You don't think that this strange obsession with the minutiae of what Silverstein did or didn't say, together with the hounding of the man as shown in the video you linked and endorsed, points more toward malice than stupidity (though I don't rule out stupidity)? Do you realise what ideological company you're keeping?
What exactly are you trying say? Just come out and say it without the fancy foot work.
And assuming you will, my answer is NO.
Silverstein would be treated, by me, the same no matter what his religion was.
Accusations in this thread of being anti-semetic were directed at me, more than once.