WTCs1,2 Visual Facts for What Happened, Audio/Visual Facts for What Didn't Happen

(It Doesn't Matter Whether a One-Way Crush Down Is Possible, Or Whether the Floors Braced the Core)

Conclusion:
All the visual facts confirm the gravity collapse of the Towers.
All the visual facts refute the use of explosives/thermite in the collapse of the Towers.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
You can't reason someone out of something he was never reasoned into. - Swift

I have a question: What on earth is a gravity collapse?

I have an observation: If you drop an object on another object, one result is a big BANG (unless the objects are cotton or similar).
 
I have a question: What on earth is a gravity collapse?

I have an observation: If you drop an object on another object, one result is a big BANG (unless the objects are cotton or similar).

I have a question for you, what happens when the weight of thirteen floors falls on one suspended floor ?

I also have an observation, you continue to post off topic, when are you going to post on topic, address the OP and stop derailing threads ?
 
Last edited:
<snip>

I have an observation: If you drop an object on another object, one result is a big BANG (unless the objects are cotton or similar).

Gotcha! In a classic controlled demolition (you can find them on youtube) the loud explosions are immediately preceding the collapse/implosion. Very easy (even for a marine architect) to hear, and quite unique.

But as the building then implodes, there are no more loud explosions, just rumbling sounds. That's the difference - When the bottom of part C is dropped onto the top of part A, there is no big BANG! It is clearly just a gravitational collapse sequence, without explosives.
When the floor system of A collides with the floor system of the next floor (part of C!) it carries more than enough momentum to destroy that floor, which then destroys the next floor, using gravity to do the work!!

Controlled demolitions also rely on gravity to do most of the work. That's why we know that none of the WTC buildings were destroyed by that method, because of the lack of demolition explosions just before the collapse initiation.
 
Gotcha! In a classic controlled demolition (you can find them on youtube) the loud explosions are immediately preceding the collapse/implosion. Very easy (even for a marine architect) to hear, and quite unique.

But as the building then implodes, there are no more loud explosions, just rumbling sounds. That's the difference -

Just 'rumbling sound' when you rip steel elements apart??

I agree that in classic controlled demolition you start with EXPLOSIVES down below, BANG, BANG, BANG, etc, and WTC 1 was clearly not such an event. WTC 1 is supposed to be a one-way crush down by gravity - upper part crushing down lower part producing a rumbling sound - by gravity only! Unheard of and never seen before/after 911. Actually physically impossible as shown in other threads at JREF and on the Internet. And it seems a lot of people incl. NYFD staff heard BANG, BANG, BANGS when WTC 1 and 2 were destroyed.
 
Just 'rumbling sound' when you rip steel elements apart??

I agree that in classic controlled demolition you start with EXPLOSIVES down below, BANG, BANG, BANG, etc, and WTC 1 was clearly not such an event. WTC 1 is supposed to be a one-way crush down by gravity - upper part crushing down lower part producing a rumbling sound - by gravity only! Unheard of and never seen before/after 911. Actually physically impossible as shown in other threads at JREF and on the Internet. And it seems a lot of people incl. NYFD staff heard BANG, BANG, BANGS when WTC 1 and 2 were destroyed.

WTC 1 isn't 'supposed' to be anything at all. It was just a plane impact/fire induced collapse, due to circumstances that you correctly state have never been seen before or since.

You seem surprised that a unique event wouldn't be like anything else. Well, duh. No other 110 story steelframe buildings had ever been hit by giant jets traveling at over 400 mph.

Clearly it wasn't physically impossible for the collapse to happen due to those circumstances, because it actually happened right in front of the world, without explosive demolition.

And yes, there were loud sounds, but as you can hear on the audio, no explosive detonations consistent with controlled demolition.

Only the most hardcore paranoiacs and dissemblers insist that it was controlled demolition. Everyone else accepts reality the way it is, and has moved on already.
 
You know what's impossible Heiwa? Trying to deny a causal relationship between plane impacts, fires and the collapses.

Stick to marine architecture and you'll be fine. You're way out of your depth with this subject.
 
Just 'rumbling sound' when you rip steel elements apart??
Essentially no structural steel was "ripped apart". What broke, broke at the joints, many of which were bolts. . The " pop pop pop" reported by many witnesses is consistant with rows of bolts giving way.
I agree that in classic controlled demolition you start with EXPLOSIVES down below, BANG, BANG, BANG, etc, and WTC 1 was clearly not such an event. WTC 1 is supposed to be a one-way crush down by gravity - upper part crushing down lower part producing a rumbling sound - by gravity only! Unheard of and never seen before/after 911.

I suppose Truth sites are not big on quoting architect Bob Shelton who was on the 56th floor on the morning of 9/11. He heard the same noises you cherry-pick yet he knew he was hearing a building in the process of collapsing.

On the 56th floor, an architect believes the building was failing
structurally. Architect Bob Shelton had his foot in a cast; he'd broken it falling off a curb two weeks ago. He heard the explosion of the first plane hitting the north tower from his 56th-floor office in the south tower. As he made his way down the stairwell, his building came under attack as well. "You could hear the building cracking. It sounded like when you have a bunch of spaghetti, and you break it in half to boil it." Shelton knew that what he was hearing was bad. "It was structural failure," Shelton says. "Once a building like that is off center, that's it."


So what? WTC was unlike any other structure in the world.

In Report From Ground Zero (pgs 310-311), FDNY structures expert Vincent Dunn describes how the WTC towers had effectively no fireproofing when comparred to the older steel buildings, built to standards that required 2 inches of brick and masonry on all structural steel. Dunn also says that the WTC towers were unique in the minimal fireproofing.

Page 310, Report From Ground Zero;

http://snurl.com/j54ud [books_google_com]

Who is Vincent Dunn?
http://unjobs.org/authors/vincent-dunn
 
Just 'rumbling sound' when you rip steel elements apart??

I agree that in classic controlled demolition you start with EXPLOSIVES down below, BANG, BANG, BANG, etc, and WTC 1 was clearly not such an event. WTC 1 is supposed to be a one-way crush down by gravity - upper part crushing down lower part producing a rumbling sound - by gravity only! Unheard of and never seen before/after 911. Actually physically impossible as shown in other threads at JREF and on the Internet. And it seems a lot of people incl. NYFD staff heard BANG, BANG, BANGS when WTC 1 and 2 were destroyed.

again you dont understand "new yorker" and our use of similes
he was describing what he saw not what he heard
the "booms" he said were for emphasis along with his hand gestures (again english is very tough when youre listening to new yorkers decimate the language, as i do on a daily basis)

and its FDNY, please get it right
 
Just 'rumbling sound' when you rip steel elements apart??

I agree that in classic controlled demolition you start with EXPLOSIVES down below, BANG, BANG, BANG, etc, and WTC 1 was clearly not such an event. WTC 1 is supposed to be a one-way crush down by gravity - upper part crushing down lower part producing a rumbling sound - by gravity only! Unheard of and never seen before/after 911. Actually physically impossible as shown in other threads at JREF and on the Internet. And it seems a lot of people incl. NYFD staff heard BANG, BANG, BANGS when WTC 1 and 2 were destroyed.

Out of all the visual/audio facts provided, this is all that you can come up with? That one opinion can disprove all the many facts?

Is this the best you got?

It doesn't matter if a one-way crush down is possible or not, whether the floors braced the core columns or not, whether the fire temperatures were hot enough, whether ...

Your hypothesis is contradicted by the visual facts and is therefore wrong.
You still don't understand , the visual facts prove your hypothesis wrong.
And again -No amount of exclamation points disprove the visual facts.
Yet understanding you remain -You cannot argue away the visual facts by what you believe is possible or impossible.
One more time - you're arguing that your hypothesis is true and the contradicting audio/visual facts false.

Because you cannot read good and have inadequate comprehension:

Abstract:
(from OP)
Regarding WTCs1,2 Audio/Visual Facts

Hypotheses that contradict the visual facts are wrong.
Not all hypotheses that agree with the visual facts are right.
Restated: Where in conflict, the visual facts trump all hypotheses. You can argue about causes, but you can’t argue with facts.

“I pass with relief from the tossing sea of cause and theory to the firm ground of result and fact.” -Churchill

Visual Facts For What Happened: ONE. Perimeter columns gradually buckled and collapsed at the failed floors. TWO. Floor slabs subsequently collapsed inside the perimeter and core columns. THREE. Perimeter and core columns, not crushed nor exploded, subsequently toppled to the ground.

Audio/Visual Facts For What Didn’t Happen: ONE. No expected CD loud detonation sounds. TWO. No evidence for expected explosives/thermite damage to columns or spandrel plates. Evidence of large sections of connected, unexploded, unshattered toppled core and perimeter columns. THREE. CD explosives-ejected perimeter columns should have outdistanced the dust cloud behind them, they did not.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
You can't reason someone out of something he was never reasoned into. - Swift

The audio/visual facts are sufficient to know what happened , what didn't happen and are indisputable. The mechanism and explanation for the causes are more complex, can be disputed, but cannot trump the visual facts.
The above OP facts stand and your contrary opinion is false and worthless.
 
Last edited:
Just 'rumbling sound' when you rip steel elements apart??

I agree that in classic controlled demolition you start with EXPLOSIVES down below, BANG, BANG, BANG, etc, and WTC 1 was clearly not such an event. WTC 1 is supposed to be a one-way crush down by gravity - upper part crushing down lower part producing a rumbling sound - by gravity only! Unheard of and never seen before/after 911. Actually physically impossible as shown in other threads at JREF and on the Internet. And it seems a lot of people incl. NYFD staff heard BANG, BANG, BANGS when WTC 1 and 2 were destroyed.

If I was a gullible fool I would take you at your word and not bother reading the fire fighters statements. But since I am not a gullible fool I have read their statements and not one of them supports your insane theories. Not one fire-fighter who was there has stepped forward in support of your CD theory.

I find it sad that you resort to such pathetic and transparent cherry picking of those that were there to try and support your position. A position that as been shown to be impossibly false right from the start. I can only guess that you are so desperate for attention now, that any means justify the ends. And this is the sum total of your contribution to the understanding of the events of Sept 11th, zero. Your only contribution is to drive your own agenda forward, disregard all engineering principles and pour scorn on those who make an effort to understand this dreadful event or even take the time to show you where you are mistaken.

I could go on, but I will not, as I have no desire to give you the smug satisfaction of getting me suspended or even banned for calling you what you are. If you are the sum total of the efforts of the truth movement, if you are deemed one of the critical thinkers of this movement then it is little wonder you have achieved zero in almost eight years.


Sorry for the derail and apologies BasqueArch, this will be my last reply to this member in this thread.
 
Last edited:
Here are the 4 fixed broken links from the OP :


TWO. No evidence for expected explosives/thermite damage to columns or spandrel plates. Evidence of large sections of connected, unexploded, unshattered toppled core and perimeter columns.
For explosives/thermite to have been used in the CD of the exterior columns, only two hidden places were available: (1)The plenum space between the lay-in ceiling tile directly under the floor trusses and the floor deck above. Explosive/thermite charges would be visible within this plenum, and (2) the hand access holes at the base/head locations of the columns.
(1) Picture of floors and spandrel plate at this location. Note access construction holes for bolting ends of columns.
http://www.911hoax.com/911Blogger_1-4_perimeter-column.jpg
(2) The hand access holes provided at the head and base of each 36 foot column to install the columns four connecting bolts. Picture of holes at 6 feet above the floor below, 36 feet oc. Placement of explosives/thermite inside of columns.
http://i49.photobucket.com/albums/f290/pjs501/wtcpanelbolts.jpg
http://images.quickblogcast.com/81199-71081/2_7_exterior_wall.jpg
(3) WTC2 columns impaled in Bankers Trust building; no CD damage to WTC2 columns bases or spandrels from explosives/thermite. Columns toppled.
http://www.studyof911.com/gallery/albums/userpics/10002/normal_BTflyingcolumns.jpg[/QUOTE]
 
Last edited:
Stateofgrace, no derail at all, my exact opinions. Thank you for saving me the typing.
 
Last edited:
Conclusion:
All the visual facts confirm the gravity collapse of the Towers.
All the visual facts refute the use of explosives/thermite in the collapse of the Towers.

In your dreams maybe.
None of that explains the facts at the scene.
Gravity didnt blew up the contents of the towers 800 feet radially and pulverize the contents so thoroughly that of the roughly 2600 people in the towers, 1100 are completely unaccounted for. (and then this 'gravity' left the basements intact. uhuh.


GRAVITY AT WORK:


 
Not one fire-fighter who was there has stepped forward in support of your CD theory.

It's not her (or his) theory. It is simply the best fitting hypothesis to explain observed events and it (CD) is supported by a mountain of highly compelling evidence. (obviously dismissed or not encountered by you)

Most damning of course is the fact that the towers were completely shredded in a cacophony of powerful explosions over a 15 - 17 second period. Apparently this kept most people from thinking it was an explosion/
In fact it was many thousands of explosions. (*not all, there is an overwhelming amount of witness testimony of explosions)

and WTC7 fell into its footprint. Neatly

The explosions are clear as day in many videos:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dtx_GcFCs6c
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=toUdpeI04pM


Not one fire-fighter who was there has stepped forward in support of your CD theory.
wrong again, http://firefightersfor911truth.org


It is one thing to demonize and dismiss people with a few sharp but simple words. It is more difficult to explain the facts as we know them and put forth a hypothesis that makes sense. That is what we are hoping for.

Gravity aint it!


 
wrong again, http://firefightersfor911truth.org

It is one thing to demonize and dismiss people with a few sharp but simple words. It is more difficult to explain the facts as we know them and put forth a hypothesis that makes sense. That is what we are hoping for.

WRONG. Read what I wrote.

Not one fire-fighter who was there has stepped forward in support of your CD theory.

The person that runs the site you just linked was not there. Where are the fire fighter who were there that support you ?
Not those who's statements you cherry pick but actual fire fighters who were there and support the CD theory.

ETA .There was a thread about this site not so long ago and what real fire fighters thought about it, I would link it but sorry I can't find it just now.
 
Last edited:
and WTC7 fell into its footprint. Neatly

Then why did it smash into neighbouring buildings?

verizondamagedetail.jpg


wtc30wbroadwaydamagefroju6.jpg
 
Not one fire-fighter who was there has stepped forward in support of your CD theory.

how would you know that? Ive spoken to many NYC firefighters, and I can assure you you're dead wrong! But why would you believe me You don't believe your own eyes.

here's a clip shows u'r wrong
In fact, controlled demolition was many people's first reaction./ (especially w/re WTC7) What you want them to join infowars? ("Come out")
Please.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SXD3bAbZCow

even a cursory look at the Oral Histories show many examples of people thinking explosives were involved at the time.
Others that say explosives, and then qualify it afterwords
(i.e. I thought there were explosions going off but was later 'proven' it was a collapse) -he never offers what the 'proof' is. (the official story)
Explosives is what the evidence shows.


"Somewhere around the middle of the World Trade Center, there was this orange and red flash coming out. Initially it was just one flash. Then this flash just kept popping all the way around the building and that building had started to explode. The popping sound, and with each popping sound it was initially an orange and then red flash came out of the building and then it would just go all around the building on both sides as far as I could see. These popping sounds and the explosions were getting bigger, going both up and down and then all around the building. I went inside and told everybody that the other building or there was an explosion occurring up
there and I said I think we have another major explosion..."

"As I just got in under the entrance there, I got just a little ways back and it was just like -- you hear the noise, a boom, and then a blast of air."

"we started to hear the second roar. That was the north tower now coming down. I should say that people in the street and myself included thought that the roar was so loud that the explosive - bombs were going off inside the building."

There are 117 others like this in the group of 500 interviews.



"The great enemy of the truth is very often not the lie, deliberate, contrived and dishonest, but the myth—persistent, persuasive and unrealistic."
—John F. Kennedy

"Those who have suggested 9/11 was an inside job have a much stronger case than those who are trying to support the official narrative of the 19 hijackers."
- Professor Graeme MacQueen
Founding Director, Centre for Peace Studies
McMaster University
 
WRONG. Read what I wrote.
The person that runs the site you just linked was not there. Where are the fire fighter who were there that support you ?
Not those who's statements you cherry pick but actual fire fighters who were there and support the CD theory.

ETA .There was a thread about this site not so long ago and what real fire fighters thought about it, I would link it but sorry I can't find it just now.

But it's more than this. If it's all so obvious, why is still a pack of anonymous folk from the 911 skeptics community posting on this? The evidence for thermite is so intriguing? Then why haven't the thermite experts from Texas Tech's Combustion Lab taken over the call from Steve and Alex Jones (no relationship)? Why are our JREFF friends still anonymous nobodies instead of the leading authorities on the demolition of large buildings? Why is it that 911 Truth demonstrations only attract a couple of dozen people, at best? Why is that there are no major personalities - political, or otherwise - except the well-known fornicator Charlie Sheen, who publically support 911 skepticism?

It's really pretty straight forward. Things are the way they're supposed to be. Neo and Morpheus were characters in a movie. Kids off the street do not know more about building demolition than people who do it for a living. Scientists with doctorates understand complex chemical reactions better than Youtube videos. People who think the world is run differently belong to labelled categories. Some of them are witches. Some of them are astrologers. Others are better described by names banned on the JREFF.
 
Last edited:
how would you know that? Ive spoken to many NYC firefighters, and I can assure you you're dead wrong! But why would you believe me You don't believe your own eyes.

here's a clip shows u'r wrong
In fact, controlled demolition was many people's first reaction./ (especially w/re WTC7) What you want them to join infowars? ("Come out")
Please.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SXD3bAbZCow

even a cursory look at the Oral Histories show many examples of people thinking explosives were involved at the time.
Others that say explosives, and then qualify it afterwords
(i.e. I thought there were explosions going off but was later 'proven' it was a collapse) -he never offers what the 'proof' is. (the official story)
Explosives is what the evidence shows.


"Somewhere around the middle of the World Trade Center, there was this orange and red flash coming out. Initially it was just one flash. Then this flash just kept popping all the way around the building and that building had started to explode. The popping sound, and with each popping sound it was initially an orange and then red flash came out of the building and then it would just go all around the building on both sides as far as I could see. These popping sounds and the explosions were getting bigger, going both up and down and then all around the building. I went inside and told everybody that the other building or there was an explosion occurring up
there and I said I think we have another major explosion..."

"As I just got in under the entrance there, I got just a little ways back and it was just like -- you hear the noise, a boom, and then a blast of air."

"we started to hear the second roar. That was the north tower now coming down. I should say that people in the street and myself included thought that the roar was so loud that the explosive - bombs were going off inside the building."

There are 117 others like this in the group of 500 interviews.

"The great enemy of the truth is very often not the lie, deliberate, contrived and dishonest, but the myth—persistent, persuasive and unrealistic."
—John F. Kennedy

"Those who have suggested 9/11 was an inside job have a much stronger case than those who are trying to support the official narrative of the 19 hijackers."
- Professor Graeme MacQueen
Founding Director, Centre for Peace Studies
McMaster University

This is de ja vu I've heard all this before. These are all very, very, very old arguments. I'm sorry, but I personally am not going to take time from the rest of my life to deal with all of them. I would rather eat soap than do that. It is interesting though, that Professor MacQueen, whom you cite as having something meaningful to say, no longer speaks about 911. This might be because, as a profesor of religious studies, he has absolutley no technical or scientific experience at all. I also once posted a great quote of his where he states that firefighters have shown no interest at all in theories of controlled demolition on 911. I posted it up here already, so you can find it for yourself.

Why do you think that tired old arguments about how 'experts' really do believe in controlled demolition would fly here?
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom