Why I despise the Truthers

The path of greatest resistance would be down the center of the building. The path of least resistance would be outward. That is the path that the walls took. That's why you see multi-story sections of the walls standing upright in the proper orientation against the sides of surrounding buildings. But the floors did not have any forces acting upon them to drive them outward, so they fell straight down. That was, for the floors, the path of least resistance.

The core columns also followed what was, for them, the path of least resistance. They were all recovered pretty much in association with the footprint.

The "path of greatest resistance argument came out of a foggy mind.
 
So to sum up, you still are unable to describe a scenario in which the FDNY, NYPD, and PAPD could have been completely ignorant of a CD either before or after the fact, therefore you and anyone else who is a proponent of the CD Theory are indicting these agencies by implication.

Your argument fails, almost before you even start...

First of all, what do you mean by FDNY?
Do you mean all of the FDNY? or do you mean some of it?
Maybe you mean just somebody in the FDNY?
Ditto for the other agencies.
None of these agencies is just one indivisible thing -- they are made up of lots of individual people.
Same thing regarding the group you guys call 'truthers'... they don't all lie or have 'crackpot' ideas - maybe some do, but that doesn't mean they all do, and only a fool/biggot would try to push that idea.

e.g.
1) This guy is a 'truther'.
2) He is a liar.
3) therefor all 'truthers' are liars'

As to your idea that "any proponent of the 'CD Theory' is indicting these agencies by implication" , that's just another dishonest tactic, IMO.
If what you are saying were true, many crimes could ever be investigated, without 'indicting by implication' the various people involved...


You are probably smart enough to know this, so it looks like you are using an obvious dishonest tactic in order to attack people who do not agree with your own views.
 
Terry...

do you believe the words of Indira Singh on this matter to be true?

TAM:)
 
Your argument fails, almost before you even start...

First of all, what do you mean by FDNY?
Do you mean all of the FDNY? or do you mean some of it?
Maybe you mean just somebody in the FDNY?
Ditto for the other agencies.
None of these agencies is just one indivisible thing -- they are made up of lots of individual people.
Same thing regarding the group you guys call 'truthers'... they don't all lie or have 'crackpot' ideas - maybe some do, but that doesn't mean they all do, and only a fool/biggot would try to push that idea.

e.g.
1) This guy is a 'truther'.
2) He is a liar.
3) therefor all 'truthers' are liars'

As to your idea that "any proponent of the 'CD Theory' is indicting these agencies by implication" , that's just another dishonest tactic, IMO.
If what you are saying were true, many crimes could ever be investigated, without 'indicting by implication' the various people involved...


You are probably smart enough to know this, so it looks like you are using an obvious dishonest tactic in order to attack people who do not agree with your own views.

FDNY is Fire Department New York. Well known abbrevation in 9/11 discussions. No need to define it ad naseum.

I think I know where this guy will go,but I will sit back and let it unfold.:cool:
 
Terry...

do you believe the words of Indira Singh on this matter to be true?

TAM:)

I can't say I know that much about this -- I have no way of knowing, unless she has some reason to lie...

But I know that what she said does not implicate the entire section of FDNY involved, or even any of the FDNY, for that matter...
 
She says that they (The FDNY) told her they were going to have to bring the building (WTC7) down...can't get much more plain and simple than that.

TAM:)
 
FDNY is Fire Department New York. Well known abbrevation in 9/11 discussions. No need to define it ad naseum.

I think I know where this guy will go,but I will sit back and let it unfold.:cool:

Some advice:
1) read the post
2) reply intelligently to the post [or not] :)
 
FDNY is Fire Department New York. Well known abbrevation in 9/11 discussions. No need to define it ad naseum.

Actually the FDNY is the Fire Department of the City of New York and FDNY has been it's abbreviation for probably 100 years. It can get a bit confusing as we call the Police Department of the City of New York the NYPD. In addition, the Board of Education of the City of New York is now the Department of Education of the City of New York. I'm sure you get my point. :)
 
Last edited:
SINGH: "After midday on 9/11 we had to evacuate that because they told us Building 7 was coming down. If you had been there, not being able to see very much just flames everywhere and smoke - it is entirely possible - I do believe that they brought Building 7 down because I heard that they were going to bring it down because it was unstable because of the collateral damage. That I don't know I can't attest to the validity of that all I can attest to is that by noon or one o'clock they told us we need to move from that triage site up to Pace University a little further away because Building 7 was going to come down or be brought down."

HOST: "Did they actually use the word "brought down" and who was it that was telling you this?"

SINGH: "The fire department. And they did use the words 'we're gonna have to bring it down' and for us there observing the nature of the devastation it made total sense to us that this was indeed a possibility, given the subsequent controversy over it I don't know."

from one of the CT favorite sources...

http://www.prisonplanet.com/articles/february2007/090207broughtdown.htm

TAM:)
 
She says that they (The FDNY) told her they were going to have to bring the building (WTC7) down...can't get much more plain and simple than that.

TAM:)

Someone from a gov. agency phone FD chief " Hi Jim, [Tom ,whatever] we have word that the #7 is compromised, so pull everyone back etc.. no details... national security...
 
Someone from a gov. agency phone FD chief " Hi Jim, [Tom ,whatever] we have word that the #7 is compromised, so pull everyone back etc.. no details... national security...
Yay, phantom phone calls. I was wondering when we'd have new imaginary evidence to add to the pile.
toot.gif
 
Someone from a gov. agency phone FD chief " Hi Jim, [Tom ,whatever] we have word that the #7 is compromised, so pull everyone back etc.. no details... national security...

now who is speculating? Read her actual words, as I have quoted above...there is no room for interpretation...she tells us what they said to her...

TAM:)
 
Someone from a gov. agency phone FD chief " Hi Jim, [Tom ,whatever] we have word that the #7 is compromised, so pull everyone back etc.. no details... national security...


Dang it, Terry, why didn't you come forward with this evidence before? We could have busted the case wide open long ago!

"All units, be on the lookout for a suspected conspirator. Name of Jim, Tom, something like that. Works for a government agency, or claims to. Has access to a phone."

I tell ya, if they don't have this perp in custody in a few hours, the police must be in on it!

Respectfully,
Myriad
 
Terryuk:

more speculation.

What we have is her testimony that THE FIRE DEPARTMENT told her they were going to bring it (WTC7) down.

Speculate all you want, but if you believe her testimony to be true, it directly accuses the FDNY of bringing down WTC7 and then lieing about this through denying it was brought down intentionally.

Edit: and all those 2nd/3rd/4th hands you mention...well if that is true, than all those "hands" are guilty of covering this matter up...are they not?

TAM:)
 
Yay, phantom phone calls. I was wondering when we'd have new imaginary evidence to add to the pile. [qimg]http://www.lethalwrestling.com/upload/toot.gif[/qimg]


Don't you know the difference between evidence and hypothesis?

All investigation involve hypothesis. Also when defending against a prosecution in a court, hypothesis are presented to demonstrate innocence for example.
 
I suspect you're most likely lying about being an EMT and lying about researching the truth movement. I'd actually like to be able to verify that you are an EMT and was at GZ on 9/11. Can you prove that?


I was never an EMT on 9/11, I was 16 at the time. If you read the post further it would clearly state.

I became an EMT and I am working on becoming a FDNY Firefighter because of the actions of those brave men and women.


Last time I looked it was the Truth Movement helping to expose the 'cough' the Bush Administration and your FAUX News heros deny exist. And no one in this movement claims FDNY, NYPD, & PAPD are murderers. Please provide multiple sources showing this is the claims of the Truth Movement or apologize to those who really are on the side of the 9/11 Hero's.

Do I have to post this again?

Update: People Died in WTC 7: This Makes Silverstein and the FDNY Guilty of AT LEAST Manslaughter
 
Last edited:
Don't you know the difference between evidence and hypothesis?
I absolutely know the difference. The point I was trying to make (and admittedly not doing the best job ever) is that's every bit as solid as anything considered "evidence" by the movement.

You know, because if they had something resembling real evidence... they might be able to prove any element whatsoever of the conspiracy.
 
Ah, so you're going with Israel/Mossad angle.

I'm naming the man who supplied the bodies to plant the explosives. I don't care what race or nationality or what agency he belongs to. He is a key player in the demolition of the Twin Towers.

He was also allowed to fly out of the country 3 days after the 9/11 attacks when the rest of us weren't able to even get onto a plane.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom