• Quick note - the problem with Youtube videos not embedding on the forum appears to have been fixed, thanks to ZiprHead. If you do still see problems let me know.

Merged Defend/Debate Reincarnation / Child Reincarnation Stories

Wonder234 said:
My definition of reincarnation is the standard definition.

Give me your definition of reincarnation.
Click to expand...

Resume said:
What do you mean by "standard" definition? This is your claim we're examining here.
Click to expand...

Wonder234 said:
The definition you find in the dictionary.
Click to expand...


The definition I find in the Concise Oxford English Dictionary I have on the shelf here is "The rebirth of a soul in a new body." That's incompatible with this:

Wonder234 said:
Well, I'm not necessarily trying to prove that souls transfer from body to body. I'm trying to show that someone's memories are actually the memories of another person. If you proved that the memories of one person are the memories of another then you could prove that that's the case, you could do that without talking about a soul.
Click to expand...


Which dictionary are you using? What is its definition?
 
Wonder234 said:
I've looked at some cases it's just that I haven't posted one in this thread.
Click to expand...


I know you haven't posted any, but you claimed that there are at least some that are "actually not that bad". Then you said that you haven't found any convincing ones. If your "actually not that bad" cases aren't convincing even to you there doesn't seem to be much to discuss here.
 
Last edited:
Wonder234 said:
I don't know how I became convinced that reincarnation is real, but once you're convinced, and I do not believe you control being convinced, it is a matter of doubting what you believe.
Click to expand...
It's very easy to unquestioning accept something and incorporate it into your belief system without first examining it properly to ensure it deserves to be so incorporated. But it's never too late to examine a belief to check there is sufficient evidence for it, and to readjust your beliefs if it doesn't stand up. It's also sometimes necessary to re-examine beliefs that appeared fully justified, but for which new contradictory evidence has now emerged.
 
Wonder234 said:
I tried and can not think of what would falsify reincarnation, for me the "evidence" would have to be explained away, so far I have found none of the things meant to explain it away convincing.
Click to expand...

Logically speaking, the burden of proof is on you. No one is obliged to prove/disprove your claim.
 
Wonder234 said:
I tried and can not think of what would falsify reincarnation, for me the "evidence" would have to be explained away, so far I have found none of the things meant to explain it away convincing.
Click to expand...

Wonder234 said:
If by testable claims you mean cases of reincarnation, I'll try to get to that soon.
Click to expand...

Do a good job, and don't make another post until you have something.
 
Wonder234 said:
I tried and can not think of what would falsify reincarnation, for me the "evidence" would have to be explained away, so far I have found none of the things meant to explain it away convincing.
Click to expand...


You don't seem to have found any convincing evidence for reincarnation either. Why accept unconvincing evidence, but not unconvincing explanations of that unconvincing evidence?
 
Wonder234 said:
Me: In cases of children who remember past lives where people claim the parents lie about it while getting their children to play along; Some people don't go public about their child's comments that indicate a probable past life and instead just tell friends and family members, which, I believe, removes the incentive for monetary gain and therefore of a reason to lie.
Click to expand...
Other poster: please demonstrate at least one reliable case of a child who remembers a past life.

Remember: first you must demonstrate that a phenomenon actually exists.
 
Wonder234 said:
Why would the address and the names of his kids not be valid?

He did say what his past self's favorite soda was, a soda that was discontinued 50 years before his supposed new incarnation. And there have been cases where intimate details have been reported.




It seems unlikely that each case has some unique thing to explain it away, why would it happen so much if that's the case? Maybe if there was some weird psychological phenomenon that was discovered besides cryptomnesia, but I can't think of what that would be.

What would make you think that past lives are real?
Click to expand...

But the fact that soda was made is historical data anyone with an inclination could find. Any historical data available today cannot be considered to be evidence of a past life. To even consider that the topic needs more study, you'd have to provide data unavailable historically and confirmed archaeologically. Even then, you'd need many data points before you can say there's evidence.
 
SusanB-M1 said:
If they did, one can only hope that the adults around them would interpret them correctly!
Click to expand...

I imagined a couple "past lives" when I was a kid. The story was they were relatively ordinary and didn't live long. Then I grew up. :D
Forgot to say that family appropriately ignored me!!!
 
Last edited:
Wonder234 said:
I believe it is easier to make an argument for the persistence of memories than the mechanism by which the awareness that those memories are housed in transfers from body to body and how could we observe observe a soul leaving, existing apart from and then going to another body? There doesn't seem to be any obvious way.
Click to expand...


OK. Go right ahead and do it. You're not exactly making a good start.
 
Last edited:
I could of course be wrong but the impression I'm getting is that Wonder234 is reasonably intelligent but, for whatever reason, is coming from a background where he/she has never been exposed to critical thinking skills, the scientific method etc. Home schooled, or something?

They have somehow found their way to this forum, which is an ideal place to acquire the skills they currently lack. Can I politely suggest that we first try to help them fill in the gaps in their education rather than go straight into full on attack mode?
 
Wonder234 said:
Then wouldn't more children report past lives, if they all experienced adults talking and absorbed and rearranged the information?
Click to expand...
Only if (a) there was such a thing as reincarnation, and (b) if the adults chose to interpret what the child said as evidence of reincarnation; both of which would fail to stand up to scrutiny.
 
As was pointed out the last time this topic came up, why would memories of a past life necessarily imply reincarnation? Why not time travel, being able to speak with the dead, or even necromancy? The last would be the most fun, I would think.
 
Hokulele said:
As was pointed out the last time this topic came up, why would memories of a past life necessarily imply reincarnation? Why not time travel, being able to speak with the dead, or even necromancy? The last would be the most fun, I would think.
Click to expand...
That is correct, and Wonder234 has wisely chosen to limit his claim to the transfer of memories, presumably from dead people to living people.

But it is still contrary to the current understanding of the laws of nature, and the evidence is the same as what has been presented for reincarnation, so it is just as bad. It seems that Wonder234 also understands this part.

S/he is probably mentally attuned to the idea of reincarnation so that it will be very difficult for him or her to follow where this evidence leads, and accept that reincarnation, or the transfer of memories does not exist.
 
The big problem I have with the idea of survival of memory is that we know from actual testing and experience that memory does not survive damage to the brain in cases where the individual survives. No mechanism has been shown to suggest that memory can survive the destruction of the brain.

Without either a coherent theory, or convincing evidence, there is nothing but speculation to discuss.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Back
Top Bottom