• Quick note - the problem with Youtube videos not embedding on the forum appears to have been fixed, thanks to ZiprHead. If you do still see problems let me know.

carlson test and debunking randi

I wasn't offering criticism: I was asking questions. If you wish others to be better informed about astrology, it might be a good idea to try to answer them.

ill give an example as soon i have time:D
 
US naval observatory:D

here is an example.
this is what james says about gemini rising, my rising sign, and what tradition says, though i can see he adds his experience as i had similar experiences.
This is not as vague as « you are normally social, confident, but inside more insecure and sometimes need to be alone».

Your personality suggests someone who tends to live on nervous energy and who is always on the move. You like to think, speak, write, travel and generally be on the move, changing from one subject or location to the next with consummate ease. You can be very lively. Never a dull moment - unless you get bored, that is. Boredom is the worst thing that can happen to you. Your body language compliments what you are saying, using gestures to emphasise a word or phrase.

The one thing you are is adaptable. You just love change and ever-changing situations. 'Variety is the spice of life' someone once wrote. No, for you variety is an absolute MUST, without it life would be so dull. You do need lots of stimulus and constant interests. Resting, or even staying still , is not easy - there's too much to do! Your versatility is almost legendary. I think it's a safe bet that you can do two things at the same time - or more. Watching the TV while having a telephone conversation is just one example. You can turn your hand to anything and you learn so quickly.

Being an intelligent soul you are noted for being clever and informed. Learning, in fact any kind of education, really appeals. All that knowledge - you simply have to know. You absorb information like a sponge and once your enthusiasm is fired up you learn so quickly. Some folk may accuse you of being a, 'a mine of useless information'. But, what would they know - it's all useful information, and to you it is food for the mind. You like to communicate through speaking, writing, and telephone calls. Getting about and traveling also appeals, you just like the thrill of movement and ever-changing scenarios.

You have the gift of humour. Laughter comes naturally and you can see the funny side of any situation, especially if it involves someone else getting into trouble. Never stuck for a witty comment, you can liven up the most austere situation with some clever quip. It isn't that you have to think about these things, they just come naturally, off the top of your head, so to speak. Sometimes you surprise even yourself by what comes out of your mouth so spontaneously. You are good fun to be around.

Your ruling planet has only difficult aspects.
Your ruling planet - Mercury - has difficult aspects which modify the way in which you express yourself. Your nervousness gets in the way of easy self expression and you lack confidence which, in turn, affects your communication skills. Sometimes you will find that it isn't easy to make yourself understood or to express your opinions adequately. You just 'lock up' and feel inhibited. At other times you will chatter endlessly, repeating the same point in many different ways as if afraid people will not understand you. More likely, you are afraid of silence, it feels uncomfortable. Misunderstandings are so easy. You mean to say one thing but somehow it comes out all wrong. Your opinions change rapidly, especially to win an argument.

Learning is not easy. There may have been problems in your early education which was affected or even halted in some way by events beyond your control. The problem now is that you try to take on board too many ideas, as if you are afraid you might miss something. You may start to read a book and never finish it, learn a new skill yet never complete the course. Your restless, nervous nature seems to want to move on to other things. Rather than learn and be original you are inclined to imitate or borrow from others.

You tend to be diffuse with too many things on the go at the same time, so continuity becomes a problem as indeed does completing tasks. Your nature is to be nervous, excitable and restless. You have difficulty in staying still or resting and you are prone to nervous exhaustion as a result. It is important to realise that all the talents and abilities previously mentioned are yours for the asking. Once you learn to slow down, taking one thing at a time and also learning the art of relaxation, you will find a new lease of life. Remember, the mind a great servant but a bad master. The mind is something you are well equipped to deal with.

Your ruling planet has Mixed aspects.
Both interpretations are possible - not at the same time, they will tend to alternate.


--- and here is my Sun position. As you can see they are very different signs
The result of this combination in my opinion is that because of gemini i find it difficult to focus in one sign, unlike typical capricorn and do not always follow my principles and values of honesty and high principles. The sun is what we want to be and how we want to shine. the rising sign is the more dynamic part of personality, the biological personality,spontaneous, of which we often are not aware until someone points it out to us. We tend to think we are our sun sign, but often people see another side of us.:D

Sun in Capricorn
Cautious and deliberate. Highly principled and trustworthy. Reliable and dependable. Values honesty and straight dealing.
Aspires to be a success in life and to have a position of responsibility. Enterprising and keen to get on. Can see the greater picture and plan a way to succeed. Endless patience and determination. Businesslike, professional, highly efficient. Takes work and responsibilities seriously. Works tirelessly, very conscientious.

Rigid outlook. Far to conventional. May have to live within strictures dictated by others, afraid to break free. Insecure. Rules and regulations dominate life. Expects much but gives little.
May tend to hoard, afraid to spend though a sense of insecurity. Never seems to be enough.
Gloomy and pessimistic. Sees obstacles rather than challenges. Narrow view of life



 
where i say «focus on one sign» i meant « focus on one thing»

:D
here is an example.
this is what james says about gemini rising, my rising sign, and what tradition says, though i can see he adds his experience as i had similar experiences.
This is not as vague as « you are normally social, confident, but inside more insecure and sometimes need to be alone».

Your personality suggests someone who tends to live on nervous energy and who is always on the move. You like to think, speak, write, travel and generally be on the move, changing from one subject or location to the next with consummate ease. You can be very lively. Never a dull moment - unless you get bored, that is. Boredom is the worst thing that can happen to you. Your body language compliments what you are saying, using gestures to emphasise a word or phrase.

The one thing you are is adaptable. You just love change and ever-changing situations. 'Variety is the spice of life' someone once wrote. No, for you variety is an absolute MUST, without it life would be so dull. You do need lots of stimulus and constant interests. Resting, or even staying still , is not easy - there's too much to do! Your versatility is almost legendary. I think it's a safe bet that you can do two things at the same time - or more. Watching the TV while having a telephone conversation is just one example. You can turn your hand to anything and you learn so quickly.

Being an intelligent soul you are noted for being clever and informed. Learning, in fact any kind of education, really appeals. All that knowledge - you simply have to know. You absorb information like a sponge and once your enthusiasm is fired up you learn so quickly. Some folk may accuse you of being a, 'a mine of useless information'. But, what would they know - it's all useful information, and to you it is food for the mind. You like to communicate through speaking, writing, and telephone calls. Getting about and traveling also appeals, you just like the thrill of movement and ever-changing scenarios.

You have the gift of humour. Laughter comes naturally and you can see the funny side of any situation, especially if it involves someone else getting into trouble. Never stuck for a witty comment, you can liven up the most austere situation with some clever quip. It isn't that you have to think about these things, they just come naturally, off the top of your head, so to speak. Sometimes you surprise even yourself by what comes out of your mouth so spontaneously. You are good fun to be around.
Your ruling planet has only difficult aspects.
Your ruling planet - Mercury - has difficult aspects which modify the way in which you express yourself. Your nervousness gets in the way of easy self expression and you lack confidence which, in turn, affects your communication skills. Sometimes you will find that it isn't easy to make yourself understood or to express your opinions adequately. You just 'lock up' and feel inhibited. At other times you will chatter endlessly, repeating the same point in many different ways as if afraid people will not understand you. More likely, you are afraid of silence, it feels uncomfortable. Misunderstandings are so easy. You mean to say one thing but somehow it comes out all wrong. Your opinions change rapidly, especially to win an argument.

Learning is not easy. There may have been problems in your early education which was affected or even halted in some way by events beyond your control. The problem now is that you try to take on board too many ideas, as if you are afraid you might miss something. You may start to read a book and never finish it, learn a new skill yet never complete the course. Your restless, nervous nature seems to want to move on to other things. Rather than learn and be original you are inclined to imitate or borrow from others.

You tend to be diffuse with too many things on the go at the same time, so continuity becomes a problem as indeed does completing tasks. Your nature is to be nervous, excitable and restless. You have difficulty in staying still or resting and you are prone to nervous exhaustion as a result. It is important to realise that all the talents and abilities previously mentioned are yours for the asking. Once you learn to slow down, taking one thing at a time and also learning the art of relaxation, you will find a new lease of life. Remember, the mind a great servant but a bad master. The mind is something you are well equipped to deal with.
Your ruling planet has Mixed aspects.
Both interpretations are possible - not at the same time, they will tend to alternate.


--- and here is my Sun position. As you can see they are very different signs
The result of this combination in my opinion is that because of gemini i find it difficult to focus in one sign, unlike typical capricorn and do not always follow my principles and values of honesty and high principles. The sun is what we want to be and how we want to shine. the rising sign is the more dynamic part of personality, the biological personality,spontaneous, of which we often are not aware until someone points it out to us. We tend to think we are our sun sign, but often people see another side of us.:D

Sun in Capricorn
Cautious and deliberate. Highly principled and trustworthy. Reliable and dependable. Values honesty and straight dealing.
Aspires to be a success in life and to have a position of responsibility. Enterprising and keen to get on. Can see the greater picture and plan a way to succeed. Endless patience and determination. Businesslike, professional, highly efficient. Takes work and responsibilities seriously. Works tirelessly, very conscientious.

Rigid outlook. Far to conventional. May have to live within strictures dictated by others, afraid to break free. Insecure. Rules and regulations dominate life. Expects much but gives little.
May tend to hoard, afraid to spend though a sense of insecurity. Never seems to be enough.
Gloomy and pessimistic. Sees obstacles rather than challenges. Narrow view of life
 
I dont think astrology is paranormal,I think its just good guess work.Whats to study?
 
no its not paranormal,yet Randi told Young that it was.Full stop.:D
Well if Randi says it is, then if you can demonstrate that it works for the media and for a reliable observer, then you're on your way to a million bucks.

Normally the way this works is for you to develop a number of charts for people about whom you only know their birthdates, times and locations, and see if they can pick out their own. Do you think you can do that? Do you want to try it out with a few people here? I can think of a fairly easy protocol.
 
So you're "never stuck for a witty comment, you can liven up the most austere situation with some clever quip. It isn't that you have to think about these things, they just come naturally, off the top of your head, so to speak. Sometimes you surprise even yourself by what comes out of your mouth so spontaneously. You are good fun to be around".

But then, "your nervousness gets in the way of easy self expression and you lack confidence which, in turn, affects your communication skills. Sometimes you will find that it isn't easy to make yourself understood or to express your opinions adequately. You just 'lock up' and feel inhibited."

Riiiight.
 
Well if Randi says it is, then if you can demonstrate that it works for the media and for a reliable observer, then you're on your way to a million bucks.

Normally the way this works is for you to develop a number of charts for people about whom you only know their birthdates, times and locations, and see if they can pick out their own. Do you think you can do that? Do you want to try it out with a few people here? I can think of a fairly easy protocol.

you obviously didnt watch the youtube links i sent.
they explain the problems with his test and show an alternative test by Young.
its funny that skeptics have been complaining that astrologers criticize their methods but dont show any alternatives,
well, here is one:D
 
you obviously didnt watch the youtube links i sent.
they explain the problems with his test and show an alternative test by Young.
its funny that skeptics have been complaining that astrologers criticize their methods but dont show any alternatives,
well, here is one:D
What is wrong with the method I've proposed?

I can tell you that what is wrong with Young's challenge is that it does not, at any point, put astrology to the test. It is a test where Young can say, "I know more about astrology than you". I have no doubt that is true. One can learn practically everything in the literature about dragons, but it doesn't make dragons true.
 
Last edited:
Here's the Young Challenge, with my annotations.


James Young said:
James Young said:
You will be asked 10 questions on basic Astrology. A score of at least 8 correct answers is needed before you can move on to the next stage.

As I say, how is this a test of astrology? It is a test of the ability to memorize and nothing more.


James Young said:
Those who cannot achieve this score will be deemed to have failed the challenge. Note; This is a test of existing knowledge.

This is not a test of existing knowledge unless it can be shown to be knowledge. Unsupported claims are not knowledge.


James Young said:
In order to prevent cheating by those who think it is perfect acceptable to get their answers from books or other sources, a time limit on supplying answers is in force.

Again, Young is asking people to memorize data, and do it rather quickly. This is not, in any sense, a test of astrology.

James Young said:
James Young said:
You will be given the birth data of a real person and asked to type out a report giving the main character traits of this person. To do this you need to calculate and draw a chart then interpret it. You must cover general character traits, personality, mentality, and emotional responses. A minimum of 3 pages of A4 is required. Those who cannot do this successfully will be deemed to have failed the challenge.

He is skipping the part where we discover what "successfully" means. Does Young judge? Does the person? How is this person selected?

James Young said:
James Young said:
You will be required to detail the future trends for the same person for the next 12 months. You must include Transits, Progressions, and Directions. Solar return is optional. Those who cannot will be deemed to have failed the challenge.

...and then you wait twelve months to see if they were accurate, right? Again, who judges?

James Young said:
This test requires you do do no more than a traditional Astrologer is asked to do in the normal course of his work.

This is a test to see if a person could be an astrologer, not a test of whether or not astrology works. It is filled with gaps in the protocol, even assuming that protocol was useful.

Now, do you want to discuss what is wrong with the basic idea I've outlined?
 
well, here is one:D

idunno, I see you posting many grins, but it seems you are serious. But what say you to Tricky's points? It seems obvious that the Young challenge is a test of knowledge/competency at astrology, not whether it works at all.

Plus, the stuff you posted was the usual untestable vague stuff about learning quickly, having a sense of humor, blah, blah.

Most people will think this applies to them, concentrating on the things they believe match, and downplaying what they think doesn't.

:D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D
 
Sorry, stupid ISP dropped me today. Anyway, I see you are using the US Naval ephemeris, european calculations, and tropical coordinates.

Umm, you do realize that the USNO almanacs are published in sidereal coordinates, yes? How would that affect your calculations?
OMG! A woman who understands projections, coordinate systems and geographic transformations... (pant pant pant). This is the kind of woman that I would give my NAD spheroid for. I can't hear things like this from women without wanting to datum.
 

Back
Top Bottom