Would Rev Alamo received more leniency from an atheist judge?

Cainkane1

Philosopher
Joined
Jul 16, 2005
Messages
9,011
Location
The great American southeast
Can a judge use his court to judge according to his own particular religious bias?

I read this article and a variety of controversial thoughts raced through my mind.
The story was about an evangelist, Tony Alamo, who was recently sentenced for using his stature as a self-proclaimed prophet to "force underage girls into sham marriages with him, and controlling his followers with their fears of eternal suffering." Doesn't this sound like his followers were a bunch of people who deserved being deluded (if that is what they want to call it)?

Nevertheless, the part that I found interesting was that the judge who sentenced Alamo to 175 years in prison for child sexual abuse warned of another kind of justice awaiting the aging evangelist. The judge said, "Mr. Alamo, one day you will face a higher and a greater judge than me, may he have mercy on your soul."

It's obvious that this judge believes in some sort of God who will eventually judge the criminals he sentences to prison. He also believes that what Alamo did was a serous sin as well as against the law. Such raises the questions, did the judge permit is religious bias to interfere with his judgment? Can a judge use such religious bias in sentencing? Can this defendant appeal his case and get a retrial based on the judges admitted religious bias? Would this man have received a more fair trial with a judge that doesn’t believe that there is a God that punishes everybody for sinning?

A friend of mine had this on his webpage. The article is his not mine.
 
Last edited:
Can a judge use his court to judge according to his own particular religious bias?

I read this article and a variety of controversial thoughts raced through my mind.
The story was about an evangelist, Tony Alamo, who was recently sentenced for using his stature as a self-proclaimed prophet to "force underage girls into sham marriages with him, and controlling his followers with their fears of eternal suffering." Doesn't this sound like his followers were a bunch of people who deserved being deluded (if that is what they want to call it)?

Blaming the victim is rarely a good start to a thoughtful post.

I don't think there's any reason to believe that a theist judge would be less lenient than an atheist judge; an atheist judge could just as easily decide that precisely because there's no afterlife or judgement after death, he needs to punish Alamo more harshly for his mistreatment of his followers (because no one else will do it in the judge's stead). An atheist judge could also decide that because religious people are all a bunch of self-deluded dupes, Alamo's pretence to religious leadership is no different than Pope Benedict's.

People are people. Different people are different.
 
If I had been a judge I would have given this pervert pretty much the same sentence. 175 years for putting your nasty hands on a child is sufficient punishment. This physically and mentally ill old buzzard got what he deserved I an atheist can't imagine anything worse.
 
I would hope that any judge would uphold the Constitution and treat all cases equally, regardless of his or her personal religious convictions.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom