Why I despise the Truthers

short and sweet response

Zen even though it wasn't addressed too me I'll answer your question.

I would only accept a new investigations findings if a few variables were met. First the findings would have too have overwhelming proof the entire operation was conducted by a foreign group such as "Al-qaeda", which currently there isn't anything substantial. 2nd all documents and executive orders pre-911 too present day would have too be declassified for public knowledge. This disclosure would have too include anything and everything in regards too 911 itself and the Iraq operation which followed. Last and most importantly the investigation must be conducted by an entity outside the Federal branch of government.


Since documents can be classified for up too 25 years I'll be 56 years old before anything substantial is proven. As I have visited declassified archives a few times, I am very aware of the Black Magic Marker which is used on many documents before there release. Even by 2026 when the day of 911 becomes declassified information its highly unlikely the whole truth will come too bare. I enjoy the company of the truth movement however from experience I feel its a lost cause. I do feel very strongly the government has failed too substantiate there claims of 911, however with current information available its impossible to substantiate any alternative theory. This last sentence is the exact reason I feel without any doubt 911 was much bigger than an act of terrorism. Posts which ask "Truthers" for concrete proof, for any alternative view, simply plays into the hands of the "Federal Government", doing exactly they'd hoped. Just imagine it from the opposite perspective once. The truth movement although growing with a large base doesn't represent any kind of danger without concrete proof. If 911 really was an inside job, It was a complete success from the side of the conspirators.
 
If 911 really was an inside job, It was a complete success from the side of the conspirators.

What's ironic is that to many in the truth movement, not only was the 'inside job' NOT a complete success, they made so many mistakes that anybody with an internet connection and the ability to view YouTube videos are able to figure it out.
 
http://www.physics911.net/stevenjones
A truly independent, international panel would consider all viable hypotheses, including the pre-positioned-explosives theory, guided not by politicized notions and constraints, but rather by observations and calculations, to reach a scientific conclusion. Questioning (preferably under oath) of officials who approved the rapid removal and destruction of the WTC steel beams and columns before they could be properly analyzed — and others as outlined above — should proceed in the United States.

As far as a criminal an investigation…

I would imagine there would first need to be a new administration then a real attorney general and a Department of Justice that does its job. There would need to be congressional hearings where no one is out of reach or above questioning even if they have already left their position or office. Maybe even a new commission. Ultimately seeing what 9-11 led to there should be War Crime trials led by an international body. The US also needs to take a hard look at War profiteering.

An interesting start to describing the investigation you want. Would you mind helping me clarify a few specific points by answering these questions?

1. Should the investigators have the power to subpoena witnesses, that is force them to appear and testify under oath even if they don't want to? Or should witness cooperation be optional?

2. Should the investigators have the power to arrest, or cause to be arrested, witnesses who fail to appear on command? (Note that if the answer is no, the answer to question 1 must be that cooperation is optional.)

3. Should the investigators have the power to imprison or otherwise penalize witnesses who appear (or are arrested as per question 2), but refuse to answer questions?

4. Should the investigators have access to information that the U.S. Department of Defense has designated "classified" (or other similar designations e.g. secret, non-exportable technology, etc.) in the interest of national security?

5. Should the investigators have access to information that corporations in the U.S. have desgnated as trade secrets?

6. Should the investigators have the power to criminally prosecute and sentence individuals for crimes revealed by their investigation? If so, under what body of law? If not, what measures if any should they take if criminal acts are disclosed?

The answers to these questions are very important in determining whether I, or most other Americans, would be in favor of such an investigation, neutral about it (that is, not advocating it but accepting it if it happens), or actively opposed to it.

Respectfully,
Myriad
 
Thank you. Just out of curiosity what are the names of the people who will be in attendance at the next Super bowl? Come on quick. I'm waiting.

Roger Gaudell will be at the Superbowl this year. There I have named one person. Can you name one person for your investigation?
 
As someone said above, "Oh my!" This really is one of the worst arguments I've seen from a truther.

If I'm not mistaken, the tallest building that the Loizeaux family has taken down was 30 stories tall. And even though they only rigged 11 of those 30 floors with explosives, it took them an entire month to wire it up. An entire month for 11 stories. How long would it take to rig 220+ stories?

Now you're arguing that they should be able to rig 220 stories in the same amount of time that it took the planes and fire to bring down the towers. You're in serious need of professional help if you can't see the fallacy in that..

One word demolishes all of your arguments, Steve: THERMITE.

:rolleyes:
 
It was only in April when I started researching more into the truth movement to better understand what their "evidence" is. As most of you have come to the same conclusion as I have, they are full of [rule8].

What makes me despise the Truthers more is the fact that they call the FDNY, NYPD, and PAPD murders. They claim that they were involved with the horrible acts of 9/11.

I hope you truthers can sleep at night for stepping on the honor and memory that these men and women have about their job.

Is it not unjust, to despise people just because of their point of view. I believe so.

At this moment in time I myself am undecided as to what happened on that fateful day, which is part of the reason I came to this forum. I doubt if I will ever know the truth (considering the response I got here) :rolleyes:

But one thing I can say, is that from all the research I have done, into both sides, I can honestly say that I have not read of any "truthers" who have called "the FDNY, NYPD, and PAPD murders (sic)".
 
Last edited:
But one thing I can say, is that from all the research I have done, into both sides, I can honestly say that I have not read of any "truthers" who have called "the FDNY, NYPD, and PAPD murders (sic)".

No, they're not dumb enough to phrase it like that. But their whole WTC7 demolition can't help but impliacte the FDNY in at least the coverup, if not the execution.

Only Alex Jones has had the gall to come right out and say it (on his website) and he's been denying it ever since.
 
Is it not unjust, to despise people just because of their point of view. I believe so.
"the FDNY, NYPD, and PAPD murders (sic)".

You are very, very wrong! Not only do they accuse FDNY, NYPD, PAPD and many, many others of involvement, but any one of the various "conspiracy theories" must inevitable involve literally thousands of people in various branches of the US Military, specifically/mostly the US Air Force.

If you think for one minute that does not [rule8] off all of the military members here as well as most other member of this forum you are living in la, la, land.

No, I don't despise them I [rule8] them!
 
You are very, very wrong! Not only do they accuse FDNY, NYPD, PAPD and many, many others of involvement, but any one of the various "conspiracy theories" must inevitable involve literally thousands of people in various branches of the US Military, specifically/mostly the US Air Force.

If you think for one minute that does not [rule8] off all of the military members here as well as most other member of this forum you are living in la, la, land.

No, I don't despise them I [rule8] them!

You quoted me, "Is it not unjust, to despise people just because of their point of view" and said I was wrong.

I must disagree, it is very wrong to despise someone simply because you dont like their opinion. I think we shall have to agree to disagree on that one.

CHF states, "they're not dumb enough to phrase it like that"

Whilst you say, "Not only do they accuse FDNY, NYPD, PAPD and many, many others of involvement"

Do you have a link with evidence of this? Before I book my ticket to la la land.
 
Whilst you say, "Not only do they accuse FDNY, NYPD, PAPD and many, many others of involvement"

Do you have a link with evidence of this? Before I book my ticket to la la land.
All you need is any link to any theory that includes the words "controlled demolition," "bombs," "thermite," or "Bush aministration." Because there's no such thing as a conspiracy theory involving any of those factors that, once you actually start considering the possibility, could have ever have been pulled off without complicity by... at the very least... the NYFD and NYPD.
 
CHF states, "they're not dumb enough to phrase it like that"

Whilst you say, "Not only do they accuse FDNY, NYPD, PAPD and many, many others of involvement"

Just to be clear, truthers do indeed accuse the FDNY. Their logic demands that they do.

However most of them know better than to come out and say it seeing how vile an accusation it is. That's why they always squirm when the "pull it" claim is taken to its logical conclusion.

Again, look up prisonplanet.com to see what was written there about Silverstein and the FDNY taking down WTC7.

Naturally, no truther has the guts to waltz into an FDNY firehouse and make their accusations there.
 
You quoted me, "Is it not unjust, to despise people just because of their point of view" and said I was wrong.

I must disagree, it is very wrong to despise someone simply because you dont like their opinion. I think we shall have to agree to disagree on that one.

CHF states, "they're not dumb enough to phrase it like that"

Whilst you say, "Not only do they accuse FDNY, NYPD, PAPD and many, many others of involvement"

Do you have a link with evidence of this? Before I book my ticket to la la land.

It depends on the opinion. I wouldn't despise someone who is of the opinion that fish flavored ice cream is delicious, but I would despise someone who thinks that having sex with a small child is OK (I am looking at you NAMBLA!). I wouldn't despise someone who is of the opinion that there may be more to the story of 9/11 than we know, but despise someone whose opinion slanders/libels people like the FDNY, NYPD etc with absolutly no evidence.
 
..I must disagree, it is very wrong to despise someone simply because you dont like their opinion. I think we shall have to agree to disagree on that one.


Sorry Woooody64, gotta disagree big time with you on that one. Off the top of my head I can think of plenty of opinions that merit despising, both for the opinion itself and the person who holds it. For instance, those NAMBLA people, the ones who hold the opinion that it's OK for grown men to have sex with young boys of any age. Don't they deserve to be despised? Or racists who believe we should hang members of whatever race they don't belong to, how about them?

As I mentioned before, the world isn't all one big matter of opinion, truth and reality also play major roles. And some people try to wrap the mantle of "opinion" around beliefs that are stupid, wrong, and just plain crazy. If some people want to proclaim their opinion that the FDNY is part of a conspiracy that murdered many of their own members, so be it. But don't expect that opinion to be respected, nor that persons voicing it shouldn't be despised.
 
Last edited:
All you need is any link to any theory that includes the words "controlled demolition," "bombs," "thermite," or "Bush aministration." Because there's no such thing as a conspiracy theory involving any of those factors that, once you actually start considering the possibility, could have ever have been pulled off without complicity by... at the very least... the NYFD and NYPD.

They could not have been involved. Does not make sense, if the towers were rigged with explosives, I dont see how the NYFD and NYPD would be involved, why would they turn up?

if they knew what was going to happen? Would'nt of that been suicide?

Still does not disprove CD though.
 
Just to be clear, truthers do indeed accuse the FDNY. Their logic demands that they do.

However most of them know better than to come out and say it seeing how vile an accusation it is. That's why they always squirm when the "pull it" claim is taken to its logical conclusion.

Again, look up prisonplanet.com to see what was written there about Silverstein and the FDNY taking down WTC7.

Naturally, no truther has the guts to waltz into an FDNY firehouse and make their accusations there.

It is indeed a vile accusation, and one that does not make sense. I have saw a bit off stuff on pp.com, I will head over there again.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom