Your thoughts on the “Flight 93” smoke plume photo

What are your thoughts on the “Flight 93” smoke plume photo?

  • It’s real and shows a plume from UA 93 crashing that grew 700yd wide*, drifted 250yd* w/out dissip

    Votes: 39 86.7%
  • It’s real and originated from/near the crater, but wasn’t caused by UA 93 or a 757 crashing.

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • It’s real, but wasn’t caused by UA 93 or a 757 crashing and originated far from the crater.

    Votes: 3 6.7%
  • It’s fake.

    Votes: 3 6.7%

  • Total voters
    45
1) No, I understand.

2) I understand how it can effect the plume size, but how would it affect the drift? Plane crashes, explodes, plume forms, plume drifts.

Try an experiment for me.. Take a molotov cocktail, light it, throw it as hard as you can into the ground at a 45-degree angle... and measure the horizontal distance of the smoke plume from the "impact site".

Maybe then you'll get it, because this is basic physics.

At the risk of going over your head, what happened to the horizontal compnent of the velocity/momentum of the fuel before the impact? Why do you think it's horizontal velocity went to 0 during the impact? Why wouldn't you consider the fact that it didn't go to 0? Why wouldn't you consider the fact that "smoke plume" originated from fuel that was burning while being spread south, like the rest of the debris? You've utterly ignored this entire avenue of thought.
 
Last edited:
BTW: What do the * mean at the first option? Very clear poll, isn´t it?
Yes, it's very clear if you even bothered to READ:

" *If you disagree with these descriptions in this poll choice, please state how long the photo was taken after UA 93 allegedly crashed, how wide you think the plume was, how far it drifted if at all, and whether you think it dissipating much at the time the photo was taken."
 
Why do you think it's horizontal velocity went to 0? Why wouldn't you consider the fact that it didn't?
Based off the forensics of the crash scene, most witnesses saying it crash "90 deg down", and factoring the official story that it "burrowed" underground.

Can you show me where the explosion went south?
 
Based off the forensics of the crash scene, most witnesses saying it crash "90 deg down", and factoring the official story that it "burrowed" underground.

"Pitch angle - Capt. (deg)" Reads at about 40 degrees. ​
Source: NS Archive/NTSB (Document 4) [PDF] [local] (Click pic for hi-res.)



​
Source: Your website
​
 
Yes, it's very clear if you even bothered to READ:

" *If you disagree with these descriptions in this poll choice, please state how long the photo was taken after UA 93 allegedly crashed, how wide you think the plume was, how far it drifted if at all, and whether you think it dissipating much at the time the photo was taken."

Ooops :blush:
 
EDIT: My attempt to illustrate absurdity by being absurd is, now that I think about it, perhaps a tad too absurd.
(I copy and pasted a random wikipedia article, removing all spacing and indentation, froming a massive, illegible wall of text)

EDIT 2: Too late, Ollie got it. :p
 
Last edited:
Babylon 5 is an epic American science fiction television series created, produced, and largely written by J. Michael Straczynski. The show centred around the titular Babylon 5 space station, which acted as a focal point for politics, diplomacy and wars. It is noted for its heavy reliance on pre-planned story arcs over its five-year run, sometimes described as a 'novel for television'.[1] The pilot movie, The Gathering, aired on February 22, 1993, and the regular series initially aired from January 26, 1994 through November 25, 1998, first in syndication on the short-lived Prime Time Entertainment Network, then on cable network TNT. Because the show was aired every week in the United Kingdom on Channel 4 without a break, the last four or five episodes of the early seasons were shown in the UK before the US. The series won several awards, including two Hugos for Best Dramatic Presentation. J. Michael Straczynski was determined to produce a science fiction series for adults in which, for once, things would be done properly: consistent technology, "no kids or cute robots". He started out with ideas for two different shows, one a vastly ambitious epic covering massive battles and other universe-changing events and the other set in a single space station, before realizing both could be done in a single series.[2] It was not a utopian future — there is greed and homelessness. It was not a place where everything was the same at the end of the day — main characters grow, develop, live, and die. Straczynski wanted the show to be a mirror to the real world and to covertly teach (an idea mentioned by Mark Twain).[3] The Babylon 5 StationUnlike most television shows, this series was conceived as a novel, with a defined beginning, middle, and end. In addition, even tie-in novels, comic books, and short stories play a significant part of the overall story. The show uses an arc-driven storytelling style now prevalent in science fiction and in mainstream drama. In the DVD feature The Making of Babylon 5, Walter Koenig said "It's an exciting uniquely different series that could forever change the way you look at science fiction television" and referred to "groundbreaking special effects and new breathtaking achievements in makeup, sets and costumes." Straczynski anticipated the rise of digital television, shooting the series in 16:9 format rather than the normal 4:3 - a full six years before ER and many other dramas began doing the same thing. Babylon 5 also revolutionized the use of computer technology (using Amiga-based Video Toasters at first, and later Pentium and DEC Alpha-based systems)[4] in creating visual effects at a time when using models and miniatures was the norm. It was also the first sci-fi series to respect Newtonian physics in its space battle sequences, with particular emphasis placed on the effects of inertia. More recent series such as Joss Whedon's Firefly and the Sci-Fi Channel version of Battlestar Galactica have also made similar efforts to simulate realistic physics.[5] [edit] Music and scoring
The original pilot movie had music composed by Stewart Copeland. When the show was picked up as a weekly series Copeland was not available, and so Straczynski hired Christopher Franke, of Tangerine Dream fame. Franke stayed on as the composer for all five seasons of Babylon 5, and three of the Babylon 5 telefilms. When Straczynski obtained funds to create a new writer's edition of the pilot movie, the original Stewart Copeland score was replaced with a new score by Christopher Franke. [edit] Use of the Internet
Main article: Babylon 5's use of the Internet The show was one of the first to employ Internet marketing to create a buzz among online readers far in advance of the airing of the pilot episode. Straczynski participated in online communities on USENET (in the rec.arts.sf.tv.babylon5.moderated newsgroup), and the GEnie and Compuserve systems before the Internet came together as it exists today. Also during this time, Warner Bros. executive Jim Moloshok created and distributed electronic trading cards to help advertise the series. In 1995, Warner Bros. started the Official Babylon 5 web site which was hosted on the now defunct Pathfinder portal. In September 1995 they hired a fan, Troy Rutter, to take over the site and move it not only to its own domain name at www.babylon5.com, but also to oversee the Keyword B5 area on America Online. The fans continued to play an important role in the development of the series and the online support campaign is credited with helping persuade former PTEN station owners to carry the fourth season of the show in 1996.The series consists of a five-year story arc taking place over five seasons of 22 episodes each. John Iacovelli said "Babylon 5 is a window on the future" in the DVD feature Creating the Future, linking to the idea of a space opera. The hub of the story is set in the 23rd century (2258-2262 AD) on a large space station named Babylon 5; the five mile (8 km) long, 2.5 million ton rotating colony is built to be a gathering place for fostering peace through diplomacy, trade, and cooperation. [edit] Babylon stations Babylon 5 orbiting Epsilon IIIIn the show, Babylon 5 is a center of political intrigue and conflict, and eventually takes part in a massive interstellar conflict. This is reflected in the opening monologue of each episode which includes "last, best hope for peace" in season one but changes to "last, best hope for victory" by season three. Babylon 5 is the fifth Babylon space station, a modified version of an O'Neill Cylinder. Three predecessors, the original Babylon station, Babylon 2 and Babylon 3 were all sabotaged and destroyed before their completion. The fourth station, Babylon 4 vanished twenty-four hours after it became fully operational ("Babylon Squared" and "War Without End"). Babylon 5 is substantially smaller than the previous stations due to budget constraints after the failure of the first four stations. The station is set in the Epsilon Eridani star system, orbiting the third planet of that system, "Epsilon III". Bruce Boxleitner, who played station commander Captain John Sheridan, described the space station Babylon 5 as "... A free port for diplomats, travelers and businessmen. A combination of building the United Nations and Times Square on an intergalactic scale...", in the introduction of "The Guide to Babylon 5". Civilizations
Main article: Civilizations in Babylon 5 G'Kar (left) of the Narn Regime and Londo Mollari of the Centauri Republic.At the beginning of the series, Five dominant civilizations are represented. The dominant species are the Humans, Minbari, Narn, Centauri, and the Vorlons. "The Shadows" and their various allies are malevolent species who appear later in the series. The less powerful races make up the League of Non-Aligned Worlds. [edit] "Trap doors" Spoiler warning: Plot and/or ending details follow.
Though conceived as a whole, and with Straczynski writing most of the episodes (including all of the episodes of the third and fourth seasons, a feat never before accomplished in American television[6]) it was necessary to adjust the plotline to accommodate external influences. Each of the characters in the series was written with a "trap door" into their background that, in the event of an actor departing from the series, the character could be written out with minimal negative impact to the story. In the words of Straczynski, "As a writer, doing a long-term story, it'd be dangerous and short-sighted for me to construct the story without trap doors for every single character. [...] That was one of the big risks going into a long-term storyline which I considered long in advance."[7] Major challenges included the replacement of actor Michael O'Hare as the station commander after the first season. Jeffrey Sinclair was intended from the beginning to become Valen.[8] As originally planned, this would have occurred at the end of the series, but with Michael O'Hare's departure at the end of Season One, Sinclair's transformation to Valen was moved up by what became several years.[citation needed] The character of Talia Winters was to have undergone a transformation into a Psi-Corps agent, having been revealed as a "sleeper" whose true personality was buried subconsciously and acted as a spy observing the events on the station and the actions of her command staff. When Thompson left the series, this revelation was turned into a way to remove the character from the series permanently. Had Thomson remained, her "good" persona would have been restored by the use of a data crystal that Kosh had commissioned through the services of a "Vicar"; According to JMS, Kosh had detected the Psi-Corps plot, and had taken steps to salvage what he considered a valuable resource. This plot was never used.[citation needed] Two characters were written out using a pair of intertwining "Trap Doors". When Jason Carter left the series at the end of Season 4, the "Trap Door" calling for Marcus Cole to die in battle was altered so as to literally give his life *to* Susan Ivanova as she lay dying from wounds suffered in battle. In a twist that left the possibility for Cole's return, his body was left in suspended animation on the station to await a new discovery that might resuscitate him. Subsequently, when Claudia Christian left the series at end of Season 4, her character was written out of the series by having Ivanova accept a command of her own on a deep-space exploration mission, her self-realization of her grief over the loss of Marcus being the defining factor in Ivanova's decision to leave.[citation needed]Languages English is mentioned explicitly as the "Earth language of commerce". Hearing other human languages or even their mention is highly uncommon in the series. Ambassador Delenn and Londo Mollari, both alien characters, speak with regional accents similar to Russian and Eastern European slavic countries. All the major human characters speak American English, with the exception of Marcus Cole, who speaks with distinct British Received Pronunciation. Susan Ivanova, born in Russia, speaks with an American accent, but has some posters with writing in the cyrillic alphabet in her room, possibly indicating she knows the language.[citation needed] Her father speaks with a distinct Russian accent, as does her brother. Various other minor human characters speak English with recognizable regional accents. Londo Mollari has a noticeable accent, developed independently by actor Peter Jurasik[9] and most closely imitated by William Forward, who played Lord Refa. In the novels it is described as a "Northern accent" and is considered uncouth.[citation needed] G'Kar has a particular gift for speech and writing in both Narn and English, as is demonstrated particularly from early in the third season onward. The Gaim, Pak'Ma'Ra and Vorlons do not speak directly in English, though in the case of the Vorlons it is not entirely clear that sounds preceding their English speech is their native language. Some companion literature to the series has suggested they simply refuse to learn other languages. This is true for the Pak'Ma'Ra - in the tv series, Lennier asks Delenn what to do with the Pak'Ma'Ra Ranger applicants, since they refuse to learn any language other than their own. Among aliens, only Minbari are shown to speak a different language when humans are present to stress that the humans cannot understand what is being said. When Minbari (or Narn, Centauri, etc.) are shown talking to each other, they are shown as speaking in English (except for a Narn religious ceremony in season 1) although according to creator Joe Straczynski it is presumed they are speaking their native language while the audience hears it as English. Authoritarianism vs. chaos; light vs. dark The central theme in Babylon 5 is the conflict between order and chaos, and the people caught in between. The Vorlons represent an authoritarian philosophy: you will do what we tell you to, because we tell you to do it. The Vorlon Question "who are you?" focuses on the identity as the motivator over personal goals.[10] The Shadows represent chaos. Their belief is that by creating conflict, a stronger generation is born — "survival of the fittest".[11] The question they pose is "what do you want?" Placing desire and ambition before everything else, encouraging conflict between other groups, who choose to serve their own glory or profit.[12] Selfishness is often the turning point of a character from light to darkness, and selflessness denotes a change in the reverse. The stated philosophies of both the Vorlons and the Shadows seem directly in conflict with the effects their presence seems to produce. During the time that the Vorlons are tacitly "in charge" of the known universe, wars and skirmishes seem commonplace. However, as soon as the Shadows increase their presence, an alliance of races begins to form to fight them. ("Z'ha'dum").[edit] War and peace The Babylon 5 universe includes numerous major armed conflicts. The conflicts serve to illustrate specific themes: every conflict has a forgotten "third side," people crushed beneath the feet of the powerful; a single individual willing to sacrifice himself can be more powerful than the greatest army; whereas an individual willing to sacrifice everyone else to serve his own objectives can reduce entire worlds to ashes, and yet still be defeated. Ultimately, every violent conflict is born out of self-interest, perpetuated by prejudice and ideology, and resolved by the realization that each side needs the other to survive. The most clear example of this is the history of the Hyach race: The Hyach evolved alongside the Hyach-Doh, with whom they interbred. Over the course of centuries the Hyach leadership began a process of persecution beginning with religious laws and ending in genocide. It was not until after the last Hyach-Doh had been killed that the Hyach birth-rate began to fall: the Hyach genetic structure needed the Hyach-Doh for them to survive, and by wiping them out they had doomed their race. By the end of the series, we find members of opposing sides working together to forge a new future. [edit] Love Unrequited love is a source of pain in Babylon 5. The losses of characters such as Ivanova and Sinclair are central to the story arc of the first three seasons, while Marcus and Lennier are ultimately destroyed by their love (for Ivanova and Delenn, respectively). Not all love in the show is unrequited, however. Sheridan, for example, returns from the dead after discovering that his love for Delenn is "worth living for" in "Whatever Happened to Mr. Garibaldi?".[13] [edit]Religion One of the aspects of Babylon 5 was that many of its characters had profound spiritual and/or religious beliefs ("The Parliament of Dreams"). Straczynski, an atheist, was determined that the characters and the show would treat all these beliefs with the utmost respect, saying, "religion [...] has always been present. And it will be present 200 years from now. That may not thrill me, but when one is a writer, one must deal with realities, and that's one of them. To totally ignore that part of the human equation would be as false and wrong-headed as ignoring the fact that people get mad, or passionate, or strive for better lives. [...] In the Babylon 5 universe, all the things that make us human -- our obsessions, our interests, our language, our culture, our flaws and our wonderfulnesses -- are all still intact."[14]
Often, a religious or moral question was presented with no clear answer. A perfect example was "Soul Hunter" in which three different interpretations are presented for the Soul Hunters' actions. The moral conflict presented in "Believers" is another example. More important for the overall arc of the program was the large plot thread hinging upon Minbari religious beliefs and the spiritual evolution of G'Kar.

Summarized?

EDIT: Muhawawawaw ... I know - i´m nasty. :D
 
Last edited:
Babylon 5 is an epic American science fiction television series <snip>

<snap>

<snip> the spiritual evolution of G'Kar.

I very much enjoyed Enterprise, or as it was retitled from season 3 onwards Star Trek: Enterprise.

I've got all 4 seasons on DVD. On the one hand I felt sorry the series got canned, on the other hand, I didn't have to spend a lot of money on buying the DVD's.

What I missed in season 4, and partially in season 3 (the Xindi arc) was the premise of humanity's first steps in space discovery, which where portraided very good (IMHO) in the first two seasons.

Also, Jolene Blalock is really hot :D
 
Summarized?

EDIT: Muhawawawaw ... I know - i´m nasty. :D

As I said, I was mocking Killtowns bizarre obsession with the smoke plume by removing the formatting form a wikipedia article. Being a Babylaniac myself, B5 seemed like a good semi-random choice.

@Pardalis & Bell: Star Drek Voyager, 7th season; the episode where 7 0f 9 spends too much time in the holodeck pretending to be a regular person. Hair down, sleveless red dress with scooped neckline... nuff sed. ;)
 
As I said, I was mocking Killtowns bizarre obsession with the smoke plume by removing the formatting form a wikipedia article. Being a Babylaniac myself, B5 seemed like a good semi-random choice.

@Pardalis & Bell: Star Drek Voyager, 7th season; the episode where 7 0f 9 spends too much time in the holodeck pretending to be a regular person. Hair down, sleveless red dress with scooped neckline... nuff sed. ;)

I never really watched VOY (trekkie lingo - but I'm not a trekkie, mind you) so I missed that (best?) part of the series.

Pardalis, yes. They can make me their slave any day :D
 
You guys are:
love072.gif



:D
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom