Merged why the release of names associated with Epstein mean little to absolutely nothing.

It's archeology - just because little is left of one intel doesn't mean it wasn't important.
Epstein having extensive contacts to various governments and intelligence agencies and did work for them is no longer in question, for example.
 
Oh for crying out loud. It's a very peripheral issue, but trying to blow "there are people named who hold the perfectly rational view that human beings can't change sex" into "Epstein and his operation were 'anti-trans'" is beyond ridiculous, when there is actual evidence he was funding "gender reassignment" research.

Outside the bubble of internet communities that have become deranged by this transient nonsense, the vast majority of people know that mammalian sex is fixed at conception and immutable, and lots of them even say so, particularly if they're not vulnerable to being cancelled for wrongspeak. That there are people named in the Epstein files (including people as unconnected to it all as J K Rowling) who have expressed that view should come as no surprise to anyone.

The fact is, small point though it may be, Epstein seems to have had a prurient interest in trans people and funded research into medical and surgical treatments.
 
Marsh's article that Art linked to should be required reading. A couple of otherwise sensible accounts I follow on .. Bluesky? Mastodon? .. seem to be taking claims at face value. It provides ammo for their protectors - "Well that claim that cut people's feet with a scimitar that left no scars was bogus so I bet this is too". Big thanks to those filtering the firehose of data.
NB not defending these scum. Build a solid case and see how many life sentences can be piled on top of each other.
 
Marsh's article that Art linked to should be required reading. A couple of otherwise sensible accounts I follow on .. Bluesky? Mastodon? .. seem to be taking claims at face value. It provides ammo for their protectors - "Well that claim that cut people's feet with a scimitar that left no scars was bogus so I bet this is too". Big thanks to those filtering the firehose of data.
NB not defending these scum. Build a solid case and see how many life sentences can be piled on top of each other.

i agree that people should be trying to get the facts right. i think this is pretty murky waters though considering the facts are being suppressed by the authorities you had previously relied on for being truthful.

it’s a difficult situation imo because while you want to get it right and stick to the facts, the only way to put enough pressure on the authorities to do the right thing and be transparent is to keep the discussion going, which risks you may put something out there that appears true but isn’t. some advice on how to handle that from the article would have been good

to me it’s illustrative of the damage that can be done when you erode trust in public systems. not even the billionaires are insulted from that
 
Last edited:
To me it seems that names on the Epstein List must fall into one of four categories:

People with an entire ancillary or tangential connection to the Epstein controversy.

People connected to Epstein's power brokerage.

People connected to Epstein's parties with his underage party girls.

People connected to Epstein's alleged procurement of prepubescent children for sexual services.

Everyone seems to assume that anyone whose name shows up at all, must be part of the fourth category. There's some scrambling to establish that this particular reputable name belongs to the first category, but that's about it.

Does everyone seem to be assuming this? I think I missed a meeting. I'm not seeing the allegations of your 4th category, involving pre-pubescent children. Plenty of the 3rd category, underage party girls, for sure, but where is the 4th?
 
Last edited:
It's safe to assume that everyone connected to Epstein who had a fashion or modeling company or beauty pageant was involved in the procurement of victims.
 
I don’t think it’s clear that so many people were involved in procurement of young girls. I think many just didn’t care. Which is bloody appalling.

ETA: and it wasn't abstract like, say, someone watching on the news about kids killed in a bombing. Most of them visited and the island and could see the girls, put names and faces to them, and still regard them as what? expendable? irrelevant?

“There’s no greys, only white that’s got grubby. I’m surprised you don’t know that. And sin, young man, is when you treat people as things. Including yourself. That’s what sin is.’
‘It’s a lot more complicated than that -’
‘No. It ain’t. When people say things are a lot more complicated than that, they means they’re getting worried that they won’t like the truth. People as things, that’s where it starts.”
― Terry Pratchett, Carpe Jugulum
 
Last edited:
it's very creepy when commentators try to make a distinction between "barely legal" and rape of children.
Particularly given the age of some commentators. The older I get the older my definition of "child" gets.
I remember [eta: my brother] after his divorce a legal age girl making a play for him. When a friend asked why he didn't, he replied "Just because it's legal, doesn't make it right."
Carole Cadwalladr wrote an interesting (as always) piece

I'd really recommend reading the whole article. In it she mentions an earlier article.
This was the second last paragraph of my piece in 2005:

“This incident more or less sums up my feelings about the Côte d’Azur, Paris Hilton, Tamara Beckwith, big fat yachts and fatter millionaires. Where’s F Scott Fitzgerald when you need him? He’s dead, that’s where, and in his place there’s only Heat and OK! and Hello!. There’s only pap shots of people getting on and off yachts, and falling in and out of their bikinis. There’s only arms dealers and nudie pics of young girls. It’s all fabulous-fabulous right up to the moment you scratch the surface and something sleazy oozes out.”
 
Last edited:
Does everyone seem to be assuming this? I think I missed a meeting. I'm not seeing the allegations of your 4th category, involving pre-pubescent children. Plenty of the 3rd category, underage party girls, for sure, but where is the 4th?
Not here, maybe, but for example there's that email which could be talking about a 9-year-old, but more likely a 19-year-old, where an equals sign has replaced a 1 (due to OCR or database corruption of some sort). I saw at least one person on Facebook getting very angry when that was explained, saying it was typical of men trying to defend a paedophile. If children were involved, then of course that is horrible, but I'm not aware that there is solid evidence that it happened.
 
Wherever someone says "pedophile" in connection with Epstein.
... a fairy dies. Yes, I know. Call the pedantry police.

You're implying that everyone who misuses the word paedophile about Epstein is in fact not misusing it but really declaring their belief that he was involved in the trafficking and abuse of pre-pubescent children. Thanks for your very useful insight there. No, really.
 
Not here, maybe, but for example there's that email which could be talking about a 9-year-old, but more likely a 19-year-old, where an equals sign has replaced a 1 (due to OCR or database corruption of some sort). I saw at least one person on Facebook getting very angry when that was explained, saying it was typical of men trying to defend a paedophile. If children were involved, then of course that is horrible, but I'm not aware that there is solid evidence that it happened.
Someone I usually trust said they'd seen a different scan of the same email where it said 19. However given the amount of fake images and reports I won't trust that claim until I've seen a verified copy showing it's 19. That one data point aside, Representative Jamie Raskin, a Maryland Democrat, said 'You read through these files, and you read about 15-year-old girls, 14-year-old girls, 10-year-old girls. I saw a mention of a 9-year-old girl today. I mean, this is just preposterous and scandalous,'
So I'm less sure of the lower limit of the girls' ages but the confirmed details are bad enough
 
... a fairy dies. Yes, I know. Call the pedantry police.

You're implying that everyone who misuses the word paedophile about Epstein is in fact not misusing it but really declaring their belief that he was involved in the trafficking and abuse of pre-pubescent children. Thanks for your very useful insight there. No, really.

a lot earlier in the thread someone else wanted to use the term ephebophile instead of pedophile. some people really like these semantic debate derails, especially people who haven’t otherwise contributed to the thread. i do not and would rather discuss the topic than endlessly debate terminology. to me pedophile seems fine, if it’s confusing to someone i don’t really have much interest in what anyone not familiar with the case has to say anyway. be confused.

but to each their own. from what i’ve been following i have seen accusations as young as 14. epstein and his friends trafficked a lot of high school aged girls and many young adult women. that’s pretty much understood i think
 
Someone I usually trust said they'd seen a different scan of the same email where it said 19. However given the amount of fake images and reports I won't trust that claim until I've seen a verified copy showing it's 19.
On one of these threads, a link was provided to the actual .gov site, and it does in fact say 19yo. I'll try to remember which and link it here, it was recent.

ETA: found it, Yahoo article with link to original document in the .gov library, courtesy of angrysoba
That one data point aside, Representative Jamie Raskin, a Maryland Democrat, said 'You read through these files, and you read about 15-year-old girls, 14-year-old girls, 10-year-old girls. I saw a mention of a 9-year-old girl today. I mean, this is just preposterous and scandalous,'
So I'm less sure of the lower limit of the girls' ages but the confirmed details are bad enough
This. Just how revolting is almost an academic point now. It is already beyond the threshold of 'pretty much as bad as you would imagine'
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom