I think the evidence against the attack as reported now is fairly strong.
No footage of the attack.
This has weight only depending on how much one might realistically expect the attack to be captured. Most of the counter-theories would also require something to happen on camera which also hasn't been found- Smollett entering and leaving some other building to get beaten up by a hookup, Smollett renting a crashing a scooter.
The lack of useful video makes an attack a little harder to buy, but it has the same effect on most alternatives in this thread.
Some here have taken to saying there is only one minute of time unaccounted for in video. I may have missed a source for this, but I would be surprised if official police sources made such a detailed public announcement about a case in progress. Feel free to correct me if I missed it though. What I suspect is that this window is taken from a particular interpretation of some "leaked" comment. Which deserves at least a grain of salt.
plus the report of the attack has been revised and weakened a couple of times.
It looks like most sources were cribbing off TMZ. There is no statement on record from Smollett that he had broken ribs. Media making mistakes doesn't say much about the credibility of Smollett.
plus the failure to provide phone records.
That's been discussed a number of times. Even a couple folks in the "Smollett is obviously lying" camp can see some good reasons for that.
Now its reported that he was reluctant to report it to the police, which makes it sound like he painted himself into a corner when his friend called police, and instead of coming clean he doubled down
"Makes it sound" is just your personal feeling. Not wanting to report it to the police is fully consistent with a black, gay guy's feelings about such a situation and with a famous person's concern that they might be attacked again in the public sphere, kinda like what we're seeing.
It's also not consistent with "This was a hoax for attention"
But thanks for associating me with white supremisists simply beacause I do not believe one likely lying far left hero doing his best to give credibility to the other side.
I don't know what you think in your heart of hearts. But there are clearly a number of posters who are so strangely consistent with denouncing black people and liberal women as liars, it seems a bit strange to ignore. if you're not one of em, then good for you!