Why is everyone on Facebook talking about Amanda Todd?

It's the suicide note of a 15 year old girl.

It's not a note, it's a video of someone flipping cards with text, like a performance piece. Are we talking about the same thing?

If it has anything to do with a suicide, that just adds a further ghoulish element. JREF at its best.
 
It's not a note, it's a video of someone flipping cards with text, like a performance piece. Are we talking about the same thing?

If it has anything to do with a suicide, that just adds a further ghoulish element. JREF at its best.

If you want ghoulish.... I know somebody which googled her name to oogle at her boob, while knowing she had recently suicided. It was difficult to not freak out and hit the guy.
 
If you want ghoulish.... I know somebody which googled her name to oogle at her boob, while knowing she had recently suicided. It was difficult to not freak out and hit the guy.

Well, you know what they say, "Choose your enemies wisely, for you will become them."
 
It's not a note, it's a video of someone flipping cards with text, like a performance piece. Are we talking about the same thing?

If it has anything to do with a suicide, that just adds a further ghoulish element. JREF at its best.
Are you deliberately being insensitive? I hadn't heard of the case before, but I thought the video heart-wrenching. Nobody deserves to be treated like that.

Just thought I'd bump this topic because an arrest is made relating to this case.

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/art...reading-topless-photos-Facebook-arrested.html
There's plenty of coverage in the Dutch media, of course. Most of which are largely copies of each other. A couple of salient points:

The suspect's name is Aydin C. - that's the usual format suspect's names are released in the Netherlands. He has both Dutch and Turkish nationality. His lawyer says he will resist extradition to Canada, saying he wants to be tried in the Netherlands according to the Dutch penal system because he is Dutch.

I say, that's pure BS. Why not in Turkey, after all, he is also a Turk? :rolleyes: But I think I understand the ulterior motive, apart from the hassle of being extradited. Sentencing in NL for more crimes of the same type can only add up to 1/3 on top of the maximum sentence for that crime. Separate sentences in two countries add up full. Extradite him to Canada, if there's credible evidence. And subsequently to the UK and the USA, where other victims of his were located. If you bully globally, you may also do time globally. He is currently suspect in nine cases of online crimes, but the prosecution estimates there may be dozens. The police investigation can take several more months.

He has already been in pre-trial arrest since mid-January this year, and it recently got extended with another three months. His lawyer has confirmed that he was not registered at any municipal civic registry, and that he lived in various bungalows in holiday parks.

What an idiot, that's more illegal behaviour. And a perfect reason for the prosecutor to present him as a flight risk and press for extension of pre-trial arrest. (NL has no bail system).

His lawyer claims that the evidence the prosecution has gathered is very thin. The police has seized his computer and router. His lawyer claims it's very easy to break in into the router and that is client was not always present in the bungalow, and that it's easy to clone MAC and IP-addresses and login into someone else's router.

That's true, but then there would also be evidence of such a break-in from outside. Police found pictures and videos of several victims on his computer, how did it get there? In any case, if his lawyer is so versed in these technical matters, then we can be quite sure that a conviction or an extradition is safe and not a matter of prosecution bluffing with insufficient evidence.
 
Last edited:
Are you deliberately being insensitive? I hadn't heard of the case before, but I thought the video heart-wrenching. Nobody deserves to be treated like that.

Well, on the upside, I guess it will remain as a nice snack for those who want to wallow in a bit of tragedy safely. For those into this kind of thing, there's even a book available on Amazon that collects suicide notes in a convenient for bathroom reading format: http://www.amazon.com/Or-Not-Be-Collection-Suicide/dp/1573225800
 
It's not a note, it's a video of someone flipping cards with text, like a performance piece. Are we talking about the same thing?

Yes, we are. This is how she presented her suicide note. Feel free to continue believing that the most important factor in a 15 year old girl being exploited, bullied and harassed to the point of suicide being that she made her suicide note in a format that you find beneath you.
 
Yes, we are. This is how she presented her suicide note. Feel free to continue believing that the most important factor in a 15 year old girl being exploited, bullied and harassed to the point of suicide being that she made her suicide note in a format that you find beneath you.

I guess, so long as others find some other important point in the mix, some larger truth about justice and fair play. At least neither camp is interested in suicide prevention, the fragility of teenagers or, you know, anything of merit.

How do I know this? Because if it wasn't death porn, and if there were something worth learning, some brave soul would have taken the time to type out her missive instead of exploiting the tragedy. But perhaps that's the larger message - human beings are a callous bunch. Callous enough to feed on another's tragedy or triumph.

The truth is rather more banal: a young person can't cope with their life and commits suicide. If the meaning of the event springs from the fact of this video, it's more of a sad commentary on our lust for entertainment than anything else. I suggest, for those who enjoy immersion in visceral tragedy by way of YouTube, the categories of abused puppies or starving children.
 
I guess, so long as others find some other important point in the mix, some larger truth about justice and fair play. At least neither camp is interested in suicide prevention, the fragility of teenagers or, you know, anything of merit.

How do I know this? Because if it wasn't death porn, and if there were something worth learning, some brave soul would have taken the time to type out her missive instead of exploiting the tragedy. But perhaps that's the larger message - human beings are a callous bunch. Callous enough to feed on another's tragedy or triumph.

The truth is rather more banal: a young person can't cope with their life and commits suicide. If the meaning of the event springs from the fact of this video, it's more of a sad commentary on our lust for entertainment than anything else. I suggest, for those who enjoy immersion in visceral tragedy by way of YouTube, the categories of abused puppies or starving children.

You know what would've been really cool and all grown-up like. If you'd just admitted that you know nothing about the case and posted an insensitive post, not realizing that it was essentially a ****** - up kid's suicide note that you were complaining about the "quality" of.

This story is a couple of years old. Her parents and friends have started a foundation and are drawing donations and pushing them in two directions... to help educate teens as to some of the "pitfalls" of the internet, and to help kids who have mental health issues.

I don't see anyone here wallowing in anything, except that one post by that member who thought it was dull and not worthy of his/her time. Maybe we could get Deadmau5 to put it to dub-step? Perk it up a bit, you know?
 
At least neither camp is interested in suicide prevention, the fragility of teenagers or, you know, anything of merit.

Nobody's done anything of merit off the back of this? Other than the anti-bullying foundation set up in Todd's name, the increased donations to anti-bullying and anti-cyberbullying charities, and the parliamentary motion?

It's usually a good idea to actually know something about a subject before ranting about it, especially if that information is easily available.

How do I know this? Because if it wasn't death porn, and if there were something worth learning, some brave soul would have taken the time to type out her missive instead of exploiting the tragedy.

What a strange argument. People are simply being ghoulish because nobody has transcribed her video? How do you figure that logic out?

And how much research did you do before coming to this conclusion? Took me all of 10 seconds to find this.

But perhaps that's the larger message - human beings are a callous bunch.

Or, indeed, callous enough to take the suicide of a young girl and turn it into a whine about how she didn't take their feelings into consideration in choosing how to present her suicide note.
 
You know what would've been really cool and all grown-up like. If you'd just admitted that you know nothing about the case and posted an insensitive post, not realizing that it was essentially a ****** - up kid's suicide note that you were complaining about the "quality" of.

I don't mind being insensitive when sensitivity isn't a virtue.

This story is a couple of years old. Her parents and friends have started a foundation and are drawing donations and pushing them in two directions... to help educate teens as to some of the "pitfalls" of the internet, and to help kids who have mental health issues.

And do they do all this good work by way of notes flipped in a video? Bet not. Why not? Because they are trying to communicate. Face it, the video is death porn and no one would watch it if the girl hadn't died. If that doesn't make you weep for humanity, I don't know what would.

I don't see anyone here wallowing in anything, except that one post by that member who thought it was dull and not worthy of his/her time. Maybe we could get Deadmau5 to put it to dub-step? Perk it up a bit, you know?

I don't think you'd get the hits unless you work in another death or two. I'm not complaining because it isn't entertaining - plainly, lots of folks think it's great. I'm complaining because it's pornographic and exploitative. It isn't what she says that people are lusting for, it's her saying it. The piece reeks of the worst sort of irony: I killed myself because my image was being exploited on the Internet, because strangers were viewing my most intimate physical secrets...

Sensitivity, in this case, is introducing an emotional fog which conceals the real evil on offer - us.
 
Last edited:
I don't mind being insensitive when sensitivity isn't a virtue.



And do they do all this good work by way of notes flipped in a video? Bet not. Why not? Because they are trying to communicate. Face it, the video is death porn and no one would watch it if the girl hadn't died. If that doesn't make you weep for humanity, I don't know what would.



I don't think you'd get the hits unless you work in another death or two. I'm not complaining because it isn't entertaining - plainly, lots of folks think it's great. I'm complaining because it's pornographic and exploitative. It isn't what she says that people are lusting for, it's her saying it. The piece reeks of the worst sort of irony: I killed myself because my image was being exploited on the Internet, because strangers were viewing my most intimate physical secrets...

Sensitivity, in this case, is introducing an emotional fog which conceals the real evil on offer - us.

Deep, man! Deep!
 
Yeah, that she didn't consult you first about how best to communicate is the real tragedy here.

I've certainly not made a dent, judging by the responses here. No worries, the tragedy machine will continue production and soon enough the next serving of sadness will be along to tug the heartstrings for our amusement. If we are lucky, it will be a macaroni and white glue montage of scenes from a damaged home.

"After making this video, little Jimmy Popples was fatally injured by his drunken mother."

Won't that be tasty?
 
I've certainly not made a dent, judging by the responses here. No worries, the tragedy machine will continue production and soon enough the next serving of sadness will be along to tug the heartstrings for our amusement. If we are lucky, it will be a macaroni and white glue montage of scenes from a damaged home.

"After making this video, little Jimmy Popples was fatally injured by his drunken mother."

Won't that be tasty?

It is amazing that you can try to make mocking a dead teenager for not making her suicide note entertaining enough for you seem like you're taking the high road.
 
It is amazing that you can try to make mocking a dead teenager for not making her suicide note entertaining enough for you seem like you're taking the high road.

It's a skill. A talent. Communication.

I do appreciate the phrase, "mocking a dead teenager." Powerful stuff. Do you suppose she's in heaven now, having a fit about it?

I didn't post the video. I didn't know what it was about. The video is the fifth post in this thread, in response to "Who is Amanda Todd?" I didn't even watch the whole thing - it's terrible. When I did find out (mostly through comments) what was going on, it became even more ghastly.

The fault is partly mine for clicking without knowing the context. My bad.

But what's next, do we get our jollies from the misfortunes of the halt and the lame? Here's a pro tip: If you think Christopher Hitchens' talks became more poignant after he started displaying the signs of advanced cancer, you missed the import.

Have we become so inured that we need to be shocked by a dead girl to have any chance of flexing the scar tissue around our psyches? Do you really like living in a world where teen suicide is so disregarded it takes video from the victim to garner any notice?
 
It's a skill. A talent. Communication.

And Amanda Todd has managed to communicate exactly what she wanted to to millions of people. Do you think it possible, perhaps, that the fault here lies with you, rather than her?

I didn't post the video. I didn't know what it was about.

Yet that still didn't prevent you from going off on one about it.

I didn't even watch the whole thing - it's terrible.

Of course, it's the style of presentation that's terrible, not the story of abuse and harassment contained within.

The fault is partly mine for clicking without knowing the context. My bad.

No, your "bad" is for continuing to mock the video for its presentation style, rather than showing any sympathy for the dead young girl, once you did know its content. What you think about the fact that she's holding up cards is what's really important, right?

Do you really like living in a world where teen suicide is so disregarded it takes video from the victim to garner any notice?

I'm not overly keen on living in a world where teen suicide is so disregarded that people will continue to berate a teenager's suicide note for not being presented in a palatable enough fashion for them, rather than giving any indication that the fact that a teenage girl was harassed and bullied for years until she took her own life is in any way significant. Do you really like living in a world where the style of presentation of a teenager's suicide note is more important to people than the fact that someone who is only 15 can get to the point where they decide that life is no longer worth living? Evidently you do.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom