Why I despise the Truthers

Is there a published source for this, NYC? If not, do you know which company?


The story was told by Firefighter Tim Marmion, Engine 16


So those were several things that we were thinking about, you know, things that you know scare you but things that I guess it’s better of that you know than not know. So after the building shook and the lights went out, we thought again we might’ve been hit with another plane, a bomb had exploded, or the building we were in was coming down. What it turned out was that the other building was coming down, and that’s what we felt. But being in the inner core of the building and people had asked me did you know that the other building came down, I don’t remember if I knew. I know I couldn’t see it and most people couldn’t, ‘cause you were in the inner core of the building, and it’s a huge building, you know, you guys know how big that building is, so you could be in that building and never see a window or light of day for a month you know. And so for us to actually see it, I don’t know, I don’t remember knowing that it happened. After a little confusion about whether we should go up or go down, we decided to go down. A lieutenant from Engine 1 decided, OK, we’ll go down.

We heard over a handy talky to evacuate, but we weren’t sure if they were talking about us or talking about the civilians. If they were talking about the civilians, civilians are leaving already … civilians know to get out. So they’re not talking about the civilians, they’re talking about us if they’re saying evacuate. They also gave ‘em a red phone. Our communications with our radios don’t work very well in a building of that size. So they gave ‘em a red phone and you can plug it in and kinda have like a hard line down to the lobby where you can speak to the command center. He did that and they told him to evacuate, to get out of the building. So we started down. We started down from 22, it was orderly evacuation, the civilians were at ease, that’s why I believe there weren’t too many people that knew that the other building came down, or if they knew, they must’ve been at ease because we were there.


www.mrbellersneighborhood.com/sec8/WTCMarmion
 
Granting that the kids who are infesting this forum lately are below-average in intelligence, why would any teenager or pre-teen think it's cool to swallow a load of steaming [rule 8]? How can making yourself look like a dunce impress anybody?
 
“He did. He was on the 78th floor, BELOW the impact point.”

So it never occurred to him that there might… what? WHAT?

He might have considered what was above him, the report he was giving was about the condition and fire on the 78th floor. Pictorial evidence that we have posted show fire raging above the 78th floor. For some reason you don't want to accept that?



“Would you please stop arguing from incredulity ?It's difficult to assess the structural integrity of a 110-floor building when you're inside it.”

No one who saw this coming could get in touch with how many... 300 Fire fighters in time? But they knew it was coming and knew exactly what happened a moment after the collapse. I know there was trouble with the radios but I also know they weren’t all broken.

No but it the information received from the NYPD went through the Command Channel then Command gets on the Tactical or Fire Ground Channel to pass that information along to other firefighters. Anyways by the time this information was received and passed by command it was too late, the south tower was already coming down.


“Didn't they order the evacuation of the building?”

Evidently not soon enough.

Hindsight is 20/20, when the NYPD Aviation unit radioed FDNY Command they didn't know how long the building was going to stand...they didn't say "Hey Chief Ganci, get out you have 2 minutes and 30 seconds...." They just reported the condition of the towers and the possibility of collapse.



“Didn't you read the posts ? Are you impaired ?”

You keep saying they knew but 300 fire fighters obviously didn’t know or have a clue and no one filled them in.

They tried to inform them. On a fire ground especially that size you don't know what the other hand is doing, all you know is you were given orders and if you confront anything like victims or building conditions you pass it on. Since nobody reached the impact floor, that information wasn't given by firefighters. The NYPD helicopter next to the building gave that information.



As of today we still have to contact Dispatch to get a hold of the NYPD if we need them. So cross communications is still delayed
 
Last edited:
...How can a plane do it on its own but a plane coupled with a secondary explosive be impossible to bring the building down?...
ZS, as I pointed out here, nobody is claiming that. If the structural damage and fires (both fuel and building contents) caused by the impact of a large, fuel-laden, fast-moving airliner could bring the building down, said impact plus explosive could of course do the same thing. No one is saying otherwise; the claim opposed to you is that no such explosive devices were present. If you wish to argue for their presence, fire away and present your evidence. But repeating the line quoted above is just beating a straw man.
 
Granting that the kids who are infesting this forum lately are below-average in intelligence, why would any teenager or pre-teen think it's cool to swallow a load of steaming [rule 8]? How can making yourself look like a dunce impress anybody?
Rage against the machine, dude!

(Belated thanks for the birthday wish, BTW.)
 
Granting that the kids who are infesting this forum lately are below-average in intelligence, why would any teenager or pre-teen think it's cool to swallow a load of steaming [rule 8]? How can making yourself look like a dunce impress anybody?

Almost all of these young "truther" teens think that they're somehow smarter than their counterparts who do not believe in these conjecture-based conspiracy theories. This makes them feel special...it's ok if they don't fit in with the "sheeple", they're just government shills. I believe this is the source of the elevated level of arrogance so present in their ignorance. Allowing their dearly-held theories to be "debunked" would eliminate their source of self-proclaimed supremacy, and make them just like everybody else.

Much like the child who deliberately ignores logic and reason to believe in Santa Claus or the Tooth Fairy, 9/11 CTers refuse to accept evidence against their theories. This evidence isn't just attacking their theory, it's attacking their "supremacy". Expect to see a similar response from CTers faced with "debunking" as you'll see with a child told Santa Claus doesn't exist. You're not just showing them the truth, you're taking away something that's dear to them. For that, they will resist.
 
Almost all of these young "truther" teens think that they're somehow smarter than their counterparts who do not believe in these conjecture-based conspiracy theories. This makes them feel special...it's ok if they don't fit in with the "sheeple", they're just government shills. I believe this is the source of the elevated level of arrogance so present in their ignorance. Allowing their dearly-held theories to be "debunked" would eliminate their source of self-proclaimed supremacy, and make them just like everybody else.

Much like the child who deliberately ignores logic and reason to believe in Santa Claus or the Tooth Fairy, 9/11 CTers refuse to accept evidence against their theories. This evidence isn't just attacking their theory, it's attacking their "supremacy". Expect to see a similar response from CTers faced with "debunking" as you'll see with a child told Santa Claus doesn't exist. You're not just showing them the truth, you're taking away something that's dear to them. For that, they will resist.

Wow, I have never looked at it like that. That is probably the best summary I have ever heard.
 
Much like the child who deliberately ignores logic and reason to believe in Santa Claus or the Tooth Fairy,

Hey, watch it there big guy, Your treading on very shaky ground. (I have youngsters near by):D
 
MJD I understand yourfrustration. Trying to show evidence to the herd is like living the monty python parrot sketch. This is a dead parrot, no it's just sleeping...
Buddy, I'm not joking when I say that I am practically in tears laughin at this page.

I'll be back in the morning...
 
Buddy, I'm not joking when I say that I am practically in tears laughin at this page.

I'll be back in the morning...
Did you figure out the truther video you posted? It is full of junk. Why post such obvious junk? Try to find something better, than sounds like explosions, and "I know what explosives sound like". Or the "pull it", please find a video with out pull it in it.
 
You know, I was curious how Hauer could have known about anthrax. Then I looked up his history and position as of 9/11.



So, yes, he'd have no reason at all to suspect biological attacks. (He also was working for the NIH on Septermber 11th.) [/sarcasm]

Of more interest:



It's more bad luck than a plan. But, it may be able to explain how Hauer could think it was Osama...

Source: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jerome_Hauer
I thought I did reply to this. I guess not. Sorry. I think that Hauer either be hung or get a metal. You would need a real investigation first to determine which.

Anyone hear anything about that Anthrax investigation as of late? Gee I wonder why those pesky terrorists would have stopped mailing that Anthrax.
 
Almost all of these young "truther" teens think that they're somehow smarter than their counterparts who do not believe in these conjecture-based conspiracy theories. This makes them feel special...it's ok if they don't fit in with the "sheeple", they're just government shills. I believe this is the source of the elevated level of arrogance so present in their ignorance. Allowing their dearly-held theories to be "debunked" would eliminate their source of self-proclaimed supremacy, and make them just like everybody else.

Much like the child who deliberately ignores logic and reason to believe in Santa Claus or the Tooth Fairy, 9/11 CTers refuse to accept evidence against their theories. This evidence isn't just attacking their theory, it's attacking their "supremacy". Expect to see a similar response from CTers faced with "debunking" as you'll see with a child told Santa Claus doesn't exist. You're not just showing them the truth, you're taking away something that's dear to them. For that, they will resist.
Much like the blind faith followers of the religious right, this present administration, lies about WMD's, and lies about 9-11.

Open wide and swallow.
 
Granting that the kids who are infesting this forum lately are below-average in intelligence, why would any teenager or pre-teen think it's cool to swallow a load of steaming [rule 8]? How can making yourself look like a dunce impress anybody?

I tend to disagree here, on this point...

I think most of our young visiting truther friends are "intellegent" in the sense that they possess a good deal of knowledge, and are able to reproduce it, and within their world view, interpret it.

What I think is lacking is an ability to critically analyze data, eliminating the bias of their world view, and process the information in an unbias fashion.

It is the similar to when we state that S. Jone's work is poor because he is a kook. This is not taking his data and analyzing it critically, free of bias. This is not critical analysis.

However, do not mistake this for someone stating "I do not trust S. Jones work because he is a kook". This has nothing to do with critical analysis of his work, or a lack of it. This is basically stating that the data or science should be scrutinized BECAUSE the author of said data or science may have allowed HIS OWN bias into his work.

I personally may not have the knowledge to honestly and fairly analyze his work critically (or I may, who knows), but I can still express my concern that he may allow his bias against the USG to influence his work...it is opinion, and there for I am entitled to it...lol
 
Who's a young truther on here and how would you know? The same way you know 9-11 was an inside job?

For most people, the label of "young truther" is given to someone either because (A) the person has revealed their age directly, or (B) the content, tone, and demeanor within their posts indicate someone who is likely of a young age. It someone is incorrectly deemed a "young truther" based on (B) it may not reflect well on the so labeled, and may be a hint to brush up on tact, civility, and debating techniques.

TAM:)
 
Who's a young truther on here and how would you know? The same way you know 9-11 was an inside job?


1.)Rev, and he as already said so.

2.)Unlike Santa, The Tooth Fairy, and the "Inside Job" theory....Science is real.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom