FireGarden
Philosopher
- Joined
- Aug 13, 2002
- Messages
- 5,047
Do you think it was more of a
(1) Blair: "OK God, should I invade Iraq? What's that? If the next word I hear starts with a constanant then you wants me to invade Iraq, If it starts with a vowel you want me to not invade...OK..."
Chere: "Tea's ready!"
Blair: "Invasion it is!"
or a
(2) "Please God, help me make the right decision"
type of prayer? The latter seems more likely than the former no?
I'm willing to accept it was the second.
Does Blair think that he was helped to get the right answer? If so, wouldn't that give him a special kind of certainty? -- one not supported by objective advice.
Maybe it was a bit like Homer's prayer: "Lord, if in thy wisdom you approve of this war then give me no sign...... Thy will be done." After all, isn't all such prayer a search for justification?
If Blair said, "I prayed but got no answer so I had to make the decision on my own." That wouldn't have been so bad.
