• Security incident: ISF was recently accessed by intruders. Please change your password, and change it anywhere else you used it. Read more

Hokulele - kurious_kathy Book Challenge

Kathy - when people here hav questioned the suffering of sick chidren, you respond by bringing up naughty 2 year olds.

Even if I accepted that argument, can you tell me what terrible sin my niece might have commited to deserve being born without a properly functioning heart which caused her to spend the first few months of her life in terrible suffering?
 
KK:
I do not believe there is one certain response. All I can repeatedly state is God does not allow suffering for nothing, maybe he just wants us to cry out to him and receive him after we are broken and contrite? I myself am broken and that heartache is what God has used in my life to turn me around and show me my need for him.

It is pretty clear. KK is having an abusive relationship with god (god is the abuser).

I am 100% serious, and am not joking in the slightest.

The reason why I am posting this, is because you people need to change your attitudes. There is no sense in playing the rational game with an abused woman. You wouldn't start to rationally argue with a woman that is regularly abused. You wouldn't suggest a woman that is treated by her man like scum to read a philosophy book. You need to do something else. I don't know what. Help her realize that she is worth something independently of an authority figure? Try and help her solve her emotional problems?

-----

KK, I am sorry if it sounds condescending. I guess the reason it sounds condescending is because it is. But I haven't managed to think of a better way to make people see the problem.

Some people have a good relationship with god. They are inspired by the idea of god to lead a better, richer more fulfilling life on their own. Your relationship with god has made you a person that is too dependent on god. God should make you more creative,happy,fulfilled in your life, not utterly dependent on him.
 
KK said:
Hey Liz I have kept my end of the bargain


Liar. This is complete bull:rule10. Here's the set-up from the first post in this thread:

Hokulele said:
Here is a challenge to you (I offered something similar to Jesus Freak a few years ago). I will read and offer up an analysis of any and/or all the articles on Charlie's website if you read and offer up an analysis of a book of my choice. I have in mind Bart Ehrman's God's Problem: How the Bible Fails to Answer Our Most Important Question — Why We Suffer. He comes from a strong evangelistic background, and he isn't an atheist, so you shouldn't have to worry on that account.

Deal? Or aren't you open-minded enough to follow your own advice?

kurious_kathy said:
Okay I will get the audio on that book and let you know what I think after I am finished. And here are a few articles on "Evil and Suffering" for a good start to take a look and share your thoughts. http://www.alwaysbeready.com/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=48&Itemi d=69

also look at these articles too on "The Existence Of God" http://www.alwaysbeready.com/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=28&Itemi d=46

and the articles pertaining to an evaluation of "The God Who Wasn't There" http://www.alwaysbeready.com/index.php?
option=com_content&task=view&id=161&Itemid=128
I would really like it if you would take your time while examaning the evidence and tell me if you can agree on some of it or all perhaps, or just some feedback would be nice.

And as for your above questions well I have been studying a while and in the time I have grown in my understanding I have been able to discern things I believe are important insights others may not have seen clearly yet. It took me a long time to evaluate and examine Catholics and these are some of my observations that I feel it is important to share with especially people who are Catholic.


You will note that what you agreed to (you did say, "Okay") was to read and analyze the Ehrman book, not to listen to two minutes of it and say, "This is too depressing." Nobody asked you to like the book, but you agreed to read and analyze it.


If you expect me to sit down and disect every little bit of that book forget it I have other things to do with my time.


Too bad. That's what "analyze" means, and that's what you said "Okay" to. But it's okay if you want to be proved a liar. (Doesn't God have some pretty nasty things to say about liars?)

Ever heard the term garabage in garbage out? Well that's my analysis of his book, total negative garbage.


You seem to suffer from the delusion that saying something makes it so. You can't just say this is "analysis" and **poof!** it's analysis. Go back and look at what Hokulele did. She read. She quoted. She said what she thought about the passages she quoted. Then she quoted some more and said some more about what she thought about those passages.

Doesn't it make you feel ashamed that an atheist is better at living up to her word than you are?


Do you recall the terrible 2's? I think we start pretty young with bad behaviors and that is because we are born with this fallen nature do to the cruse.


Did you stone your two-year-old children when they misbehaved?
 
KK:

It is pretty clear. KK is having an abusive relationship with god (god is the abuser).

I am 100% serious, and am not joking in the slightest.

The reason why I am posting this, is because you people need to change your attitudes. There is no sense in playing the rational game with an abused woman. You wouldn't start to rationally argue with a woman that is regularly abused. You wouldn't suggest a woman that is treated by her man like scum to read a philosophy book. You need to do something else. I don't know what. Help her realize that she is worth something independently of an authority figure? Try and help her solve her emotional problems?

-----

What attitude do you mean? Rationalizing with Kathy is the point of this thread, except the challenge for her was to read the books her and Hokulele agreed upon:Kathy was supposed to read a book of Hokulele's choice and Hokulele was to read one of Kathy's choice. Now that your up to speed on this, what you see is atypical of Kathy: She stopped reading because it was depressing her.

You make sense on god abusing her, but it's a vicious cycle she repeats over and over.
Nothing works for her but to go back to godbot mode: She is afraid to leave that comfort zone. Her fear is predicated upon by god's eternal punishment and is made to believe she is worthless in the sight of god because the bible says that's what she is until she accepts Jesus. That is a very significant point: She believes herself to be worthless in the sight of god if she questions anything that questions god.

So how do you go from a point where one is wholeheartedly accepting themselves not worthy as an individual, accepting any pain and suffering as reminders from god to keep one focused on him. Not willing to think independently for herself without having fear of offending god?
 
Your claim of God being unjust is purely taken from a fallen mans perspective. If you were holy I think you would have to see it God's way but for now many are just still blinded to that reality. Can you even try to wrap your head around what holiness must mean? To me it must be absolute righteousness which cannot tolerate any evil. If Jesus is not in us then God can't even look upon us because we are covered with dirty sin which we were born into. And I'm not stating a child sinned immediately but they do show bad behaviors at a young age. Do you recall the terrible 2's? I think we start pretty young with bad behaviors and that is because we are born with this fallen nature do to the cruse. The good news is Jesus made a way to get beyond the curse so we can be reconciled to God. It's Jesus in me now that God sees do you understand?
Kathy, I think I'm actually beginning to comprehend the depth of the self-loathing that your beliefs foster in you.

Instead of arguing with God why not agree with him and try to accept him on his own terms? Your hate for him in my opinion is what is blinding many of you here on this forum.
I, for one, don't hate your god. I couldn't hate your god any more than I hate the Easter Bunny or unicorns.
 
You need to do something else. I don't know what. Help her realize that she is worth something independently of an authority figure? Try and help her solve her emotional problems?

In the many years that Kathy has been posting some people have tried being nice while others have been mean. Some have tried appealing to her emotions while others have appealed to her rationality. Some have tried arguing by analogy. Some have shared their personal experiences with God and have described the path they took away from Him. Some have tried explaining how happy they are without the God of the Bible. Some have tried to explain that non-fundamentalist Christianity can lead to a fulfilling life while others argued that agnosticism can lead to a fulfilling life.

If you or anyone else has any advice, please present it. We cannot help people that do not want help. Kathy does not want help. I hope she breaks free of her new dependancy, but in the meantime, I don't hold any hope of our helping her. Her continually returning to the JREF board must cause her pain and I believe she would be happier if she walked away from this board.
 
Bolding mine.

Confession through torture? Watch 24 much?

She sounds like an abuse victim to me. Look at all the references to suffering and repenting. Her whole cringing attitude is evidence.
 
I, for one, don't hate your god. I couldn't hate your god any more than I hate the Easter Bunny or unicorns.
To be fair, there's no reason to hate the easter bunny even if it was real.

Her god, on the other hand, if he was real seems worthy of loathing. Perhaps she's understands our points more than she lets on, and simply is trying to prevent herself from hating god.
 
Kathy - when people here hav questioned the suffering of sick chidren, you respond by bringing up naughty 2 year olds.

Even if I accepted that argument, can you tell me what terrible sin my niece might have commited to deserve being born without a properly functioning heart which caused her to spend the first few months of her life in terrible suffering?

No I did not blame it on a naughty 2 year old but it is absolutely evident that we have bad behaviors in us at an early age.

And how do you expect me to know why God allowed that heart condition? He just did. Do you really think I understand it all? All I know is this world has suffered mainly do to sin and the enemy of our souls.
 
KK:

It is pretty clear. KK is having an abusive relationship with god (god is the abuser).

I am 100% serious, and am not joking in the slightest.

The reason why I am posting this, is because you people need to change your attitudes. There is no sense in playing the rational game with an abused woman. You wouldn't start to rationally argue with a woman that is regularly abused. You wouldn't suggest a woman that is treated by her man like scum to read a philosophy book. You need to do something else. I don't know what. Help her realize that she is worth something independently of an authority figure? Try and help her solve her emotional problems?

-----

KK, I am sorry if it sounds condescending. I guess the reason it sounds condescending is because it is. But I haven't managed to think of a better way to make people see the problem.

Some people have a good relationship with god. They are inspired by the idea of god to lead a better, richer more fulfilling life on their own. Your relationship with god has made you a person that is too dependent on god. God should make you more creative,happy,fulfilled in your life, not utterly dependent on him.

Oh I'm expressing I am being abused now? I have admitted to living in chronic pain and I do not like it but it's my fault I had the surgeries and put my hope in doctors. I was better with my degenerative disk disease before I attempted surgeries to fix it. I look back and know it's my own bad choices that caused me more pain. So how exactly am I accusing God of my own wrong choices? If anything I just had hoped he would heal me but I am not one he is choosing to do that for, at least not so far.

And yes I am dependent on God, what's so wrong with that? You think me weak for it then let me glory in my weakness so he is proven to be my strength. I have many days I would not get out of bed without the Lord helping me to. And I have found things I can do without using much physical ability that are creative so I do find some joy in that. I am just challenged to have to change a lot of things I use to enjoy under my current circumstances. I always was a very active person so God has challenged me to change in ways I really did not want to have to. Are you following me? Change is hard sometimes especially when we lose some of those gifts we once enjoyed like better health and such. If you have never been in someones shoes that deals with chronic pain and fatigue I do not think you can really even try to relate or be compassionate. I have lots of empathy for others who suffer now because I know what if feels like.
 
Last edited:
Liar. This is complete bull:rule10. Here's the set-up from the first post in this thread:




You will note that what you agreed to (you did say, "Okay") was to read and analyze the Ehrman book, not to listen to two minutes of it and say, "This is too depressing." Nobody asked you to like the book, but you agreed to read and analyze it.





Too bad. That's what "analyze" means, and that's what you said "Okay" to. But it's okay if you want to be proved a liar. (Doesn't God have some pretty nasty things to say about liars?)




You seem to suffer from the delusion that saying something makes it so. You can't just say this is "analysis" and **poof!** it's analysis. Go back and look at what Hokulele did. She read. She quoted. She said what she thought about the passages she quoted. Then she quoted some more and said some more about what she thought about those passages.

Doesn't it make you feel ashamed that an atheist is better at living up to her word than you are?





Did you stone your two-year-old children when they misbehaved?

Back up and let me ask you why you are judging me? I told Hokulele I would listen to the audio book and tell her what I thought when through. I did not intend for her to start a thread to put me on the spot when I agreed to do so, so I would appreciate it if you would realize I have already done more than I origianally agreed to which does NOT make me a liar at all. You need to be nice and stop getting on my case. I just do not see anything much good in this book and why exert more energy into something I do not feel compelled to do so for? I also gave up people pleasing a long time ago so please do not try pushing this. Thanks
 
Last edited:
Kathy, I think I'm actually beginning to comprehend the depth of the self-loathing that your beliefs foster in you.


I, for one, don't hate your god. I couldn't hate your god any more than I hate the Easter Bunny or unicorns.

Yes for unbeliever in Christ I realize that's your interpretation of it, but that does not prove you right either.

And all I can say to you if you choose to hate God, Maranatha! You only condemn yourself in doing so!!
 
Oh I'm expressing I am being abused now? I have admitted to living in chronic pain and I do not like it but it's my fault...

The abusive relationship illustration hadn't occured to me before JetLeg mentioned it, but now I can barely see anything else. It really does fit very, very well.

"God only smites me when he's angry and I deserve it..."
 
Last edited:
Kathy do you even read what you respond to? Can you read? Look at this:

Foster Zygote said:
Kathy, I think I'm actually beginning to comprehend the depth of the self-loathing that your beliefs foster in you.

I, for one, don't hate your god. I couldn't hate your god any more than I hate the Easter Bunny or unicorns.


KK said:
And all I can say to you if you choose to hate God, Maranatha! You only condemn yourself in doing so!!

Are you even capable of explaining how your response makes any sense whatsoever?

Norm
 
Last edited:
He is a very good writer and a decent researcher. I own his "Lost Gospels" and "Lost Christianities". :)

Agreed, it is a link back to Isaiah, but Peter* took it a step further and suggested that Jesus, who was without sin, couldn't redeem mankind without suffering (which ties into agglerithm's thread).

My bolding.


* - Well, the author of the letter. There is some dispute as to whether or not it was written by Peter himself.
I am not convinced by ideas of atonement that Jesus had to die or that he had to suffer - there are a number of different images and metaphors in the Bible.

My favourite part of the Peter epistles is 2 Peter 16. Paul is hard to understand - no kidding!
 
Holden: You're in a desert, walking along in the sand when all of the sudden-

Leon: Is this the test now?

Holden: Yes. You're in a desert walking along in the sand when all of the sudden you look down-

Leon: What one?

Holden: What?

Leon: What desert?

Holden: It doesn't make any difference what desert, it's completely hypothetical.

Leon: But how come I'd be there?

Holden: Maybe you're fed up, maybe you want to be by yourself, who knows? You look down and you see a tortoise, Leon, it's crawling towards you-

Leon: Tortoise, what's that?

Holden: Know what a turtle is?

Leon: Of course.

Holden: Same thing.

Leon: I've never seen a turtle -- But I understand what you mean.

Holden: You reach down, you flip the tortoise over on its back Leon.

Leon: Do you make up these questions, Mr. Holden, or do they write them down for you?

Holden: The tortoise lays on its back, its belly baking in the hot sun beating its legs trying to turn itself over but it can't, not without your help, but you're not helping.

Leon: What do you mean I'm not helping?

Holden: I mean, you're not helping. Why is that Leon? -- They're just questions, Leon. In answer to your query, they're written down for me. It's a test, designed to provoke an emotional response. -- Shall we continue? Describe in single words, only the good things that come in to your mind about... your mother.

Leon: My mother?

Holden: Yeah.

Leon: Let me tell you about my mother...
 
Back up and let me ask you why you are judging me?

Why not ? You're doing it all the time to everybody, time for you to taste some of your own medicine.


I told Hokulele I would listen to the audio book and tell her what I thought when through. I did not intend for her to start a thread to put me on the spot when I agreed to do so, so I would appreciate it if you would realize I have already done more than I origianally agreed to which does NOT make me a liar at all.

No you didn't and yes it does.


You need to be nice and stop getting on my case.

No we don't.

I just do not see anything much good in this book and why exert more energy into something I do not feel compelled to do so for?

Then you shouldn't have been straightforward about the fact you weren't going to fulfill your end of the agreement should the subject displease you. Instead, you let everybody believe you were going to actually read or listen to the book and actually comment what was written in it, when what you intended to do all along was to make lame excuses and spend your time preaching and judging everybody according to your stupid, bigoted and hateful prejudices. That makes you a liar.


I also gave up people pleasing a long time ago

We all figured that out long ago


so please do not try pushing this. Thanks

Does not happen !
 
Oh I'm expressing I am being abused now? I have admitted to living in chronic pain and I do not like it but it's my fault I had the surgeries and put my hope in doctors. I was better with my degenerative disk disease before I attempted surgeries to fix it.

Look Kathy, there's the blaming yourself again. You put hope in doctors in order to, hopefully, get some relief from your disease, but now you have chronic pain from the procedures.
Why did you have these surgeries? Was the disease causing you discomfort? If you hadn't done these surgeries, would the disease be having adverse effects now? Did you not have consultation about the pro and cons of the surgeries?

I am certain you had a choice to either let the disease take it's course, causing you to have severe chronic pain in the future, or have surgery in an attempt to alleviate the condition.
What about the disease itself? Did you ask for that? Did you have a choice of whether or not to have degenerative disk disease?

I look back and know it's my own bad choices that caused me more pain. So how exactly am I accusing God of my own wrong choices? If anything I just had hoped he would heal me but I am not one he is choosing to do that for, at least not so far.

At the time of the surgery, you didn't believe the procedure was a bad choice, otherwise it would've never been done.

But the quote above is exactly why your not getting the point about suffering. Why would you consider being punished for wrong choices, when the choice was a natural one to correct an affliction you never asked for?

Many Xtians have died from their conditions when they refused treatment to fix the problem, believing god would heal them instead. Can't say they had a lack of faith, could you? But they died from their condition by testing their faith when all they had to do was go to a doctor or ER and survived.

And yes I am dependent on God, what's so wrong with that? You think me weak for it then let me glory in my weakness so he is proven to be my strength. I have many days I would not get out of bed without the Lord helping me to. And I have found things I can do without using much physical ability that are creative so I do find some joy in that. I am just challenged to have to change a lot of things I use to enjoy under my current circumstances. I always was a very active person so God has challenged me to change in ways I really did not want to have to. Are you following me? Change is hard sometimes especially when we lose some of those gifts we once enjoyed like better health and such. If you have never been in someones shoes that deals with chronic pain and fatigue I do not think you can really even try to relate or be compassionate. I have lots of empathy for others who suffer now because I know what if feels like.

Fine, good for you, but don't judge people just because they have never had chronic pain and/or use it as a crutch to accuse people of being incapable of compassion toward suffering.

Suffering is the fact of the matter here, why must we suffer? Why must death and misery be a price when the catalyst for all of this was put within reach of man to begin with?

Since you get depressed reading Ehrman, then you are incapable of having independent intellectual thought: You don't think for yourself anymore as an individual, god does the thinking instead. You're just a godbot with chronic pain.
 
Last edited:
I just do not see anything much good in this book and why exert more energy into something I do not feel compelled to do so for?
Nice catch, Flo

Now, I wonder if this quote could be applied to any other books ...
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom