Why the PATRIOT Act?

So... that begs the question why post here if you do not intend to engage in discussion?

By the way, you forgot to answer the question here. You falsely claimed to have engaged in a discussion, before making an excuse for avoiding a direct question. Neither of which explains why you are posting statements then refusing to actually discuss what WAS posted.

I know, the irony of doing that in a post asking why you do that is annoying.
 
By the way, you forgot to answer the question here.

I believe I have already answered the question about the victims. I admitted somewhere that there may be real victims. I don't see the point in going on endlessly repeating it.
 
I believe I have already answered the question about the victims. I admitted somewhere that there may be real victims. I don't see the point in going on endlessly repeating it.

You seem not be able to distinguish between writing something in response to the question and actually supplying an answer that contains the information required with out room for ambiguity.

Why should the question not be repeated until you actually provide a satisfactory answer in place of a handwave?
 
You seem not be able to distinguish between writing something in response to the question and actually supplying an answer that contains the information required with out room for ambiguity.

Why should the question not be repeated until you actually provide a satisfactory answer in place of a handwave?

Several conspiracy researchers have pointed out how the victims could have been faked. Just a year or so ago I firmly believed the victims were real (except the passengers in the supposed planes). Today I think it's possible that the victims could have been faked. The victims could also be real, I don't know. Let's keep all options on the table.
 
Several conspiracy researchers have pointed out how the victims could have been faked. Just a year or so ago I firmly believed the victims were real (except the passengers in the supposed planes). Today I think it's possible that the victims could have been faked. The victims could also be real, I don't know. Let's keep all options on the table.

What a way to fail to answer again!

So which of the three almost-answers you just provided should we accept as your answer?
1) The victims were real.
2) The victims were fake.
3) You don't know.
 
So you can have something toxic to chew on? Don't think so. It would be harmful for you.

My, that's a lot of courage you're not showing. So pretty much you can't bring yourself to admitting what everyone here has figured out, that you're entertained by the violent deaths of 3000 people.
 
Several conspiracy researchers have pointed out how the victims could have been faked. Just a year or so ago I firmly believed the victims were real (except the passengers in the supposed planes). Today I think it's possible that the victims could have been faked. The victims could also be real, I don't know. Let's keep all options on the table.

I don't think you've got a table.
 
I engage in civilized discussions.

What forum do you do that on?

You don't have to be a professor in psychology to understand that repeating the same question umpteen times produces naughty and toxic replies.

You don't have to be a professor in psychology to realize that evading the same question umpteen times is a sign of insincerity and deception.
 
I think it's possible that the victims could have been faked. The victims could also be real, I don't know. Let's keep all options on the table.


Why don't you just visit their survivors? There have to be something like 10,000 people who were closely related to the 9/11 victims and a million who knew at least one victim.

Here, I'll start you off: Janet Alonso. When I go to the place where I used to see her, she's not there anymore.

It's not like it's hard to research this stuff first hand. All you have to do is want to.
 
Why don't you just visit their survivors? There have to be something like 10,000 people who were closely related to the 9/11 victims and a million who knew at least one victim.

Here, I'll start you off: Janet Alonso. When I go to the place where I used to see her, she's not there anymore.

It's not like it's hard to research this stuff first hand. All you have to do is want to.

But what about this:

"WASHINGTON — A New York congresswoman who represents Manhattan wants answers to why nearly 3,000 victims of the 9/11 terrorists attacks weren’t reported in the Social Security Administration’s official list of deceased Americans. ... “While nearly 3,000 individuals were killed on Sept. 11th, the list does not show an increase in numbers from the typical DMF daily average,” Maloney said." -- http://911scholars.ning.com/profiles/blogs/3000-deaths-from-911-not-in
 
It's not like it's hard to research this stuff first hand. All you have to do is want to.


Anders has, in the not-to-distant-past, expressed an explicit desire not to personally pursue the validity of the things he says or claims to believe. His M.O. is to troll others into bringing the evidence within arm's reach so that he can easily bat it aside. He's very comfortable in his intellectual La-Z-Boy.

All part of the performance, of course.

ETA: See? :rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
But what about this:

"WASHINGTON — A New York congresswoman who represents Manhattan wants answers to why nearly 3,000 victims of the 9/11 terrorists attacks weren’t reported in the Social Security Administration’s official list of deceased Americans. ... “While nearly 3,000 individuals were killed on Sept. 11th, the list does not show an increase in numbers from the typical DMF daily average,” Maloney said." -- http://911scholars.ning.com/profiles/blogs/3000-deaths-from-911-not-in

What about it?

There is no evidence to suggest the discrepency is because "nobody died", nor is that relevent to the question of if people died. That is only relevent to how the repurcussions were handled in an administrative sense.
 
But what about this:

"WASHINGTON — A New York congresswoman who represents Manhattan wants answers to why nearly 3,000 victims of the 9/11 terrorists attacks weren’t reported in the Social Security Administration’s official list of deceased Americans. ... “While nearly 3,000 individuals were killed on Sept. 11th, the list does not show an increase in numbers from the typical DMF daily average,” Maloney said." -- http://911scholars.ning.com/profiles/blogs/3000-deaths-from-911-not-in


I'm going to give you the benefit of the doubt on this one because you probably don't understand how the US Social Security system works. See here for a detailed explanation.
 
I'm going to give you the benefit of the doubt on this one because you probably don't understand how the US Social Security system works. See here for a detailed explanation.

Are you saying 3000 victims are missing in the statistics because of the below reasons?

* The death was not reported to the Social Security Administration (SSA).

* The death occurred before the Death Master File was maintained in a computer database. About 98 percent of the deaths in this database occurred between 1962 and the present.

* The person did not participate in the Social Security program.

* Survivor death benefits were (are) being paid to dependents or spouse.

* A recent death may not be indexed yet.

* Human error.

Can that really explain all the 3000 missing victims in the statistics? And don't you think the New York congresswoman knew about that before demanding answers about the Social Security Administration’s official list of deceased Americans?
 
Are you saying 3000 victims are missing in the statistics because of the below reasons?

* The death was not reported to the Social Security Administration (SSA).

* The death occurred before the Death Master File was maintained in a computer database. About 98 percent of the deaths in this database occurred between 1962 and the present.

* The person did not participate in the Social Security program.

* Survivor death benefits were (are) being paid to dependents or spouse.

* A recent death may not be indexed yet.

* Human error.

Can that really explain all the 3000 missing victims in the statistics?

So are you suggesting a massive and impossible conspiracy is more likely than mismanaged data?

That says a lot more about your mindset than it does about the likelyhood of three thousand faked deaths.
 
What about it?

There is no evidence to suggest the discrepency is because "nobody died", nor is that relevent to the question of if people died. That is only relevent to how the repurcussions were handled in an administrative sense.

There were 6,298 deaths registered on 9/11 when there should have been over 9,000! http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HckSSIGt50Q

I don't think such huge discrepancy can be dismissed so easily.
 
So are you suggesting a massive and impossible conspiracy is more likely than mismanaged data?

That says a lot more about your mindset than it does about the likelyhood of three thousand faked deaths.

It seems to suggest a huge conspiracy, yes. If the quote about the New York Congresswoman is correct, then I think that's significant. At least it should be investigated further I think.
 
There were 6,298 deaths registered on 9/11 when there should have been over 9,000! http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HckSSIGt50Q

I don't think such huge discrepancy can be dismissed so easily.

Once again, wether or not you believe this is likely or not is not the question. Are you seriously suggesting it is less likely than the people never having existed, despite other forms of their existence?

At exactly what point do you assume clerical errors become impossible? Given that the administration was acting under unprecedneted pressure, with a far larger case load than expected, and not all victims were identified immediately?

Are you unaware of equally large errors made by other administrative arms under less unique circumstances? The defecits in immigration records in my own country spring to mind.

Administrative errors are precedented, the conspiracy you describe is not. So allow me to ask one final time in the hope of a direct answer.

Are you suggesting the administrative errors are less likely than the conspiracy you describe? (Note that is not asking if you believe the errors or not, please answer the question that WAS asked).
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom