianity is true. That thread has been closed temporarily. Until the thread is reopened I've decided to have a different thread. In this new thread I would like members of religions "other than Christianity" to give evidence why you believe your religion is true. Thanks
Click to expand...


Tomorrow, at dawn, the Aten will appear on the Eastern horizon.

I win.


DOC said:
Once again please do not post evidence for Christianity in here.
Click to expand...


Or what? Are you going to refute it? Deny that there's such a thing as christianity?

That'll end well.
 
DOC said:
What is your evidence that the Flying Spaghetti Monster exists?
Click to expand...

Thomas Jefferson brought Macaroni and Cheese to America. So are you saying that you disbelieve a great man like Thomas Jefferson? Thomas Jefferson bringing Mac 'n Cheese to America is just more evidence that the FSM is true. I should know since I know someone who took a logic course and got an 'A' in it. Yes, it may not be proof but you have to agree that it is another piece of evidence. Would you like a definition of the word evidence?
 
I am X.
I exist.
Therefore Fillipo Luppi's religion is well evidenced.
(seriously, DOC: You've managed to quite amusingly misunderstand his point)




But I must ask: Why on earth would we give evidence for a religion?
There are a lot of non-religious folk on this forum.
The next biggest group is Christians, which you've explicitly barred.

So, why would the majority of people on this board go and give you evidence for a religion they don't follow?

If you want apologetics for other religions, then I suggest you find forums for those religions and post your query there.

Remember: It's the religions making the claim. They have to support their claims. Not us. Didn't you cover burden of proof in your logic class?


and LOL @ plumjam.
 
DOC said:
Hi, I currently have the below thread in the History and Literature forum.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=124603

In that thread which has over 14,000 posts I give some historical and other evidence why I believe Christianity is true. That thread has been closed temporarily. Until the thread is reopened I've decided to have a different thread. In this new thread I would like members of religions "other than Christianity" to give evidence why you believe your religion is true. Thanks

Once again please do not post evidence for Christianity in here.
Click to expand...

Most religions have some of the truth.
The Hindus know there is a soul and have a formula to find out and I believe that none of them have all the truth.
 
Incredible double standards here DOC. Nobody has ever proved any religion, least of all you. Why is the bar set so high for religions other than xtianity?
Incidentally, seeing as you feel the need for proof of xtianity in your other thread, is it fair to assume that you lack faith? (I've not looked into the other thread, I can't see the point in watching you delude yourself further.)
 
The fact that the other thread has 14,000 posts scares me from even going there, so to reply to this thread, without reading that one...

Fillipo Lippi nailed it. That's exactly the kind of evidence you'll get for any religion. If that's good enough, any religion can be proven true. If that's not good enough, what specifically do you want?
 
Filippo Lippi said:
In my just over 0 posts in this thread I have shown that

1/ some people were prepared to die for religion x
2/ somebody famous believed it
3/ somebody famous said it was quite good
4/ umpteen presidents of country y believed in x
5/ I can't believe that x isn't true

Now DOC, what is wrong with my evidence?
Click to expand...

Hey DOC does this help?

X= xtianity/zeus/islam/judaism/seikhism or whatever other delusion you prefer.
 
Pup said:
The fact that the other thread has 14,000 posts scares me from even going there, so to reply to this thread, without reading that one...
Click to expand...

Me too, but I had to have a peek. Honestly mate, have a look at his evidence, it's hilarious.
 
edge said:
Most religions have some of the truth.
The Hindus know there is a soul and have a formula to find out and I believe that none of them have all the truth.
Click to expand...

even Law and Order on TV has some truths. They have stories ripped from the headlines!!!

Therefore, Ice-T is god.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Back
Top Bottom