Zimbabwe's Money Worth More As eBay Novelty Than As Actual Money

Tippit

Unregistered
Joined
Aug 1, 2007
Messages
4,038
Location
Florida
All of you pro-New World Order, pro-Federal Reserve, pro-inflation, pro-fiat money and fractional reserve banking dullards ought to get a kick out of this:

Zimbabwe's Money Worth More As eBay Novelty Than As Actual Money

Of particular note:

"Official inflation is quoted at 2.2 million percent but independent finance houses say it's closer to 12.5 million percent."

Who is in charge of understating the rate of inflation to the Zimbabwean people, and how the hell does he get away with it? Also:

"A German company stopped shipments of bank note paper to the central bank's printers this month as the European Union looked to strengthen sanctions. The release of new money slowed as the central bank said it was looking to Indonesia and Malaysia to supply the specialized paper."

I guess when runaway super-duper-hyper-inflation is apparently only limited by the available supply of BANK PAPER, there might be a problem.

Of course, the Zimbabweans are suffering mightily under this tyranny, and it is only an extreme example of the immense underlying moral problem that exists under fiat money/fractional reserve regimes around the world.
 
Oh, so you mean every OECD economy is bound to experience the same catastrophe as a mathematical certainty? And it is not because Mugabe is a thug?

:rolleyes:
 
Oh, so you mean every OECD economy is bound to experience the same catastrophe as a mathematical certainty? And it is not because Mugabe is a thug?

:rolleyes:
I would think that strawman arguments would be frowned on in a forum like this.

Tippit didn't say that. He didn't even imply it. There is nothing to imply that such runaway inflation is a mathematical certainty. He certainly didn't say it.

What he meant was that the value of fiat money is determined by the honor of the government in charge of it. Do you really trust the government to manage such an important institution in our society as money? Even in a democracy, if you trust the guy in office right now, what about the next administration?

Just be careful what kind of power you allow your government. A gold standard with full reserve banking would not depend as much on the honor of the people holding public office, or even the honor of the bankers. It would depend on the actual value of a stable physical commodity.
 
Last edited:
What he meant was that the value of fiat money is determined by the honor of the government in charge of it. Do you really trust the government to manage such an important institution in our society as money?
Actually yes because you don't have much of a choice. A screwed up government will run a nation into the ground whether or not your money is based on anything.

Even in a democracy, if you trust the guy in office right now, what about the next administration?
Right, and you prefer to place your "trust" in a shiny metal that has an arbitrary value based on...what exactly?

Just be careful what kind of power you allow your government. A gold standard with full reserve banking would not depend as much on the honor of the people holding public office, or even the honor of the bankers. It would depend on the actual value of a stable physical commodity.
Really? Gold is a stable physical commodity? Why? What is it worth to modern society except being shiny and being used in electronics? Why is it worth anything at all?...wait for it, wait for it...because we place an ARBITRARY value on the shiny metal.
 
where can I buy these Zimbabwe bank notes?

edit: NM found some

Untitled-Scanned-04-8.jpg



SPECIAL PAPER? THIS IS JUST MONOPOLY paper money if I ever saw some..
 
Last edited:
Didn't they re-value the currency recently to deal with this?

You know, they lopped quite a few zeros off of the numbers.
 
Of course, the Zimbabweans are suffering mightily under this tyranny, and it is only an extreme example of the immense underlying moral problem that exists under fiat money/fractional reserve regimes around the world.

If it is a tyranny that the Zimbabweans are living under then that is the problem, not the money.
 
"Official inflation is quoted at 2.2 million percent but independent finance houses say it's closer to 12.5 million percent."

Who is in charge of understating the rate of inflation to the Zimbabwean people, and how the hell does he get away with it?

Supriseing dificult for your average individual to accurately estimate inflation rates. In any case I doubt it matters to much. Once you hit 2.2 million percent inflation for the average person might as well be infinet. Either you spend the money now or not at all.
 
Oh, so you mean every OECD economy is bound to experience the same catastrophe as a mathematical certainty? And it is not because Mugabe is a thug?

:rolleyes:

No, most people who understand english, specifically the words "extreme example", wouldn't come to ask your nonsensical question. Of course Mugabe is a thug, but no more a thug than the banker overlords who control other fiat currencies, like David Rockefeller, or Sir Evelyn de Rothschild. The difference is that their blatant counterfeiting is obfuscated by the world's most powerful and productive economies, and apologized for by a litany of ignorant academic-types. People who are in fact graduates of schools that these same overlords have endowed with limitless funds and specific propaganda-based curricula. Possibly people much like yourself.
 
Actually yes because you don't have much of a choice. A screwed up government will run a nation into the ground whether or not your money is based on anything.

And yet if you make the choice to avoid that government's debauching of its currency, you avoid many of the problems resultant from said government.

Right, and you prefer to place your "trust" in a shiny metal that has an arbitrary value based on...what exactly?

The use as money over thousands of years of human history, scarcity, durability, portability, and uniformity. Things that are much more valuable than mere faith against an issuer's desire to partake in the immense profits of seigniorage.

Really? Gold is a stable physical commodity? Why? What is it worth to modern society except being shiny and being used in electronics? Why is it worth anything at all?...wait for it, wait for it...because we place an ARBITRARY value on the shiny metal.

See above. Instead of asking the question why have human beings placed an arbitrary value on the shiny metal, you might ask yourself why some things are arbitrarily more or less valuable than others over thousands of years and make an honest attempt to understand why.

Here's to betting that an ounce of gold will be worth more than a 100 billion dollar Zimbabwe reserve note in another thousand years. I suspect my heirs will be collecting from yours posthumously.
 
Last edited:
Of course Mugabe is a thug, but no more a thug than the banker overlords who control other fiat currencies, like David Rockefeller, or Sir Evelyn de Rothschild.

Which is why both the USA and the UK have been running multimillion percent inflation. Because the thugs who run hard currencies are just as bad as the thugs running Zimbabwe.

Tippit, what color is the sky in your world? Does your theory match reality at any point? Can you even tell me whose picture graces the UK ten pound note in your version of economics?
 
If it is a tyranny that the Zimbabweans are living under then that is the problem, not the money.

The point was not to illustrate that the Zimbabweans are living under tyranny, that should be obvious. The point is to illustrate that all fiat money/fractional reserve systems are tyranny. They are all based on legal tender laws coupled with tax laws that require taxes to be remitted in fiat currencies. They all revolve around force or the threat of force exacted at some level.
 
The point was not to illustrate that the Zimbabweans are living under tyranny, that should be obvious. The point is to illustrate that all fiat money/fractional reserve systems are tyranny.

So, let me get this "illustration" straight:

  • Zimbabweans are (obviously) living under tyranny.
  • As a result, they are suffering excessive hyperinflation that is destroying the value of the currency.
  • Americans and Brits are not suffering excessive hyperinflation that is destroying the value of the currency.


You know, that's an absolutely perfect example of logic -- and it proves exactly the opposite of your point. (The form is called, technically, modus tollens).

You've illustrated very clearly that the USA and UK are not tyranny, and by extension, that not all fiat money systems are tyranny (since you yourself have proven a counterexample).

Nice own goal there.
 
And yet if you make the choice to avoid that government's debauching of its currency, you avoid many of the problems resultant from said government.
Really? How so? Some government runs their nations economy into the ground and you believe that for some magic reasoning that their money will retain their value against gold?

The use as money over thousands of years of human history, scarcity, durability, portability, and uniformity. Things that are much more valuable than mere faith against an issuer's desire to partake in the immense profits of seigniorage.
Argument to Tradition. You still have not answered why gold has any value except for some arbitrary value that has been assigned to it.

Instead of asking the question why have human beings placed an arbitrary value on the shiny metal, you might ask yourself why some things are arbitrarily more or less valuable than others over thousands of years and make an honest attempt to understand why.
Because the value of different things change of time. Cowrie shells or cows are less valuable than titanium or oil these days...or did you have some point.

Here's to betting that an ounce of gold will be worth more than a 100 billion dollar Zimbabwe reserve note in another thousand years. I suspect my heirs will be collecting from yours posthumously.
Hahahaha...yeah sure. Here's betting my heirs will be collecting a far larger return on investment from so called fiat money than your worthless gold. Have fun living in your own reality.
 
where can I buy these Zimbabwe bank notes?

edit: NM found some

[qimg]http://i18.photobucket.com/albums/b146/Bwananick/0001NEW%20ITEMS/Untitled-Scanned-04-8.jpg[/qimg]


SPECIAL PAPER? THIS IS JUST MONOPOLY paper money if I ever saw some..

Great job of running the country, Mugabe.
 
The point was not to illustrate that the Zimbabweans are living under tyranny, that should be obvious. The point is to illustrate that all fiat money/fractional reserve systems are tyranny. They are all based on legal tender laws coupled with tax laws that require taxes to be remitted in fiat currencies. They all revolve around force or the threat of force exacted at some level.

You really don't know much about ecomomics in the real world, do you?
 
You really don't know much about ecomomics in the real world, do you?
Oh yes! Sorry! I was wrong all along! You've convinced me!

Yawn.

Is this what you call a rational debate?

You have said nothing about the actual arguments.

I am a bit disturbed by Tippit's comparing fiat currency bankers to a real tyrant thug like Mugabe. The level of thuggishness isn't even comparable.

But otherwise I see nothing wrong with his arguments.

As far as the value of gold, the fact that its primary use is esthetic is a good thing. Thats one of the things that make it such a good candidate for a currency, that it is a luxury. That, along with the fact that it is durable means that the supply of it available to be used as currency will be fairly stable. Too much of it isn't used up or lost.

Its valuable not just because it is shiny, but because of its other properties. It is resistant to corrosion, is easily shaped, divided, and so on.
 
Oh yes! Sorry! I was wrong all along! You've convinced me!

Yawn.

Is this what you call a rational debate?

You have said nothing about the actual arguments.
Oh please. How pathetic. If you want to use an ad hom, use it properly. Actually, your ad hominem is a great attempt at covering up yours and and Mr. Paranoid libertarian nutjob's lack of substance. How's that for a proper Ad hom?

I am a bit disturbed by Tippit's comparing fiat currency bankers to a real tyrant thug like Mugabe. The level of thuggishness isn't even comparable.

But otherwise I see nothing wrong with his arguments.
Oooooh, nice debating tactic. Attempting to seem "moderate" to make your position valid without offering anything to support your arguments. Nice job...not.
As far as the value of gold, the fact that its primary use is esthetic is a good thing. Thats one of the things that make it such a good candidate for a currency, that it is a luxury. That, along with the fact that it is durable means that the supply of it available to be used as currency will be fairly stable. Too much of it isn't used up or lost.
Hahahaha....that's pretty funny. A useless shiny metal is a candidate for currency because it is essentially useless. Great logic.
You just can't make yourself concede that you've just placed some useless arbitrary value on the shiny metal similar to how fiat currency is valued, can't you?
Hey, if gold was just priced as a regular commodity, do you know how energy efficient our electrical grid would be?

Its valuable not just because it is shiny, but because of its other properties. It is resistant to corrosion, is easily shaped, divided, and so on.
So...it is useful because it is there. Yeah...right.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom