Why I despise the Truthers

What doesn't ? .

What does?

Coming from you, that's comedy.

And still more nothing from you. yawn


Thermite doesn't explode. Thanks.

I already proved this bare assertion wrong.
http://www.metacafe.com/watch/375503/thermite_pipe_bomb_loud/
And what was it Greening claimed about thermite?

You get that kind of reaction when the subject has been brought to bear hundreds of times and has been shot down an even greater number of times. .

Even more nothing from you. zzzzz


Why "certainly not all of it" ? Why are you so certain that not ALL of those explosions are due to that ? .

Why don’t you show me how every single account of an explosion can be accounted for? That’ll never happen.

Even the present isn't kind. Sure, they used the opportunity. But as unfortunate, tragic or despicable as I might think this is, it still doesn't mean 9/11 was an inside job.

How does it mean it wasn’t? How about a real investigation?
 
You counter a demolition pro with a software engineer? How pathetic.

We get a taste of Hoffman's idiocy on point #1 which he basically concedes the point but insists that because the towers were a non-conventional demolition a normal demolition pro couldn't spot it like a software engineer apparently can.

Yeah, the collapses was only allowed to use a 120,000 ton mass in the south tower and a 50,000 ton mass in the north tower. That, according to Hofmann, isn't enough to plow through the building as we saw.

Surely any video would have picked up the sound of those charges going off...right?

After all, according to Hoffman we're talking more explosives that, say, this.

I love it when twoofer "rebuttals" only serve to complicate things for themselves further. :D
I'm not saying this is what happened but THINK. If the Gov or rogue elements of the Gov blew the WTC like many CT’s believe don't you think they might have used I don't know... some explosive experts? And if these said experts blew the building or assisted how hard would it be to get some ofthem to write a paper for the "counter misinformation team"?

As far as the noise I guess it would depend on where the mikes are placed like on this one of the same CD. It’s clearly not as loud in fact you can hardly hear it. It also depends in what direction they started detonating. If they started at the top and then blew the rest after the building already started to fall you would hardly hear anything above the sound of a collapsing skyscraper. Above all of this it really depends on how and what they used to do it. That’s why we need a real investigation. You know one that doesn’t just stop at a theory of collapse initiation?

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sIOgpxyzqq4&mode=related&search=

Besides there’s people who would disagree with you

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qWM64aSYxuM&mode=related&search=

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MDSGm2jhdA0
 
You counter a demolition pro with a software engineer? How pathetic.


Yeah right. Way to come with the facts and the name calling there.

ZENSMACK89, a question:

If your doctor told you that you were perfectly healthy and showed no signs of illness, but your mailman told you your doctor was wrong and that you actually have leukemia, who would you believe? And why?
 
ZENSMACK89, a question:

If your doctor told you that you were perfectly healthy and showed no signs of illness, but your mailman told you your doctor was wrong and that you actually have leukemia, who would you believe? And why?
Does the doctor think he might be responsible for my leukemia an if I do have it he might go to jail?
 
Okay, so let's assume that you have reason to be suspicious of what the doctor tells you. Does this then mean that you believe your mailman's diagnosis?
 
Does the doctor think he might be responsible for my leukemia an if I do have it he might go to jail?

Well, then perhaps another doctor's opinion may be in order. But would you seek out a mailman in this situation?
 
Well, one step at a time here. I want to see what ZENSMACK89 has to say about his mailman's diagnosis before we discuss the option of seeing other doctors.
 
Well, then perhaps another doctor's opinion may be in order. But would you seek out a mailman in this situation?
Well what if the mailman's prognosis was confirmed by a bag boy?
colbert.gif
 
I'm not saying this is what happened but THINK. If the Gov or rogue elements of the Gov blew the WTC like many CT’s believe don't you think they might have used I don't know... some explosive experts? And if these said experts blew the building or assisted how hard would it be to get some ofthem to write a paper for the "counter misinformation team"?

So if the guv hired Protec to blow up the WTC or to write a paper covering up the act then surely the rest of the demolition industry can spot the problems with their report, right? Yet all you present in response is some gibberish from a software engineer.

As far as the noise I guess it would depend on where the mikes are placed like on this one of the same CD. It’s clearly not as loud in fact you can hardly hear it. It also depends in what direction they started detonating. If they started at the top and then blew the rest after the building already started to fall you would hardly hear anything above the sound of a collapsing skyscraper.

Oh give me friggin' break, Zen! That was lame even for you. According to your own software-engineer-turned-demolition-expert, the WTC towers were destroyed with far more explosives than a conventional demolition. So how can you possibly sit there and argue that the sound of these charges going off might not be audible because a camera was too far away or a mic was on the wrong side of the buildings?

There were dozens of videos capturing the collapses. Some were from helicopters, nearby buildings, even the foot of the towers themselves. Can you show me one video that captures these charges going off? Just one???

Apparently not. Your first clip (from right next to the tower) doesn't contain any demolition-type explosions; just the noise of a massive weight smashing through the tower. Your other clip is apparently by some amateur giving his demolition analysis. Not interested.

Above all of this it really depends on how and what they used to do it.

So who should judge how and what demolition charges are used? Name the explosives experts you trust.

That’s why we need a real investigation. You know one that doesn’t just stop at a theory of collapse initiation?

Explain a) who should fund the investigation, b) which experts should testify. Give me names. Enough of this vague "new investigation" talk.
 
So if the guv hired Protec to blow up the WTC or to write a paper covering up the act then surely the rest of the demolition industry can spot the problems with their report, right? Yet all you present in response is some gibberish from a software engineer.



Oh give me friggin' break, Zen! That was lame even for you. According to your own software-engineer-turned-demolition-expert, the WTC towers were destroyed with far more explosives than a conventional demolition. So how can you possibly sit there and argue that the sound of these charges going off might not be audible because a camera was too far away or a mic was on the wrong side of the buildings?

There were dozens of videos capturing the collapses. Some were from helicopters, nearby buildings, even the foot of the towers themselves. Can you show me one video that captures these charges going off? Just one???

Apparently not. Your first clip (from right next to the tower) doesn't contain any demolition-type explosions; just the noise of a massive weight smashing through the tower. Your other clip is apparently by some amateur giving his demolition analysis. Not interested.



So who should judge how and what demolition charges are used? Name the explosives experts you trust.



Explain a) who should fund the investigation, b) which experts should testify. Give me names. Enough of this vague "new investigation" talk.
Like I said it's all opinion and yours is no different.
 
Like I said it's all opinion and yours is no different.

Indeed. My opinion is based on the views of demolition pros. Your opinion is based on that of a software engineer.

While it appears as though you're unable to defend your position with anything meaningful, could you at least explain what your "new investigation" would look like? I'm honestly curious since most truthers tend to avoid that question like the plague.

For example, you want a new investigation to look into what kind of charges were used, how many charges, how they went off etc. Who would you trust to do that?
 
I didn't bring up the mailman. I would go see another doctor. Maybe a couple of them who are not associated to the doctor I am suspicious about.

This is the problem. Most CT's believe either the Gov or rogue elements of the Gov are behind the attacks. The 9-11 commission had no authority over the very people the CT's point their finger at. I’m not saying they didn’t try or that the commission was in on it but what power did they ultimately have to get to the bottom of anything when the administration, FAA, and the Pentagon were allowed to stonewall them? That pretty much goes for any official inquiry to date.

So what good is it ever going to be? It seems that the only proof official version believers ever offer up is Gov sponsored evidence. It seems a big complaint of official version believers is that CT evidence isn’t gov supported thus invalid. It goes both ways and it get’s nowhere.

What started this present discussion about doctors was someone pointed to a paper that is used by the Gov "counter misinformation team". I would imagine that the "Gov misinformation team" wasn't set-up to change the mind of any current CT’s but to try and stop the CT's from recruiting anymore non-believers. Why would they do this if it’s all just nonsense that no one really believes?

What would be sufficient? Well this posted on 911physics would be a start as far as scientifically determining what happened.
http://www.physics911.net/stevenjones
A truly independent, international panel would consider all viable hypotheses, including the pre-positioned-explosives theory, guided not by politicized notions and constraints, but rather by observations and calculations, to reach a scientific conclusion. Questioning (preferably under oath) of officials who approved the rapid removal and destruction of the WTC steel beams and columns before they could be properly analyzed — and others as outlined above — should proceed in the United States.
As far as a criminal an investigation…

I would imagine there would first need to be a new administration then a real attorney general and a Department of Justice that does its job. There would need to be congressional hearings where no one is out of reach or above questioning even if they have already left their position or office. Maybe even a new commission. Ultimately seeing what 9-11 led to there should be War Crime trials led by an international body. The US also needs to take a hard look at War profiteering.
 
What would be sufficient? Well this posted on 911physics would be a start as far as scientifically determining what happened.
http://www.physics911.net/stevenjones
A truly independent, international panel would consider all viable hypotheses, including the pre-positioned-explosives theory, guided not by politicized notions and constraints, but rather by observations and calculations, to reach a scientific conclusion. Questioning (preferably under oath) of officials who approved the rapid removal and destruction of the WTC steel beams and columns before they could be properly analyzed — and others as outlined above — should proceed in the United States.
As far as a criminal an investigation…

I would imagine there would first need to be a new administration then a real attorney general and a Department of Justice that does its job. There would need to be congressional hearings where no one is out of reach or above questioning even if they have already left their position or office. Maybe even a new commission. Ultimately seeing what 9-11 led to there should be War Crime trials led by an international body. The US also needs to take a hard look at War profiteering.

Who would pay for this?
 
I would imagine there would first need to be a new administration then a real attorney general and a Department of Justice that does its job. There would need to be congressional hearings where no one is out of reach or above questioning even if they have already left their position or office. Maybe even a new commission. Ultimately seeing what 9-11 led to there should be War Crime trials led by an international body. The US also needs to take a hard look at War profiteering.
And where would this new administration come from? Even woo hero Ron Paul has said that there's no 9/11 conspiracy.

So when President Avery takes office and fills the NIST with convenience store clerks, maybe we'll finally get the official commission that confirms any evidence whatsoever of a conspiracy. Meantime, don't hold your breath... unless you're doing it for a cheap buzz. :cool:
 
ZENSMACK89 said:
It seems that the only proof official version believers ever offer up is Gov sponsored evidence.
Rubbish. Most structural engineers and demolition pros do not work for the US government. The WTC towers are the most famous building collapses in history. If there were something seriously wrong with the OS there'd be an uproar from those who understand these things best.

And no, AE911 is not the engineering community rising up in anger.

There are tens of thousands of experts all over the world from every race, nationality, religion, gender, culture, political philosophy. By all means show them your stunning evidence and bring them on-side. No one's stopping you.

It seems a big complaint of official version believers is that CT evidence isn’t gov supported thus invalid.
Nonsense. Frank Greening doesn't work for the government and yet I think his published papers on 9/11 are quite good.

Our big complaint is that your "evidence" stems from ignorance. We refer to demolition pros while your side counters with a software engineer. We point to structural engineering reports; you point to academic frauds like Steven Jones. One side has scientific and professional consensus; the other has "experts" setting up journals to peer-review their own work.

A truly independent, international panel would consider all viable hypotheses, including the pre-positioned-explosives theory, guided not by politicized notions and constraints, but rather by observations and calculations, to reach a scientific conclusion.
Sound great in theory but you're short of specifics. Give me names of the experts you would trust to invetsigate 9/11. Tell me whose conclusions you would accept - no bitching, no whining - if they dismissed demolition theories and backed up the official story.

As far as a criminal an investigation…

I would imagine there would first need to be a new administration then a real attorney general and a Department of Justice that does its job.
Again no names. Please be specific.

If your plan would be to put Steven Jones, Jim Fetzer, and Richard Gage in charge of things then just say so.

And like Redtail, I also wanna know who'll pay for this.
 
Last edited:
Who would pay for this?
The same people who paid for the results of the Clinton investigation and this illegal Quagmire we're in. If we can afford that bull we can pay for a real investigation into 3,000 dead Americans. Are they not worth it? A windfall war profit tax would be more then sufficient.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom