Merged why the release of names associated with Epstein mean little to absolutely nothing.

There's a lot of argumentum ad hominem being used (on this forum generally) to dismiss reports that deserve serious examination.

No doubt that happens. But sometimes there are perfectly good reasons to dismiss the source, particularly if they are a known source of sensationalism and conspiracism as Mario Nawful blatantly is.

For me, it is no different to seeing Alex Jones posting on Twitter that he received an email from a listener saying Bill Clinton ate her baby on Epstein's island.

Would we think:

1. Alex Jones, dismiss.
2. Oooh, that deserves a thorough investigation.

The correct answer is 1. It just is.
 
And when someone posts such a message from Alex Jones, I'm sure we'll all agree with you.
Indeed, there have been some dreanged accusations from QAnon people, but the presence of such should have no impact on the assessment of accusations that are independent of that. Although I am half wondering if some might have been started in order to discredit genuine accusations. It's just the sort of thing that Bannon would think of as amusing.
 
I think where allegations are accompanied by extracts from the released files, it's worth looking at them seriously and not just saying, that person is unreliable.

Goodness knows whether the person highlighting this was unreliable, but I saw an extract today with some extremely damaging material about Lord George Robertson.

We've already had a ridiculous allegation about J K Rowling posted here, with regrettable credulity, so there are people I'm not going to take lectures from on this issue.
 
Last edited:
Mandelson has been arrested. And that's not an unsubstantiated allegation!


 
Last edited:
I think where allegations are accompanied by extracts from the released files, it's worth looking at them seriously and not just saying, that person is unreliable.

Goodness knows whether the person highlighting this was unreliable, but I saw an extract today with some extremely damaging material about Lord George Robertson.

We've already had a ridiculous allegation about J K Rowling posted here, with regrettable credulity, so there are people I'm not going to take lectures from on this issue.

i agree i think we can examine claims and evaluate them based on the available evidence regardless of who’s making the claim. i mean, it wasn’t that long ago that virginia giuffre was considered a discredited liar and look how that turned out
 
Being interested in a range of subjects, I have noted with interest that some people whom I had pegged as being absolutely beyond the pale based on their discourse around one subject I am interested in, have come out with surprisingly sensible observations about other subjects. (And that actually includes J K Rowling.)

I mean, take Naomi Wolf, whom I consider to be an absolute raving nutter. And yet a couple of times I've caught myself about to retweet her because she made a point I considered sensible and noteworthy, and while I admit I drew back from the retweet when I saw who it was I was about to retweet, she wasn't wrong.

People are complex, and even a stopped clock is right twice a day.

ETA: There's also the question of how much anyone can be expected to know about the account they're retweeting. The preposterous allegation against Rowling was actually sourced from a tweet by trans prostitute Jack "Beth" Douglas (although I happened to know that it was originally propagated by Jonathan "India" Willoughby). I can imagine that people outwith Scotland may not be familiar with the fragrant "Beth", nor be in the habit of carrying out in-depth investigation into the credibility of every account they happen to retweet, but I would remind people that this cuts both ways.


 
Last edited:
dangers of tribalism i suppose. my opinion is it’s ok to be wrong about something if you can admit it and learn from your mistakes, and you have to have the grace to let people be wrong and give them a chance to get there in their own time

not that any of that always works, or i even take my own advice all the time lol
 
I think where allegations are accompanied by extracts from the released files, it's worth looking at them seriously and not just saying, that person is unreliable.
I think it depends on what type of document it is.
Goodness knows whether the person highlighting this was unreliable, but I saw an extract today with some extremely damaging material about Lord George Robertson.
Is it this document?


Because it is not just Robertson mentioned there. It says the entire British establishment is part of a paedophile ring, and that the Dunblane massacre was a false flag operation designed to make guns illegal in the UK. Some of the allegations seem to have been reported to InfoWars (i.e Alex Jones’s media outlet) Paul Joseph Watson. David Icke’s name is also in this one.
We've already had a ridiculous allegation about J K Rowling posted here, with regrettable credulity, so there are people I'm not going to take lectures from on this issue.
Well, exactly! I certainly didn’t push the Rowling story. In fact, I was one of those saying it was nonsense. So I am saying that there is plenty more nonsense in these files. Much of these documents were apparently sent to law enforcement after Epstein’s death which means any Tom, Dick or Harry could send in their “theories” about Epstein, much of which were being passed around in QAnon circles.
 
I think it depends on what type of document it is.

Is it this document?


Because it is not just Robertson mentioned there. It says the entire British establishment is part of a paedophile ring, and that the Dunblane massacre was a false flag operation designed to make guns illegal in the UK. Some of the allegations seem to have been reported to InfoWars (i.e Alex Jones’s media outlet) Paul Joseph Watson. David Icke’s name is also in this one.

Well, exactly! I certainly didn’t push the Rowling story. In fact, I was one of those saying it was nonsense. So I am saying that there is plenty more nonsense in these files. Much of these documents were apparently sent to law enforcement after Epstein’s death which means any Tom, Dick or Harry could send in their “theories” about Epstein, much of which were being passed around in QAnon circles.

Yes. It was a screenshot of a couple of paragraphs of that document. Seeing the whole thing, it looks like a lot of unsubstantiated conspiracy allegations I've seen floating around from time to time. I have to say you are the first person I have come across who has given any actual reason to connect the Dunblane massacre to the wider conspiracy allegations. I know a couple of genuinely false flag operations have been identified over the years, but in general, it's a pretty good pointer to a complete nutter.

Given my own involvement in the Lockerbie investigation, demonstrating that the police scenario about how the crime was committed was just flat wrong, maybe I'll find myself in the mass of random downloads. (At one point a disaffected Lockerbie conspiracy theorist whose nose was seriously out of joint on account of my investigations having exploded his own pet theory set up a "Wikispooks" page alleging that I was MI5 or MI6 or CIA or something, I don't really remember.)
 
Last edited:
Yes. It was a screenshot of a couple of paragraphs of that document. Seeing the whole thing, it looks like a lot of unsubstantiated conspiracy allegations I've seen floating around from time to time. I have to say you are the first person I have come across who has given any actual reason to connect the Dunblane massacre to the wider conspiracy allegations. I know a couple of genuinely false flag operations have been identified over the years, but in general, it's a pretty good pointer to a complete nutter.

Given my own involvement in the Lockerbie investigation, demonstrating that the police scenario about how the crime was committed was just flat wrong, maybe I'll find myself in the mass of random downloads. (At one point a disaffected Lockerbie conspiracy theorist whose nose was seriously out of joint on account of my investigations having exploded his own pet theory set up a "Wikispooks" page alleging that I was MI5 or MI6 or CIA or something, I don't really remember.)
Yep. I think some of this reminds me of the time of the Wikileaks mass cable release. I seem to recall that many of Craig Murray’s commenters were excited about the way it would finally reveal the 9/11 false flag. And when the tranche of documents mostly revealed prosaic stuff, some of them decided that Wikileaks was itself CIA and that what was appearing was a “limited hang out”.

Anyway, as you mentioned Robertson, I had a look around on Reddit where people are combing through the documents and you can find some other rather crazed documents.

There are emails in there, again written to US law enforcement after Epstein’s death, by people who will say things like “I just watched a Netflix documentary about Madeleine McCann’s disappearance and it seems to me that some investigation into his and Maxwell’s links to that disappearance is necessary.”

Those are at least helpful for showing the writer’s workings, but there are a lot more people simply stating their suppositions as facts. And unfortunately, much of that seems to have polluted the reporting of these files. I even think that the email Ted Lieu referenced in his grilling of Pam Bondi is more in the vein of an unsubstantiated story. There is a person very active on Reddit who claims to have written that email, and surely Lieu would be able to contact him, but apparently has not.
 
Oh, don't start me on Craig Murray, never mind his hangers-on.

Thanks for the heads-up about the provenance and sources of these documents. It's proving very useful against a raving nutter on Twitter who is insisting that "it's from the US justice dept!"
 
We've already had a ridiculous allegation about J K Rowling posted here, with regrettable credulity, so there are people I'm not going to take lectures from on this issue.
I already admitted I was wrong and retracted the claim. I guess you're going to hold it over my head forever though.
 
Only if you continue to sneer at other people who have posted things in good faith without having done due diligence on the person disseminating the allegation.
 
Those are at least helpful for showing the writer’s workings, but there are a lot more people simply stating their suppositions as facts. And unfortunately, much of that seems to have polluted the reporting of these files. I even think that the email Ted Lieu referenced in his grilling of Pam Bondi is more in the vein of an unsubstantiated story. There is a person very active on Reddit who claims to have written that email, and surely Lieu would be able to contact him, but apparently has not.

to clarify, as i recall lieu didn’t claim the document he referenced was a fact. bondi has claimed that there were no accusations against trump. he referenced that to show that there are many accusations in the files and to highlight that many of them were never investigated at all
 

alex jones has mostly been getting pretty emotional and crying about it so probably not going to get anything good from him
Alex Jones is one of the biggest phoneys ever. I've seen him crying many times. He jumps back and forth from playing persecuted to being bully.
 
to clarify, as i recall lieu didn’t claim the document he referenced was a fact. bondi has claimed that there were no accusations against trump. he referenced that to show that there are many accusations in the files and to highlight that many of them were never investigated at all
Ah, thanks for the clarification. Yes, that could be the reason then. I do think it doesn’t seem to be a credible accusation. The email itself is quite extreme with a limo driver saying he heard Trump and Epstein discussing some girl with a funny name and then later on meeting her only for her to have her “head blown off”, the cops turning up and saying it didn’t look like suicide but the coroner writing that in as the cause of death. It suggested that the person writing it was privy to all kinds of conversations that seem hard to believe.

This is not to say that Bondi wasn’t absolutely dreadful in her hearing. She certainly was, and her and people like her have been one of the main culprits for making spurious claims around these files.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom