Lurker
Illuminator
- Joined
- May 15, 2002
- Messages
- 4,189
There are several "real issues" involved with Social Security. The one that this thread is addressing is the fact that the "savings" in the trust fund are debt instruments from the same entity that is saving. Therefore, there are no real savings.
There are promises, which are a tiny bit better than nothing.
I know it sounds a bit bizarre to look at a fine, conservative, well trusted investment, i.e. government bonds, and say that it is not an investment at all, but that is, in fact, the case. When you buy a government bond, it's an investment. When the government buys a government bond, it's an accounting gimmick.
And if the govt were buying private stocks then you'd be bellyaching about the risk or favoratism involved.
Just how do you feel SS should invest their surplus? A lockbox earning 0% interest (actually with inflation it would be a negative rate)