Woo wins again

wilks

Scholar
Joined
Feb 8, 2006
Messages
76
I'm about to be banned from a self help forum for posting against homeopathy.

The conversation went something like this.
Someone recommends homeopathic treatment for arthritis.
I say that there is no evidence that this works.
Someone says, yes it works, because it cured her goat's mastitis.
Someone else says it must work because doctors prescribe it.
I say that just because doctors prescribe homeopathy doesn't mean they are not fools.

Mods jump in and make me apologise because I am implying that anyone who believes in homeopathy is a fool.
All right, I'm not trying to be nasty, I apologise if anyone thought that.

Someone says it's OK because it's natural.
I say, natural doesn't mean it works or is safe (yes, I know homeopathy is safe).
Mods jump in and say we shouldn't be discussing whether or not meds work.
I ask why people are allowed to post recommending alternative therapies if no-one is allowed to point out their disadvantages.
Moderator takes huff, says no-one is banning anything, just stop speaking out against homeopathy.
I don't stop.

I know you guys get into these sort of arguments all the time (well done you!) but I didn't 'want' to get banned so I'm feeling pretty bad right now.
Has anyone any advice for hanging on in there? Or do you just have to ignore the woo posts and not cause controversy?

(I would like to point out that the most abrasive thing I said was to hint that homeopathic doctors were fools - I always try to be pleasant and friendly when I post anything).
 
Ask them why you should stop. Is there a rule against presenting arguments and evidence against homeopathy?
 
that sounds like a frightening forum since it deals with "medicine" but doesnt allow dissenting views. unfortunately i guess you are in a forum where, if you shared your info, there would be no need to have the forum!
 
point out the flaws in their anecdotes...

Pragmatic fallacy?

Placebo not accounted for?

Regressive fallacy?

Testimonial evidence with confirmation bias?

Change in environmental factors?


Keep it civil and objective, and fight them with science! :D
 
Someone says it's OK because it's natural.
I say, natural doesn't mean it works or is safe (yes, I know homeopathy is safe).
Mods jump in and say we shouldn't be discussing whether or not meds work.
I ask why people are allowed to post recommending alternative therapies if no-one is allowed to point out their disadvantages.
Moderator takes huff, says no-one is banning anything, just stop speaking out against homeopathy.
I don't stop.

Obviously, this is another case of people having a little bit of knowledge about what homeopathy is supposed to be, but not enough to realize right away it's a bunch of manure. If they come up with such lame arguments as "homeopathy is all natural", then they obviously never heard of some of the more exotic remedies out there (like "Berlin Wall" or a number of heavy metals and radioactive elements).

The trick with any woo-belief is that you can kill it if you catch it in the early stages (i.e. you give someone enough information to figure out for themselves that it doesn't make any sense). If you wait until someone has tried it, then suddenly, they become a lot more resistant to seeing the foolishness of their ways, and they object to your attempts to make them see the truth (probably because it would mean admitting they were wrong).

It's clear that the moderator(s) are homeopathy users, because they are rather quick to protect their cherished fantasy. Their bias is showing very clearly.

Ask the mods if they would object to someone recommending voodoo for example, to cure their (medical) problems, and if they would allow people to speak out against that. Ask them if they would just allow any medical advice, even that which is totally untrue, to remain unchallenged, so as not to "attack" anyone's delusions.
 
And don't call people or doctors 'fools'! If you alienate your audience up front, anything you say after that will be wasted.
 
(yes, I know homeopathy is safe).
This is only true if they really prepare the solution homeopathically. If the preparer of the product is a knowing fraud, then it is possible there is (intentionally or unintentionally) some material in what is being sold.

wilks said:
I know you guys get into these sort of arguments all the time (well done you!) but I didn't 'want' to get banned so I'm feeling pretty bad right now.
Has anyone any advice for hanging on in there? Or do you just have to ignore the woo posts and not cause controversy?
It may not be possilbe to remain unbanned and still put your views forth. The best bet toward that, though, is to remain civil and strictly within the rules of the board. Make sure you know them and can point out that you haven't violated them.
 
...Moderator takes huff, says no-one is banning anything, just stop speaking out against homeopathy.
I don't stop.

To give some advice - if a Moderator tells you to stop doing something on a board, and you defy them, you will be censored, banned, deleted, or something. Thems the rules on most boards, including this one I believe. Trying to change the rules is like getting Randi to change the rules of the MDC. Good luck, but don't cry too much when you fail.

And that speaks to the most obvious part of you request.

I know you guys get into these sort of arguments all the time (well done you!) but I didn't 'want' to get banned so I'm feeling pretty bad right now.
Has anyone any advice for hanging on in there?

I doubt if many people here get into fights with a moderator, which is the real issue here, concerning being banned. As to influencing people with beliefs about something, if they are not open minded, or not willing to examine, research, and test out reality, then it might just be a waste of time to try and argue with them, pretty much over anything.
 
I have an idea - point them to this forum and/or articles Randi has written. Use quotes. Hell, show them this very thread.

Dont try to take the weight of the unwashed masses on your own shoulders, point them towards the already established critical thinking information widely available on this here series of tubes (the internet!).
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom