• Quick note - the problem with Youtube videos not embedding on the forum appears to have been fixed, thanks to ZiprHead. If you do still see problems let me know.

College Psychology=Skepticism

JoeEllison

Cuddly Like a Koala Bear
JoeEllison
Joined
Jul 7, 2007
Messages
7,270
So, I'm headed back to college, and I opened up my Psychology 101 text(Psychology-Carole Wade and Carol Tavris) to see this on the inside of the front cover:

OVERVIEW OF CRITICAL THINKING

The first page of the book, facing the cover, is headed PSYCHOLOGICAL PROCESSES THAT AFFECT CRITICAL THINKING.

Before you hit the "meat" of the book, you see mention of the "Barnum Effect" and cognitive dissonance. I'm majoring in computer engineering... but this has the potential to be the best class of the year.

So, does anyone else see any positives or negatives to this sort of class?
 
Last edited:
If the instructor chose a text with critical thinking so prominantly featured at the front of the book, that's got to be a good sign.

I look forward to updates as the semester moves foreward.
 
UnrepentantSinner said:
If the instructor chose a text with critical thinking so prominantly featured at the front of the book, that's got to be a good sign.

I look forward to updates as the semester moves foreward.
Click to expand...
Well, we'll have to wait until Monday before I even have an idea of what the class is about, but the book is rather interesting. The first chapter addresses pseudoscience, popular opinion, and empirical evidence. As I flipped through the text, there were several critical thinking "sidebars" to the text.


So far, this is looking very promising! :D
 
JoeEllison said:
So, I'm headed back to college, and I opened up my Psychology 101 text(Psychology-Carole Wade and Carol Tavris) to see this on the inside of the front cover:

OVERVIEW OF CRITICAL THINKING

The first page of the book, facing the cover, is headed PSYCHOLOGICAL PROCESSES THAT AFFECT CRITICAL THINKING.

Before you hit the "meat" of the book, you see mention of the "Barnum Effect" and cognitive dissonance. I'm majoring in computer engineering... but this has the potential to be the best class of the year.

So, does anyone else see any positives or negatives to this sort of class?
Click to expand...


Been a long time since I took a college class. My minor was in the Honors program and the Critical Thinking class I took was just that: learning to think critically.

Today, that seems to have morphed into: how to criticize the present administration (USA) and how to criticize tradional American values, free market economics, etc.

I'm not sure what this class offers you in that regard. If the Barnum Effect is used to show you what rubes and suckers "conservatives" are, then I'd say no...it's just more of the same old leftist ideology masquerading as academics our unis and colleges have been suffering under for at least 20 years now.

Tokie
 
Psych is arguably the most interesting college major (unless you're a behaviorist), which is good n bad.

Bad because lot of people then major in it and find they can't do much with just the BA.

I used to teach psych-- never intro though-- then switched to a business college. We have a class there called organizational behavior. It's about 80% stolen intro to psych.

Not sure what my point is here....hey, could you briefly summarize what your text says about IQ tests? Just curious what kinda lies the intro texts might be spouting about them:)
 
Last edited:
Good times Joe, have fun.

Now if only they taught proper first year psych to freshmen in high school...
 
Last edited:
OnlyTellsTruths said:
Good times Joe, have fun.

Now if only they taught proper first year psych to freshmen in high school...
Click to expand...

Well, I'm back from the first class... the professor encourages open discussion. So, some Jesus girl piped up, and they got into a little back and forth. It was pretty cool, overall. I can see some serious "wasting" of class time in my future... :D
 
bpesta22 said:
Psych is arguably the most interesting college major (unless you're a behaviorist), which is good n bad.

Bad because lot of people then major in it and find they can't do much with just the BA.

I used to teach psych-- never intro though-- then switched to a business college. We have a class there called organizational behavior. It's about 80% stolen intro to psych.

Not sure what my point is here....hey, could you briefly summarize what your text says about IQ tests? Just curious what kinda lies the intro texts might be spouting about them:)
Click to expand...

I am one of those who got the BA, although it was with plans to follow through. I do credit a few of the psych classes with improving my critical thinking skills and understanding of how we can misperceive events.
 
bpesta22 said:
Psych is arguably the most interesting college major (unless you're a behaviorist), which is good n bad.

Bad because lot of people then major in it and find they can't do much with just the BA.

I used to teach psych-- never intro though-- then switched to a business college. We have a class there called organizational behavior. It's about 80% stolen intro to psych.

Not sure what my point is here....hey, could you briefly summarize what your text says about IQ tests? Just curious what kinda lies the intro texts might be spouting about them:)
Click to expand...

Hmm...that's strange...I said exactly the same thing in the "Will the Humanities Save Us Thread" about Psych (4-yr) and some other such "soft sciences" and was roundly criticized for being a no-nothing Philestine with no "right" to say such a thing.

You CAN do a lot with a BA in Psych, tho: Some of my favorite waitpersons have degrees in it. Or Philo.

Tokie
 
Mister Agenda said:
I am one of those who got the BA, although it was with plans to follow through. I do credit a few of the psych classes with improving my critical thinking skills and understanding of how we can misperceive events.
Click to expand...

Makes sense... I'm not majoring in it, but it seemed like a good idea to take a non-technical class, something with a little less math and equations and such.
 
Tokenconservative said:
Been a long time since I took a college class. My minor was in the Honors program and the Critical Thinking class I took was just that: learning to think critically.

Today, that seems to have morphed into: how to criticize the present administration (USA) and how to criticize tradional American values, free market economics, etc.

I'm not sure what this class offers you in that regard. If the Barnum Effect is used to show you what rubes and suckers "conservatives" are, then I'd say no...it's just more of the same old leftist ideology masquerading as academics our unis and colleges have been suffering under for at least 20 years now.

Tokie
Click to expand...


On the soap box already?

I am sure that is what the test book is all about.

Can I have some crackers with that wine?

As a response to the OP:

Unfortunately there is not enough scepticism in psychology! So many people can be total off the wall fruit cakes who quote all sorts of little unsupported snipetts of information. It sounds like you have a good instructor.

(I am sure that most instructors are good, just some real flakes out there.)
 
Oh, I think a psych BA is a fine degree and a great education. I got one!

I just think it's not very helpful in the job market.

Doesn't mean it's not worth pursuing for other reasons, but the ROI $ is alas not there:(
 
I just started a 600 level communication theory class where the professor led off his syllabus with a quote warning against 'incorrigible empirical rationalism'. Should be an interesting class. :boggled:
 
Last edited:
bpesta22 said:
Psych is arguably the most interesting college major (unless you're a behaviorist), which is good n bad....QUOTE]
What? I am teaching applied behavior analysis this semester. Much more interesting than airhead cognitive stuff.
Click to expand...
 
I had a college psychology class, and the professor was the biggest believer in woo ever. He was pretty good about saying there was not a lot of evidence to support it, but he also exhorted the students to keep an "open mind." He wanted us to think seriously about the full moon effect, qigong, psychics, and all kinds of nonsense. But I did get an A despite it.
 
bpesta22 said:
Psych is arguably the most interesting college major (unless you're a behaviorist), which is good n bad.

Bad because lot of people then major in it and find they can't do much with just the BA.

I used to teach psych-- never intro though-- then switched to a business college. We have a class there called organizational behavior. It's about 80% stolen intro to psych.

Not sure what my point is here....hey, could you briefly summarize what your text says about IQ tests? Just curious what kinda lies the intro texts might be spouting about them:)
Click to expand...

Psychology is the most-impacted major at UCLA. You do not transfer as a psych without a GPA >= 3.8. It's pretty rough competitively. I don't trash Psych majors. They're damn hard workers.

My Introduction to Computational and Systems Biology seminar last quarter had the prof. facilitating it state that, "the best model is one where, when you put in new data, it explodes."
 
exlex said:
I had a college psychology class, and the professor was the biggest believer in woo ever. He was pretty good about saying there was not a lot of evidence to support it, but he also exhorted the students to keep an "open mind." He wanted us to think seriously about the full moon effect, qigong, psychics, and all kinds of nonsense. But I did get an A despite it.
Click to expand...

Hah!

The professor told us a story today about how the doctor at a hospital he worked at thought one of the patients was "possessed by Satan", and how he had half a mind to have the patient AND doctor held for evaluation. :D

I'm really enjoying this class!
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Back
Top Bottom