Why I despise the Truthers

Then why didn't the Pres and VP refuse to?

To mess with your head. The CTer's believe that Bush & Cheney are evil enough to have ordered the murder of thousands but they suddenly wimp out when faced with a bible and a purjury charge.
 
To mess with your head. The CTer's believe that Bush & Cheney are evil enough to have ordered the murder of thousands but they suddenly wimp out when faced with a bible and a purjury charge.
To mess with my head? Is that the best you got?
 
Not definitively according to them. In fact they say they are sure there’s plenty they’ve missed.
I'd say they've found out government isn't going to cater their hunches, which is exactly what I said. They already know the government's job isn't to placate weirdos, even if they might want it to.
 
An interesting start to describing the investigation you want. Would you mind helping me clarify a few specific points by answering these questions?

1. Should the investigators have the power to subpoena witnesses, that is force them to appear and testify under oath even if they don't want to? Or should witness cooperation be optional?

2. Should the investigators have the power to arrest, or cause to be arrested, witnesses who fail to appear on command? (Note that if the answer is no, the answer to question 1 must be that cooperation is optional.)

3. Should the investigators have the power to imprison or otherwise penalize witnesses who appear (or are arrested as per question 2), but refuse to answer questions?

4. Should the investigators have access to information that the U.S. Department of Defense has designated "classified" (or other similar designations e.g. secret, non-exportable technology, etc.) in the interest of national security?

5. Should the investigators have access to information that corporations in the U.S. have desgnated as trade secrets?

6. Should the investigators have the power to criminally prosecute and sentence individuals for crimes revealed by their investigation? If so, under what body of law? If not, what measures if any should they take if criminal acts are disclosed?

The answers to these questions are very important in determining whether I, or most other Americans, would be in favor of such an investigation, neutral about it (that is, not advocating it but accepting it if it happens), or actively opposed to it.

I would say yes to most of these. If 9-11 happened the way they currently claim what's not to disclose? If it's a concern for something like National security or any other reason they should be given an opportunity to make a case for said concerns. Without penalties the investigation would have no teeth so they not only should have the power but the penalties should be severe for not cooperating.

All right, here's the problem: As an American citizen in America, if I receive a subpoena that comes from anything other than agents of the American judicial system as established under law in accordance with the U.S. Federal and State Constitutions, it's trash. Either the investigation is being conducted by authority of the U.S. Government, or it's being conducted by foreign agents or domestic gangsters and it's my duty as a citizen not to cooperate with it.

What you seem to be asking for is an investigation that's independent of all levels of constituted government, but that has subpoena power and the ability to convene a court of law and enforce penalties for not cooperating. That's illegal and unconstitutional. If I were to reveal national security secrets to such a body, I'd be committing treason.

However, if you're looking for organizations that have experience conducting this kind of investigation, involving coercing people to appear and answer questions, and enacting penalties without Government authority, I can suggest the Mafia (American or Russian, take your pick), or perhaps the The Ku Klux Klan, the Mossad, Murder Inc., maybe a handful of others.

Respectfully,
Myriad
 
Damn I am angry.
I'm sorry I can't read all these posts without posting.
I'm new here so let me just cut to the chase, My Brother worked for Cantor Fitzgerald on the 103 floor of the WTC north tower and I had only visited him at work 5 days before 911.
These bozo's that think my brothers death is now some sort of game on the internet are beyond contempt and to be quite frank if I was in a room with them now i would smash their stupid brains all over.
This is why I hate them,
 
Damn I am angry.
I'm sorry I can't read all these posts without posting.
I'm new here so let me just cut to the chase, My Brother worked for Cantor Fitzgerald on the 103 floor of the WTC north tower and I had only visited him at work 5 days before 911.
These bozo's that think my brothers death is now some sort of game on the internet are beyond contempt and to be quite frank if I was in a room with them now i would smash their stupid brains all over.
This is why I hate them,

Welcome to the forum, and I'm deeply sorry for your loss.

And yes, the vast majority of these bozos think your brother's death is some sort of cool video game they play with YouTube videos and conspiracy websites.
 
Then why did the Pres and VP refuse to?

*Bolding mine due to Zen making a correction later. You can edit your post btw.*

I don't know, but what makes you think that being under oath makes one tell the truth?
 
These bozo's that think my brothers death is now some sort of game on the internet are beyond contempt and to be quite frank if I was in a room with them now i would smash their stupid brains all over.
This is why I hate them,

You would have to hurry or you'd be at the end of a VERY long line!

Condolences regarding your brother.

Welcome to the Forum!
 
Welcome to the forum, Mr. Sutcliffe.

I'm very sorry about your brother. I'm not sure there is any solace here for you, but I hope there is, and you are more than welcome to seek it.

I'll caution you that watching the 9/11 consipracy theory videos would likely be a very painful and wrath-provoking experience.

I hope also that you'll understand and forgive the fact that, grappling with monsters as we do, some (if not all) of the rationalists here including myself perpetually risk becoming monsters ourselves. That is to say, we get caught up in the intellectual challenge of argumentation or the heat of dispute, and speak in ways that the victims of this tragedy might justifiably find callous or even outright offensive. Humor that's intended to mock the mockers might sometimes strike a nerve it wasn't aimed at.

On the other side of the same coin, this seems to be a common experience here:

does-this-happen-to-you.png


Respectfully,
Myriad
 
Thank you all for the welcome. I promise that will be my one and only rant.
These people try to use our loss for political gain.
If you hate bush then just say so, damn I don't like Bush and I never liked Blair, but to accuse them of mass murder on that fateful day is over the line.
 
What would you ask those members of the FDNY who describe the collapse as "it was like they had detonators, like they had planned to take down the building, boom,boom,boom,boom, floor by floor"?

I would say they are using the word "like", to compare the event to something we are more familiar with, in order that we can have an idea of what it may have sounded or looked SIMILAR too.

Are you Dylan Avery...he doesn't know what a simile is either....

TAM")
 
Welcome to the forum Peter.
I am sorry for your loss, and the tragedy that was 9/11.

TAM:)
 
Watergate? It was solved by research. Darn, independent research. You truthers are just too challenged to do real research, why?

Watergate was solved in less than TWO years and they won a Pulitzer Prize. What is your excuses for messing up everything 9/11??? Sad.

There's a very large difference between Watergate and the current administration. When discussing breaking of Constitutional law the Bush Administration has gone much farther than Nixon ever did. Executive Privilege wasn't comparable too dictatorial powers during the Nixon administration, or Nixon would never have had too resign. There was a great deal of classified documents leaked during the Nixon administration which lead too his resignation. If the people who did leak the information hadn't put there jobs on the line, once again, Nixon wouldn't have resigned. Unless somebody breaks the law and leaks information which would some how incriminate this administration its going too be very difficult too conduct an investigation, while George W. Bush still holds office with Executive Privilege. I have actually seen a video somewhere, I'm not sure where, which actually begs for somebody inside the white house too put it all on line and leak classified documents. Hasn't been an unbiased, or should I say non-political, investigation during the Bush administration. Considering the on going investigation of our Justice department, it could easily be said, every investigation since Bush took office has been Politically motivated.

What exactly do you expect from the Truth movement. Isn't as though the truth movement has a voice of power. The current Administration has political control not only over the Justice Department, but any Federal Judge who could enforce Subpoena's which have been ignored. The Truth movement serves a very good purpose though. They're making noise because questions haven't been answered by an administration which has political control over all forms of investigation. How could the Truth Movement Possibly conduct an investigation when most the documents they need too even begin aren't at there disposal? I think the Noise is a pure example of American Freedom and the day the noise goes away were no longer a Free Country.


"You can never silence the voice of the voice less" Rage Against the Machine.
 
Last edited:
Damn I am angry.
I'm sorry I can't read all these posts without posting.
I'm new here so let me just cut to the chase, My Brother worked for Cantor Fitzgerald on the 103 floor of the WTC north tower and I had only visited him at work 5 days before 911.
These bozo's that think my brothers death is now some sort of game on the internet are beyond contempt and to be quite frank if I was in a room with them now i would smash their stupid brains all over.
This is why I hate them,
Welcome Mr. Sutcliffe.
I am very sad about your brother. Your anger is quite justified, as these fools want to use him as a political football in their sick game.
I hope you will continue to contribute here. It sounds like you have a unique perspective, that we all can learn from. Maybe in some small way we can offer you a bit of comfort as well.

Thanks for coming here!
 
Last edited:
*Bolding mine due to Zen making a correction later. You can edit your post btw.*

I don't know, but what makes you think that being under oath makes one tell the truth?
Well for one thing it's already proven that the Pres and the VP didn't want to testify separately to the 9-11 commission under oath. This is because if they had to lie they would have had to tell the same lie the same way without knowing what the other said. This would go the same for all under oath. That's how NORAD and the FAA got caught saying things that just weren't true according to Tom Kean.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom