• Quick note - the problem with Youtube videos not embedding on the forum appears to have been fixed, thanks to ZiprHead. If you do still see problems let me know.

Sylvia Browne - Split from: "Is troy a typical debunker"

Aphelion

Banned
A
Joined
Feb 19, 2007
Messages
453
Pardalis said:
What do you think of Killtown, and his constant harassment and slander of Madam McClatchey?
Click to expand...


Killtown is disgraceful, but I think he's a disinfo artist. Killtown does make one good point though, you lot harass Sylvia Brown.
 
Aphelion said:
Killtown is disgraceful, but I think he's a disinfo artist. Killtown does make one good point though, you lot harass Sylvia Brown.
Click to expand...

It's awfully telling that you think that's a "good point". Comparing a total fraud who makes millions off the suffering of others, to a woman who happened to take a picture at just the right(wrong?) time is disingenous at best.
 
Aphelion said:
Killtown is disgraceful, but I think he's a disinfo artist. Killtown does make one good point though, you lot harass Sylvia Brown.
Click to expand...

Ah so you condone Sylvia using "cold reading" to simulate psychic abilities, preying on the grieving, the ill,etc?
 
Somebody posted earlier that Sylvia is making millions from what she does, so why would she need Randi's million bucks?
 
There are plenty of S. Browne discussions in the General Skepticism and the Paranormal subforum. Please take this tangent there.
 
Aphelion said:
Why does she need to prove anything? People are free to pay for her services or not. If she was so bad she would run out of customers.
Click to expand...

She made the claim that she was it's up to her to prove it. And David Blaine is good too but it ain't magic.
 
Aphelion said:
I didn't make a claim. You lot are saying shes a con artist. Could I see your proof of this?
Click to expand...

She takes money from people by promising she can perform paranormal acts.

Pretty much the definition of a con artist.
 
Redtail said:
She made the claim that she was it's up to her to prove it. And David Blaine is good too but it ain't magic.
Click to expand...


Well in that case it is up to Val Mclatchley to prove her photo is genuine. Is that what you are saying?

You still haven't answered why a woman whos making millions needs Randi's million?
 
Aphelion said:
You still haven't answered why a woman whos making millions needs Randi's million?
Click to expand...

Because it'll finally shut him up? I can't think of anything else that might do that.

As for "proof", not absolute, but a heck of a lot of evidence:

http://www.stopsylviabrowne.com/home/

Can you show us equivalent evidence that KT and Nico are disinfo agents? Oh, right, you already admited you can't.

RSLancaster: 1 Aphelion: 0.

Next match?
 
Aphelion said:
I dont have any proof they are disinfo agents.
Click to expand...

There we go. So why are you trying to hold troy as an example of debunkers and accusing people of condoning his behavior yet you dismiss them as disinfo agents?

Now could I see your proof she isnt psychic? Proceed.
Click to expand...

She made the claim she can't prove it. She has the invitation to do so and doesn't.
 
Aphelion said:
Can you prove she cant perform paranormal acts?
Click to expand...
As usual, you have the burden of proof exactly backwards. Extraordinary claims require extraordinary proof. She's making the claims. Ergo, it's up to her to prove it, not us to prove she can't.

Until she proves she can, I won't believe she can.

She's agreed to be tested by Randi, but has avoided actually taking any steps to do this. That, to me, states unequivically, that she's a con, she knows she's conning, and has to keep the con going.

If you can't see this, you're absolutely a rock with legs!
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Back
Top Bottom