WTC Dust Study Feb 29, 2012 by Dr. James Millette

Ok MM, what are you saying ?

Millette examined the wrong chips because he didn't have the correct dust ?

He had the correct dust but falsified the results because he knows it was an inside job and didn't want to get into trouble ?

He had the correct dust but he doesn't have the knowledge to establish if thermite is present ?

Chris Mohr payed him off ?

Or is it a case of you making up any old crap up to keep the dream alive ?

My money is on this one http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w9aYrHzEW-w&feature=youtube
 
"Millette examined the wrong chips because he didn't have the correct dust ?"

Millette had/has an ample supple of 9/11 WTC dust.

"He had the correct dust but falsified the results because he knows it was an inside job and didn't want to get into trouble ?"

He selected samples that failed (as I and others have repeatedly shown), to match those highlighted in the 2009 Bentham paper.

"He had the correct dust but he doesn't have the knowledge to establish if thermite is present ?"

Again, he had/has an ample supple of 9/11 WTC dust. What he doesn't appear to have is any interest in pursuing an investigation that might provide support for the 2009 Bentham paper findings.

"Chris Mohr payed him off ?"

Chris Mohr handed over $1,000 for an investigation that was underway and that Dr. Millette was previously committed to performing anyway.

"Or is it a case of you making up any old crap up to keep the dream alive ?"

Unfortunately, 9/11 was not just a bad dream.

MM
 
Again, he had/has an ample supple of 9/11 WTC dust. What he doesn't appear to have is any interest in pursuing an investigation that might provide support for the 2009 Bentham paper findings.

MM

I can agree with this. Personally, I'd like to see the Bentham authors actually support their findings.

Maybe they could do another paper with all their data? :rolleyes:
 
Millette had/has an ample supple of 9/11 WTC dust.



He selected samples that failed (as I and others have repeatedly shown), to match those highlighted in the 2009 Bentham paper.



Again, he had/has an ample supple of 9/11 WTC dust. What he doesn't appear to have is any interest in pursuing an investigation that might provide support for the 2009 Bentham paper findings.



Chris Mohr handed over $1,000 for an investigation that was underway and that Dr. Millette was previously committed to performing anyway.



Unfortunately, 9/11 was not just a bad dream.

MM

But Steven Jones claimed that He saw thermite pouring from the tower before he even started work on the paper.

Yes unfortunately 9/11 was not just a bad dream. I just can't understand why you fantasise with your thermite dream?
 
He selected samples that failed (as I and others have repeatedly shown), to match those highlighted in the 2009 Bentham paper.

He followed the Bentham selection protocol.

Did Harrit et al just get lucky in selecting the supposed thermitic chips, while Millette got unlucky?

Ain't proper science a bitch?
 
Last edited:
He followed the Bentham selection protocol.

Did Harrit et al just get lucky in selecting the supposed thermitic chips, while Millette got unlucky?

Ain't proper science a bitch?

If you consider hundreds of observed ignitions by Dr. Harrit et al and Mark Basile "lucky"?

How many chips do you know of that Millette even tried to ignite using the Bentham protocols?

Science is only a bitch when you ignore it.

MM
 
Could you document which chips those were? :rolleyes:

Are you calling Mark Basile, Dr. Harrit, Dr. Farrer, Dr. Jones etc all liars if I do not?

Can you currently provide documented DNA evidence proving your father is who you think he is?

I am certain he can, just as I am certain those scientists documented their research.

MM
 
Are you calling Mark Basile, Dr. Harrit, Dr. Farrer, Dr. Jones etc all liars if I do not?

Can you currently provide documented DNA evidence proving your father is who you think he is?

I am certain he can, just as I am certain those scientists documented their research.

MM

Thought so. Faith is a curious thing.

Nice try at the redirect tough. ;)
 
Last edited:
It's called trust, respect, and documented accountability.

MM
So, faith based.

Who are they accountable to? None of their target audience would ever doubt them. No one else seems to know they exist.

Case in point. They said they had additional data to prove their case (years ago). Has any believer ever asked them why they refuse to release it?
 
It's called trust, respect, and documented accountability.

MM

The trust and respect are based on what? If, say, they promised something, or said they had it, and then they didn't provide it, would that violate accountability? What if new data came to light, and they didn't account for it or respond, such as alternate primer formulation? In fact, don't you owe it to them to bring such things to light, and ask for them to answer these questions, in the best interests of science?
 
So, faith based.

Who are they accountable to? None of their target audience would ever doubt them. No one else seems to know they exist.

Case in point. They said they had additional data to prove their case (years ago). Has any believer ever asked them why they refuse to release it?
They actually are accountable to their target audience, and an astonishingly large percentage of their target audience is skeptical to downright rejecting of their conclusions. The YouTube video I'm working on now features a series of 9/11 Truth people from various factions expressing their belief that the 2009 thermitic paper is invalid. You will see that many people in their target audience DO doubt them.
 
They actually are accountable to their target audience, and an astonishingly large percentage of their target audience is skeptical to downright rejecting of their conclusions. The YouTube video I'm working on now features a series of 9/11 Truth people from various factions expressing their belief that the 2009 thermitic paper is invalid. You will see that many people in their target audience DO doubt them.

So now you are resorting to paying off truthers :D

MM is not going to be happy about this :rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
They actually are accountable to their target audience, and an astonishingly large percentage of their target audience is skeptical to downright rejecting of their conclusions.

The YouTube video I'm working on now features a series of 9/11 Truth people from various factions expressing their belief that the 2009 thermitic paper is invalid.

You will see that many people in their target audience DO doubt them.

???

Semantics.

The key here is your use of "target audience".

You and anyone who accepts the official story represent the "target audience".

The fact that you Chris, and others of the "target audience", "doubt" scientists reporting controversial, anti-official story findings, is not a revelation or in the least bit surprising.

MM
 
The fact that you Chris, and others of the "target audience", "doubt" scientists reporting controversial, anti-official story findings, is not a revelation or in the least bit surprising.

MM

We "doubt" these scientists because their data does not support their conclusions. Their hope that we would take their word for it is not working.

Maybe they can release all that conclusive data you say they have? :rolleyes:
 
???

Semantics.

The key here is your use of "target audience".

You and anyone who accepts the official story represent the "target audience".

The fact that you Chris, and others of the "target audience", "doubt" scientists reporting controversial, anti-official story findings, is not a revelation or in the least bit surprising.

MM
Sorry MM I was "defining" target audience as people who already hold a belief in or accept the possibility of some version of the 9/11 CD theory in the broadest sense (which could also include mininukes, no-planes, space rays, LIHOP, etc). But you're right, their target audience includes anyone they hope might be convinceable. Using my definition, however, I will say that I was surprised at how many people within 9/11 Truth reject the 2009 thermitic paper.
 
We "doubt" these scientists because their data does not support their conclusions. Their hope that we would take their word for it is not working.

Maybe they can release all that conclusive data you say they have? :rolleyes:

If you feel so data-deprived than go ask the source.

Dr. Farrer said:
"I have always shown the additional data to those that have requested it.

I have absolutely nothing to hide with the data that was collected for this paper."

https://lambda.byu.edu/ae/prod/person/cgi/sendEmail.cgi

MM
 
Sorry MM I was "defining" target audience as people who already hold a belief in or accept the possibility of some version of the 9/11 CD theory in the broadest sense (which could also include mininukes, no-planes, space rays, LIHOP, etc).

But you're right, their target audience includes anyone they hope might be convinceable.

Using my definition, however, I will say that I was surprised at how many people within 9/11 Truth reject the 2009 thermitic paper.
bolding is mine

Using my definition of your definition, I am surprised that many of those people actually read the 2009 Bentham paper, or had sufficient comprehension to form a basis for rejecting it.

Of course you do not reveal anything about your polling methods or what data caused your "surprise"?

Vague innuendo and subjective analysis does not make for quality investigative journalism.

MM
 
If you feel so data-deprived than go ask the source.



https://lambda.byu.edu/ae/prod/person/cgi/sendEmail.cgi

MM
I'm fine with the data in the "peer-reviewed" paper.

I just wonder why they wouldn't include the data that actually proves their conclusion. Are you also curious about this or are you happy to just take their word for it?

For me, it really doesn't matter. There is no conceivable way the material they suggest would be useful in the manner they suggest. The whole idea is a fail.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom