Merged Yemen war: Houthi rebels claim mass capture of Saudi troops

The Atheist

Psychopath
Joined
Jul 3, 2006
Messages
38,213
I so badly want this to be true:

Houthis claim capture of thousands of troops in Saudi raid

Given the uselessness of the Saudi army, it's entirely possible, and it seems an odd claim to make when disproving it would be so easy.

If true, it will change the entire complexion of the "war" between Saudi & Yemen and will be a serious problem for the Saudi alliance, because the Houthi will be holding all four aces as a bargaining tool.
 
Houthi rebels in Yemen say they have captured a large number of Saudi troops after a major attack near the border between the two countries.

A Houthi spokesman told the BBC that three Saudi brigades had surrendered near the Saudi town of Najran.

He said thousands of soldiers had been captured and many others killed. Saudi officials have not confirmed the claim.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-middle-east-49866677

Three Brigades?

If this is true then that's a major blow for the Saudi Army!
 
This war is in many ways a template for the coming wars in the 21st century.

Main lesson: you can't buy battlefield victory.

SA has every available benefit money can buy, but it doesn't have the experience.

This could very well be the beginning of the end of MBS's reign.
 
I so badly want this to be true:

Houthis claim capture of thousands of troops in Saudi raid

Given the uselessness of the Saudi army, it's entirely possible, and it seems an odd claim to make when disproving it would be so easy.

If true, it will change the entire complexion of the "war" between Saudi & Yemen and will be a serious problem for the Saudi alliance, because the Houthi will be holding all four aces as a bargaining tool.
Good news for the UK arms industry when the Saudis decide to replace the weapons and vehicles they lost to the Houthis. There's a silver lining on every black cloud, you know.
 
The Atheist has already started a thread on this but he does insist on putting up obscure thread titles for them.

No kidding. I didn't bother with that thread because I thought he was referring to the prince admitting responsibility for the reporter's murder in a totally fake way.
 
They've just given a press conference.

YPA said:
SANAA, Sept. 29 (YPA) – Yemen’s army Spokesman said on Sunday that over 2,000 Saudi-led coalition fighters were captured, including children and foreigners in the military operation in Najran region.

Saria said in a statement to broadcast a video showing the Yemeni army carried out a major operation against the border military sites in south of Saudi Arabia.

More than 2,000 coalition fighters were captured, including children and foreigners.” Saria added.
Saria said “hundreds of coalition military vehicles and large quantities of arms were seized in the operation, ‘Victory from God’.”

The spokesman affirmed that the rocket forces carried out nine operations against targeting enemy headquarters and military bases, including airports. [...]


Not really surprising. They've crossed the border into KSA many times to do operations there. This must be the largest one so far, though.
 
Video released shows a few vehicles being attacked and some small arms captured.

No video of thousands of prisoners though.
 
This war is in many ways a template for the coming wars in the 21st century.

Main lesson: you can't buy battlefield victory.

SA has every available benefit money can buy, but it doesn't have the experience.

This could very well be the beginning of the end of MBS's reign.

In order of your points: yes, yes, yes, and I sincerely hope so.

There's the slimmest possibility that the powers behind the throne of Saud begin to realise they screwed up, and if MBS ends up with his head on a chopping block, it will be richly deserved.

Let the negotiations begin.

Still haven't seen the captives.

I did like one bit of the Houthi commander bloke's statement - that he was holding them at a safe, secret location to protect them from Saudi air strikes.
 
Was in a different thread at that stage.

Still not helluva convincing in terms of the claims made. I see no large group of Saudi officers, which would be pretty easy to show, as they'll be in uniform.

Easy to dress up people in uniform. What they can do is display documentation showing the name, rank and serial numbers of the solders captured. Plus tons of equipment that is operational. And if there serial numbers on that then show that. This would show the suppliers where their equipment is.
 
I haven't heard the Saudi deny it - I would assume that
a. they would know and
b. they would tell if it wasn't true
 
Three whole Brigades would look a lot more impressive than that.

A Brigade is a big formation, how would they guard that many prisoners?
Where are the many dozens of vehicles?

Some countries armies are only 3 brigades!
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom