Why I despise the Truthers

3 more engineers show ross's errors, 3 to zero, back to you

Why would I show the needed numbers that prove Ross wrong. That's for you to do. Can you?

"As I said, if you look at his numbers he is wrong.."

I hear you. Now where? Just because the building collapsed doesn't mean it had enough energy on it's own to do so at the speed and the manner it did. You do understand this don't you? Wasn't everyone on here the other day throwing hissy over my plane only statement?

Numbers are needed to show Ross wrong, why are you unable, unprepared, unaware of how to do the simple math to show Ross is bogus as you claim?
I doubt if you will take my work as proof. I have done the work and Ross is wrong. Which means Ross predicts Global collapse due to the fact he made an error. Ross says he is short 390MJ of energy for collapse to start. He is trying to say it would stop. Do you ZenSmack89 know what 390MJ is? It is the energy Ross says is missing. You know how big 390,000,000 joules is. Like 186 pounds of TNT. Gee the aircraft impacts were 2200 pounds of TNT energy. Ross says the top floors falling are only missing 186 pounds of TNT energy. I found with simple errors he made he was wrong by some 20 percent, and there was a 410,000,000 joules more energy availible to start global collaspe. I was being very conservative and see there were more errors but I think others have shown it better.

Plus another engineer who post here, found Ross wrong by 1389MJ, so there is about 1000MJ extra energy to begin global collapse. http://newtonsbit.blogspot.com/2007_07_01_archive.html So this work shows there is about the energy of a 500 pound bomb (500 pounds of TNT = 1,000,000,000 joules) extra to start global collapse. You see it is energy. I am not sure if you understand this, but you can get some help if you want to see why there are only 0.000067 percent of all engineers in the 9/11 truth movement.

There are over more engineers here who agree with this. My napkin scratching quickly found an error, http://newtonsbit.blogspot.com/2007_07_01_archive.html shows the work done by another engineer with Ross's work and the error. There are more examples of critiquiing Ross's work and proving it in error. Why not comment on them with some actual critiques?

Your turn, now you show why Ross's work is correct with numbers. Show me why http://newtonsbit.blogspot.com/2007_07_01_archive.html this is right or wrong. Please take your time to come up with some numbers and the critique of http://newtonsbit.blogspot.com/2007_07_01_archive.html.

It is amusing 9/11 truth follower who do not trust the government, trust an engineer who makes mistakes that are easy for other engineers to see wrong. Even Dr Greening can show you the errors! http://www.journalof911studies.com/articles/Article_2_Greening.pdf

So where are your numbers?
 
I doubt if you will take my work as proof. I have done the work and Ross is wrong. Which means Ross predicts Global collapse due to the fact he made an error. Ross says he is short 390MJ of energy for collapse to start. He is trying to say it would stop. Do you ZenSmack89 know what 390MJ is? It is the energy Ross says is missing. You know how big 390,000,000 joules is. Like 186 pounds of TNT. Gee the aircraft impacts were 2200 pounds of TNT energy. Ross says the top floors falling are only missing 186 pounds of TNT energy. I found with simple errors he made he was wrong by some 20 percent, and there was a 410,000,000 joules more energy availible to start global collaspe. I was being very conservative and see there were more errors but I think others have shown it better.

Plus another engineer who post here, found Ross wrong by 1389MJ, so there is about 1000MJ extra energy to begin global collapse. http://newtonsbit.blogspot.com/2007_07_01_archive.html So this work shows there is about the energy of a 500 pound bomb (500 pounds of TNT = 1,000,000,000 joules) extra to start global collapse. You see it is energy. I am not sure if you understand this, but you can get some help if you want to see why there are only 0.000067 percent of all engineers in the 9/11 truth movement.

There are over more engineers here who agree with this. My napkin scratching quickly found an error, http://newtonsbit.blogspot.com/2007_07_01_archive.html shows the work done by another engineer with Ross's work and the error. There are more examples of critiquiing Ross's work and proving it in error. Why not comment on them with some actual critiques?

Your turn, now you show why Ross's work is correct with numbers. Show me why http://newtonsbit.blogspot.com/2007_07_01_archive.html this is right or wrong. Please take your time to come up with some numbers and the critique of http://newtonsbit.blogspot.com/2007_07_01_archive.html.

It is amusing 9/11 truth follower who do not trust the government, trust an engineer who makes mistakes that are easy for other engineers to see wrong. Even Dr Greening can show you the errors! http://www.journalof911studies.com/articles/Article_2_Greening.pdf

So where are your numbers?
I don't see any credentials for the first two at Newton Bit. Forgive me if I'm missing something. Are they anonomous. Are they the same person. And why are you linking the same article by Greening that I gave you. It's the same one you just left out the reply from Ross.

"I doubt if you will take my work as proof."

How could I when its's not? I think you know, that's why you started your reply with that sentence. Conscience?
 
2 engineers and a scientist, what r u?

I don't see any credentials for the first two at Newton Bit. Forgive me if I'm missing something. Are they anonomous. Are they the same person. And why are you linking the same article by Greening that I gave you. It's the same one you just left out the reply from Ross.

"I doubt if you will take my work as proof."

How could I when its's not? I think you know, that's why you started your reply with that sentence. Conscience?
I have been an engineer for 33 years, I have a masters degree, MSEE. I am also a pilot for 34 years, if you are a US citizen and you or your parents paid taxes in 1975, I want to thank you for the million dollar training you provided; it was the best in the world. The other web site is an engineer too. I would say, over 100 years of engineering is at your posting pleasure.

How did I know you would not have numbers or facts?

Greening debunks Ross, Newtons Bits debunks Ross, I debunk Ross. It seem numbers do not help you, but your lack of numbers and facts also debunks Ross. You and Ross go ahead and stay in the building Ross says will stand, good idea.
 
Last edited:
I have been an engineer for 33 years, I have a masters degree, MSEE. I am also a pilot for 34 years, if you are a US citizen and you or your parents paid taxes in 1975, I want to thank you for the million dollar training you provided; it was the best in the world. The other web site is an engineer too. I would say, over 100 years of engineering is at your posting pleasure.

How did I know you would not have numbers or facts?

Greening debunks Ross, Newtons Bits debunks Ross, I debunk Ross. It seem numbers do not help you, but your lack of numbers and facts also debunks Ross. You and Ross go ahead and stay in the building Ross says will stand, good idea.
I still don't know who Newton bits is. I still don't know who you are nor do I want to. Don’t worry about what I know I can say I’m anybody just the same as you. Prove me or my source wrong in the same terms I present them in. It shouldn’t be hard for a genius like you.

Ross debunked Greening, Greening replied, then Ross debunked Greening further, and I haven't seen any reply back to Ross from Greening. Why is that? Did I miss something? Is Greening still working on it? The loss of mass that is.

Let me ask you something. This napkin scratching new flaw you claim to have found in Ross's calculations with your scary 33 year old million dollar training did Greening point out this flaw? Why not? Did he miss it? Do you have an independent consensus with Greening or a different view on Ross? If it’s the same did you come to it independently? If it’s different why is it different? How did you come up with something by just napkin scratching that your hero Mr Greening missed? What else has he missed?

Now you are going off with your babble about kinetic energy of the falling mass and whether or not the energy calculations were correct without addressing Greenings flaw of not accounting for loss of mass all the way down.

Now this was the end of Ross's last reply even after assuming for argument sake that Greening was right in his last response to Ross. It full of numbers and calculations so you should like it. Did you read it because you are claiming to debunk Ross but I don’t really see how you address it? Why don’t you school me with your scary knowledge and read it and tell me in layman terms how Ross is wrong. Was that you who referred to me as a “real dumb guy”? Ok walk me through it big mouth. Here is Ross go back and read the whole thing because you either didn’t read it or you are ignoring it or you don’t understand it. Debunk it in the same logical terms and language he addresses Greening’s flawed work.

http://www.journalof911studies.com/articles/Article_3_RossReply.pdf

Here’s the summary…

“By adopting Dr. Greening's own arguments, corrections, contentions, figures and reasoning, the analysis once again shows that the collapse would be arrested at an early stage. Dr. Greening has not disproved the logic and conclusions of my article, but has in fact reinforced the most important conclusion: that collapse would have been arrested at an early stage.

Further doubt has been cast on a gravity-driven collapse using the analysis Dr. Greening has provided in reference to the pulverization of the concrete. Combining this with our knowledge of the theoretical minimum collapse time having regard only to momentum transfer, it is shown that a collapse time of 17.5seconds, is the theoretical Minimum collapse time having regard only to the momentum transfers and the concrete pulverization. This timing contrarily does not take regard of the loss of effective mass that would be present due to the pulverization and the ejection of the concrete pieces outside the area where they play a role in promulgating the collapse. Having regard to this and the other energies involved, the theoretical minimum collapse time can be seen to be approaching double that of the figures given for the collapse timing in official reports, even with no account taken of the energy demand from the distortion and destruction wrought to the steel superstructures.”

PS Why have you or no one else touched the NIST quotes I posted?
 
No, just that no one heard any demolition explosions.

They should appear on every audio/video recording from 9/11, Zen.

Yes, they're that loud.
Maybe you have your hands on your ears. You know... like whenever anyone tries to point out facts about 9-11 to you? It might also help if you stop screaming NAH NAH NAH NAH
 
Maybe you have your hands on your ears. You know... like whenever anyone tries to point out facts about 9-11 to you? It might also help if you stop screaming NAH NAH NAH NAH


What would you know about 9/11 facts? You don't have any.
 
Maybe you have your hands on your ears. You know... like whenever anyone tries to point out facts about 9-11 to you? It might also help if you stop screaming NAH NAH NAH NAH

Translated = I have no idea why there are no large detonation noises in any videos and i will ignore further questions on this subject
 
infowars wins again

Now you are going off with your babble about kinetic energy of the falling mass and whether or not the energy calculations were correct without addressing Greenings flaw of not accounting for loss of mass all the way down.
Hey, you win. The numbers you presented have me stumped. I am unable to ace your detailed calculations. After being an engineer for 33 years I have never seen such great calculations showing Ross's work so clearly as you have shown me. You must of gone to GA Tech, they always are sharp engineers.

Thanks again for sending me to UPT, it was a very good year.

I am sorry I questioned your ability to do the math and physics to put me in my place. I only have a masters degree in engineering and it seems your training has got me beat at these complicated issues of 9/11. I have to know what school produced such a great scholar as yourself who has quickly supplied the numbers and calculation to put this issue to bed.

I am in awe of your ability to point out the relevant numbers and calculations to make it so clear where 9/11 truth stands on this serious topic.

Thank you
 
Maybe you have your hands on your ears. You know... like whenever anyone tries to point out facts about 9-11 to you? It might also help if you stop screaming NAH NAH NAH NAH

Now you are defaming my religion.

Hands and ears go together.

Then you scream!

NAH NAH NAH NAIN.

See the difference!!!

It willbring you wealth
 
Excellent. You're one of the first conspiracists to do so.

Please provide me with the testimony of any first responder who state they knew that WTC 7 was going to be blown up. These testimonies can be from before, during, or after 9/11.

Do it or shut your mouth.
I have provided you with several, and I have done this seven times now.

http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=-2179339594842383954&q=wtc7+smoking+gun

So I will now ask you, and the rest of the herd, for the 8th time, to address the testimonies in the video. Do it, or shut your mouth.

I should actually take back my comment about the sound of silence- there is the pretty clear sound of the OTer world crashing down upon all of you. How tragic.
 
http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=-2179339594842383954&q=wtc7+smoking+gun

So I will now ask you, and the rest of the herd, for the 8th time, to address the testimonies in the video. Do it, or shut your mouth.

Is this the best case? Just smoke and sound and fury?

Jowenko is shown a clip with no explanation. When he's told that it was seven hours after WTC 1 & 2, he begins to see how impossible controlled demo is--he first says "They must have worked really hard''--or words to that effect--and then they cut away from the interview. I recall that he has changed his mind. For one thing, he knows that there wasn't time.

There's no distinct sequence of explosions or puffs of smoke like one hears and sees in controlled demolition.

The one firefighter interviewed says he heard an explosion. I'm sure he did. As others have pointed out, the word is ambiguous. He heard the massive roar of multiple stories collapsing. He was, as he said "a deer in the headlights'--in a panic situation.

Despite the slanted way that video is edited, it doesn't present much of a case that building 7 came down from controlled demolition.

It even has the canard about no steel-framed buildings collapsing from fire.

Surely, there's something more compelling than this?
 
Last edited:
Is this the best case? Just smoke and sound and fury?

Jowenko is shown a clip with no explanation. When he's told that it was seven hours after WTC 1 & 2, he begins to see how impossible controlled demo is--he first says "They must have worked really hard''--or words to that effect--and then they cut away from the interview. I recall that he has changed his mind. For one thing, he knows that there wasn't time.

There's no distinct sequence of explosions or puffs of smoke like one hears and sees and in controlled demolition.

The one firefighter interviewed says he heard an explosion. I'm sure he did. As others have pointed out, the word is ambiguous. He heard the massive roar of multiple stories collapsing. He was, as he said "a deer in the headlights'--in a panic situation.

Despite the slanted way that video is edited, it doesn't present much of a case that building 7 came down from controlled demolition.

It even has the canard about no steel-framed buildings collapsing from fire.

Surely, there's something more compelling than this?
Follow up phone interview with Jowenko where he confirms his opinion on WTC7 after further review of the collapse.

http://www.pumpitout.com/audio/danny_jowenko_022207.mp3
 
Hey, you win. The numbers you presented have me stumped. I am unable to ace your detailed calculations. After being an engineer for 33 years I have never seen such great calculations showing Ross's work so clearly as you have shown me. You must of gone to GA Tech, they always are sharp engineers.

Thanks again for sending me to UPT, it was a very good year.

I am sorry I questioned your ability to do the math and physics to put me in my place. I only have a masters degree in engineering and it seems your training has got me beat at these complicated issues of 9/11. I have to know what school produced such a great scholar as yourself who has quickly supplied the numbers and calculation to put this issue to bed.

I am in awe of your ability to point out the relevant numbers and calculations to make it so clear where 9/11 truth stands on this serious topic.

Thank you
You're welcome.
 
Yes, we have heard that before...I do not believe he reviewed the WTC interim report. If he did, and still feels it was a CD, than he is woo...simple.

TAM:)
 
I have provided you with several, and I have done this seven times now.

http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=-2179339594842383954&q=wtc7+smoking+gun

So I will now ask you, and the rest of the herd, for the 8th time, to address the testimonies in the video. Do it, or shut your mouth.

I should actually take back my comment about the sound of silence- there is the pretty clear sound of the OTer world crashing down upon all of you. How tragic.
And for the 8th time your denial is noted.
 
Follow up phone interview with Jowenko where he confirms his opinion on WTC7 after further review of the collapse.

http://www.pumpitout.com/audio/danny_jowenko_022207.mp3

Ok. You've convinced me that Jowenko believes that the building could not have come down from fire, alone. Now, what did he know about how the building was damaged? What does he believe happened?

In considering the balance of evidence on WTC 7, is there something more substantial?

Such as: physical evidence of remnants of explosives? Testimony from people who set up the explosives?

Again, Silverstein's sound bite doesn't make sense as a confession of insurance fraud or of controlled demolition.
 
I should actually take back my comment about the sound of silence- there is the pretty clear sound of the OTer world crashing down upon all of you. How tragic.
Your bowel truth movement, consisting of a relative handful of impotent little agenda-driven intellectual lightweights, has nothing. No thing. Frauds, liars, and opportunistic fanatics all, grouped together under the banner of dumb. The sad yet amusing flailing or arms and stamping of feet you exhibit will not alter by even one degree the course of history.

Oh well.
 
Ok. You've convinced me that Jowenko believes that the building could not have come down from fire, alone. Now, what did he know about how the building was damaged? What does he believe happened?

In considering the balance of evidence on WTC 7, is there something more substantial?

Such as: physical evidence of remnants of explosives? Testimony from people who set up the explosives?

Again, Silverstein's sound bite doesn't make sense as a confession of insurance fraud or of controlled demolition.
Is there something more substantial as far as Jowenko goes? I don't know. Apparently on WTC7 he comes down on the side of truthers based on the video and I believe plans of the building someone provided him with. He has claimed it once and then followed up and confirmed his opinion in the telephone interview.

On the towers he comes down on the official version side primarily because it goes the opposite direction of a traditional controlled demolition and he also couldn't fathom anyone having the time to wire the building.
 
Your bowel truth movement, consisting of a relative handful of impotent little agenda-driven intellectual lightweights, has nothing. No thing. Frauds, liars, and opportunistic fanatics all, grouped together under the banner of dumb. The sad yet amusing flailing or arms and stamping of feet you exhibit will not alter by even one degree the course of history.

Oh well.
Yes right, right.

Unlike the Law abiding representatives of truth justice and the American way currently occupying the present Administration and infiltrating our Government agencies led by the intellectual heavyweight George Dubya.

Talk about opportunistic?

They used the deaths of 3000 Americans to fuel their twisted imperialistic agenda while filling their pockets with the spoils all on the backs of American casualties, dead Iraqi's, and tax payer money dulled out to their corporate friends.

History will not be kind.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom