• Quick note - the problem with Youtube videos not embedding on the forum appears to have been fixed, thanks to ZiprHead. If you do still see problems let me know.

carlson test and debunking randi

idunno

Banned
I
Joined
Sep 2, 2006
Messages
811
i think youll find these interesting

it seems the skeptics are afraid

paulohttp://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xwQTS6yuQhU&mode=related&search=

Astrologer James Young issues a direct challenge to critics of his videos [such as UncleFeedle and shanedk] to prove they have sufficient knowledge of the subject to be taken seriously. Have they? So far only 2 have applied for the challenge, lovasip backed out, the other failed. And the rest? Every tactic in the book has been used to avoid the challenge. They say [now], as feedlemania deadens their brains, that it doesn't matter HOW Astrology works, only IF it works. Nice try, but it is just another evasion. Care to try my challenge UncleFeedle? Thought not!

Feedle says that no Astrologer has entered his 'debate'. Is it any wonder with such biased minds, and comments from Feedle like 'Astrology is a crock of ****'.

Shanedk had to pay a lawyer to get his libellous videos back on and falsely accuses me of lying - but then most of what he says isn't based on fact. Legal victory does not mean moral victory. (more) (less)

http://www.firststop-astrology.com/Astrofacts/Fakes.htm

http://www.firststop-astrology.com/Astrofacts/BWC.htm

http://www.firststop-astrology.com/YouTube/Video1.htm

see also his misgivings about randis test in the same link:D
 
sorry thats an old one. i studied astrology and i can assure you he follows tradition.he doesnt uses asteroids, nodes and such crap
 
Tricky said:
I suspect that they'll never regulate it properly, which would be to only allow astrologers that could prove that astrology worked.
Click to expand...


Mockery!! The answer when there is no answer.

Unfortunately im finding out pretty fast scientists care a lot more about their Bank accounts than I thought, so Im not surprised about shams like the Carlson test:)
 
idunno said:
They say [now], as feedlemania deadens their brains, that it doesn't matter HOW Astrology works, only IF it works. Nice try, but it is just another evasion.
Click to expand...


Do you claim that astrology actually does something?

If so, what?
 
idunno said:
i only take criticism from those who studied the subject.
Do not pretend to know the subject cause I would find easily:D
Click to expand...


I wasn't offering criticism: I was asking questions. If you wish others to be better informed about astrology, it might be a good idea to try to answer them.
 
idunno said:
Mockery!! The answer when there is no answer.
Click to expand...
What is the question?

idunno said:
Unfortunately im finding out pretty fast scientists care a lot more about their Bank accounts than I thought, so Im not surprised about shams like the Carlson test:)
Click to expand...
Scientists? I know a lot of scientists and usually they are not the ones raking in the money. They do the discovering and other people make the money off their discoveries.
 
Mojo said:
I wasn't offering criticism: I was asking questions. If you wish others to be better informed about astrology, it might be a good idea to try to answer them.
Click to expand...

astrology shows trends. for example i felt an impulse to study(took up 3 courses) earlier this year while Mercury(planet of the mind) was approaching the highest point of the chart. It was not Placebo as I wasnt aware of that.
It tells personality traits as well.
But unlike some claim it doesnt necessarily tell the future. If a certain day is good for love but you stay home, nothing will happen.

But dont ask me to read for cause im no expert. James Clayton seems to be good from the free knowledge he provides,. I found him more accurate than the average astrologer:D
 
Which system are you using? Aztec? Chinese? Indian? Hawaiian? European? Which ephemeris? What type of calendar, arithmetic or astronomical? Are you using sidereal or tropical coordinates?
 
Hokulele said:
Which system are you using? Aztec? Chinese? Indian? Hawaiian? European? Which ephemeris? What type of calendar, arithmetic or astronomical? Are you using sidereal or tropical coordinates?
Click to expand...

european, tropical
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Back
Top Bottom