Par
Master Poster
- Joined
- Apr 20, 2007
- Messages
- 2,768
Indeed. It seems that TruthByDecree is trying to make the following argument, or something very like it:
It is an obvious non sequitur, however. (Holocaust denial, for example, is undoubtedly fringe pseudohistory. But it is not completely ignored*; nor necessarily should it be. This doesn’t mean, however, that Holocaust denial is somehow mainstream or legitimate.)
- If something is fringe, then it will be or should be completely ignored.
- 9/11 conspiracy theories are not completely ignored.
- Therefore, they are not fringe, but rather mainstream.
- Therefore, they are legitimate.
* Of course, it is ignored – and probably rightly so – by the vast majority of mainstream academia, just as are 9/11 conspiracy theories.
And please give the holocaust a rest already... What I would like to know if it’s so fringe then who is sending him the massive amounts of email he claims? And did you check out the comments under his articles on 9/11? I guess that’s all one guy too?
People who oppose Holocaust deniers also receive plenty of comments and email from lunatics.
Last edited: