Will America blaim the Jews for economic crisis?

Thunder

Banned
Joined
Nov 18, 2006
Messages
34,918
I never thought I would ever have to ask such a question..but it seems that now it is reaching the point where things could get very bad before they get any better...and scapegoats may be sought out.

So..will a large part of the American population blaim the Jewish community as a whole? (even though most of us are not bankers and in the EXACT same boat as every other American). Or..have we absorbed the lessons of the past and will not scapegoat any group based on ethnicity, religion, race, etc?

I hope..I pray...that the United States 2008 is strong, better, smarter, and more evolved then Germany 1933.
 
Last edited:
I suppose it all depends on how bad things get. You may argue the Jews do not control Congress, Wall Street , Hollywood or the mainstream media but I think you must agree the perception among may non-Jews in America is exactly that. White America is going to become very irritated very soon. If Obama and his Marxist gang gets into the White House and we have another Great Depression things just might get interesting.

The reverse could also be the case if McCain wins after most polls show Obama leading by 5 percentage points before the election. If this happens Blacks will burn the cities; it will be 1968 allover again.

We are living in pre-revolutionary times.
 
No doubt you are the first to respond. Either way, do you think that the average Jew on the streets of America should in any way be blamed or somehow face some punishment for our economic crisis?

My family has been in this country for 108 years. We finally have one lawyer. =) No family member has ever been a banker, or a politician, or a millionaire. Most of us are between lower middle class...and upper middle class. Lots of civil servants, doctors, businessmen, teachers, construction workers, a butcher, and one Forester/Engineer (thats me). I find it hard to argue that anyone in my family has somehow contributed to our nation's economic troubles...let alone somehow profited from it.

Do you think I or anyone else in my family should somehow suffer for our nation's problems?
 
Last edited:
I suppose it all depends on how bad things get. You may argue the Jews do not control Congress, Wall Street , Hollywood or the mainstream media but I think you must agree the perception among may non-Jews in America is exactly that. White America is going to become very irritated very soon. If Obama and his Marxist gang gets into the White House and we have another Great Depression things just might get interesting.

The reverse could also be the case if McCain wins after most polls show Obama leading by 5 percentage points before the election. If this happens Blacks will burn the cities; it will be 1968 allover again.

We are living in pre-revolutionary times.






The kind of revolution that MaGZ has in mind.
Makes me grateful for the Second Amendment.
 
So..will a large part of the American population blaim the Jewish community as a whole?

No.

I hope..I pray...that the United States 2008 is strong, better, smarter, and more evolved then Germany 1933.

It is. You might want to worry a little more about whether or not Europe[/i[ is better than Germany 1933, though even there I think the answer is still basically yes, they are better.
 
That may be so. But any comparison between the the German people of 1933 and the American people of 2008...let alone our economic situations...is without merit. The German economic situation and level of social upheavel was 10,000 times worse then what we are dealing with. Nevermind the fact that we have had democracy, pluralism, freedom, and tolerance driven drown our throats for 230 years.

I can't see how today's economic crisis could lead to anything close to the levels of evil that occured in Nazi Germany. Thank God.

..but you never know.
 
I think some people will try to blame the Jews (or the blacks, or the homosexuals or whatever) for the ills of the modern world. But they have been doing this for years and few of them are very good at it (which kind of suggests that they aren't actually superior). So I doubt you will have much of a problem.

I wouldn't be surprised if parties or politicians espousing economic protectionism or economic nationalism don't become more succesful and these can sometimes lend legitimacy to the sort of individuals or small groups who daub swastikas on synagogues or pigs on mosques. We saw something like this in Australia.
 
That may be so. But any comparison between the the German people of 1933 and the American people of 2008...let alone our economic situations...is without merit. The German economic situation and level of social upheavel was 10,000 times worse then what we are dealing with. Nevermind the fact that we have had democracy, pluralism, freedom, and tolerance driven drown our throats for 230 years.

I can't see how today's economic crisis could lead to anything close to the levels of evil that occured in Nazi Germany. Thank God.

..but you never know.

Why would White Americans react differently than Germans in the 1920s or 1930s if they lost everything in a economic catastrophe?
 
I never thought I would ever have to ask such a question..but it seems that now it is reaching the point where things could get very bad before they get any better...and scapegoats may be sought out.

So..will a large part of the American population blaim the Jewish community as a whole? (even though most of us are not bankers and in the EXACT same boat as every other American). Or..have we absorbed the lessons of the past and will not scapegoat any group based on ethnicity, religion, race, etc?

I hope..I pray...that the United States 2008 is strong, better, smarter, and more evolved then Germany 1933.

I would hope not. People are to blame, but to pick a racial group as the dividing line makes no sense. I wouldn't expect Magz to represent a significant proportion of the population.
 
Why would White Americans react differently than Germans in the 1920s or 1930s if they lost everything in a economic catastrophe?

because democracy, freedom, and liberty have been part of our upbringing and education since 1776. because, unlike the Germans, we are a people that do the best we can to fight for freedom rather then fighting to destroy it.

The Germans had democracy from 1918 till 1933. We have had democracy from 1776 till 2008.

I think it is fair to say that if we suffered identical economic and social conditions as Germany did (which we are not nor likely to)..we would behave in a very different way.

Does that....trouble you? Would you prefer the USA act towards its Jews the way Germany acted towards its Jews?

Do you believe that I and my family should be sent to "the East"?
 
Does that....trouble you? Would you prefer the USA act towards its Jews the way Germany acted towards its Jews?

Do you believe that I and my family should be sent to "the East"?

Nazism worked so well for Germany. Oh wait, no it didn't.
 
I hope things don't get so bad that scapegoats are needed. However is it a false assumption that the American public is as progressive as we should be by now. Not enough has changed to make any target group safe. The neocons and the likes of Pastor Hagey haven't helped the issue either.
 
You haven't answered my question MaGz.

Do you believe that I and my family should be punished for America's economic troubles?
 
Will America blaim the Jews for economic crisis?
Will Parky ever learn how to spell, to read what he types before he posts, or understand what begging a question is?
I never thought I would ever have to ask such a question..
I knew you had it in you. You didn't disappoint.
but it seems that now it is reaching the point where things could get very bad before they get any better...and scapegoats may be sought out.
Gee, that's never happened before.

So..will a large part of the American population blaim the Jewish community as a whole?
Why do you assume that is even an issue? Feeling paranoid, again, Parky?

DR
 
[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/thum_1884048ee9dbe61411.jpg[/qimg]


The kind of revolution that MaGZ has in mind.
Makes me grateful for the Second Amendment.
Welcome the the Godwin forum, where Parky begs for a Godwin and it gets delivered.

Way to go guys. Y'all just keep lowering the bar and y'all will infect the entirety of the JREF forums with enough stupid to sink them. MaGZ, yoiu took the bait, hook, line and sinker. Was that for a reason, or did you miss the line attached to it?

DR
 
Last edited:
What caused National Socialism to fail?

Did it fail in the 1930s?


No. It succeeded in starting a war that brought about the destruction of Germany, not to mention some other bad things.
 
What caused National Socialism to fail?

There are dozens of reasons why it failed. Picking wars with its neighbours; picking wars on two fronts at the same time; killing many, if not most, of its best and brightest people; slaughtering millions of people instead of concentrating on the war for its very survival.


Did it fail in the 1930s?

No, it lasted for a grand total of 12 years. Even communism outlasted it; and communism was complete nonsense.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom