The Greater Fool
Illuminator
ETA: You are pressing me to decide which frame is the 'real' frame. You know better. Reality is what each of these frames of reference are peeking into.You say that events happen in a specific sequence. The clock reading a specific time is just an event. So what sequence do the events happen in?
If you don't like clocks, choose whatever you like. Dave and Cindy each have a bomb. Bob sees both bombs explode at the same time. Alice sees them explode at different times.
Do Dave and Cindy die at the same time or does Cindy outlive Dave? You are clearly saying that only one sequence of events can be true, so which is it?
Make it so one bomb going off first prevents the other bomb from exploding at all for an even more counterintuitive twist. One person lives and one dies, but who? Can we change our frame of reference and change the outcome?
I believe all the foregoing demonstrate that reality happens in a specific way, in a specific sequence, otherwise frame of reference would change outcome.I don't think that's possible. Information about one bomb going off can only be transmitted to the other bomb at the speed of light so there will be a delay during which the second bomb can still go off.
And that doesn't even consider relativistic effects.
Last edited: