Why I despise the Truthers

Because they were looking at it from outside and could see the big picture.

Because they were looking at it from outside and could see the big picture.

Because they were looking at it from outside and could see the big picture.

Because they were looking at it from outside and could see the big picture.
So there weren't any firefighters that were looking at it from outside and could see the big picture?
 
As Frank Gayle, one of the NIST's lead scientists, later pointed out: "Your gut reaction would be [that] the jet fuel is what made the [WTC] fire so very intense. A lot of people figured that's what melted the steel. Indeed, it did not, the steel did not melt."

And it did not melt. It was weakened by heat. Most of the fuel for the fire was the office materials. Nothing wrong with this statement.

Quote from the FEMA report (Appendix A).
Recalling that the North Tower suffered no major structural damage from the intense office fire of February 23, 1975, we can conclude that the ensuing office fires of September 11, 2001, also did little extra damage to the towers.

Care to say where it says that? Because I could not find it in the FEMA Appendix A.

NCSTAR 1-6, NIST states that “results of both the multi-
workstation experiments and the simulations of the WTC fires showed that the combustibles in a given location, if undisturbed by the aircraft impact, would have been almost fully burned out in about 20 min.”

That was on page 280, thanks for referencing that part. :rolleyes: Care to read the part about the fire having made its way around the floor? The entire floor did not start burning all at the same time.

And you might want to note the next bullet point that says the fires were much more intense than in a regualr fire, and how the columns heated in the simulations.

IN short, a classic troofer cherry pick.

NIST dismisses the possibility that jet fuel played a sustained role in the fires. “While much of the public attention has been focused on the jet fuel, most of this was combusted in only a few minutes.” (NCSTAR 1-5 p50, para3)


And this is true. The Fuel ignited a large portion of conventional fire combustables all at once.
 
So there weren't any firefighters that were looking at it from outside and could see the big picture?

I take it you have never been to the world trade center prior to 9/11? If you stood outside and tried to look up at the base you would have to lay down to look up at it. That was impossible to do because of the debris raining down on them as well as people jumping. Plus I don't know any human who as the ability to zoom in with their eyes on the impact zones. I don't know any firefighter on the fire ground who was watching CNN when this was happening.
 
WELL? Rev, answer my questions.

Don't you want to understand what happened to those towers or are you satisfied with being an ignorant liar?
 
Last edited:
And it did not melt. It was weakened by heat. Most of the fuel for the fire was the office materials. Nothing wrong with this statement.



Care to say where it says that? Because I could not find it in the FEMA Appendix A.



That was on page 280, thanks for referencing that part. :rolleyes: Care to read the part about the fire having made its way around the floor? The entire floor did not start burning all at the same time.

And you might want to note the next bullet point that says the fires were much more intense than in a regualr fire, and how the columns heated in the simulations.

IN short, a classic troofer cherry pick.




And this is true. The Fuel ignited a large portion of conventional fire combustables all at once.
I posted the one quote wrong. It's not a quote from FEMA. It read as the following on http://911research.wtc7.net/mirrors/guardian2/wtc/how-hot.htm

"In the mid-1990s British Steel and the Building Research Establishment performed a series of six experiments at Cardington to investigate the behavior of steel frame buildings. These experiments were conducted in a simulated, eight-story building. Secondary steel beams were not protected. Despite the temperature of the steel beams reaching 800-900° C (1,500-1,700° F) in three of the tests (well above the traditionally assumed critical temperature of 600° C (1,100° F), no collapse was observed in any of the six experiments."

Quote from the FEMA report (Appendix A).

Recalling that the North Tower suffered no major structural damage from the intense office fire of February 23, 1975, we can conclude that the ensuing office fires of September 11, 2001, also did little extra damage to the towers.
 
Did a plane slam into the building in 1975 and scraped off the fireproofing? And was the fire fought?
 
I take it you have never been to the world trade center prior to 9/11? If you stood outside and tried to look up at the base you would have to lay down to look up at it. That was impossible to do because of the debris raining down on them as well as people jumping. Plus I don't know any human who as the ability to zoom in with their eyes on the impact zones. I don't know any firefighter on the fire ground who was watching CNN when this was happening.
wrong.

I was there plenty of times. I worked in Jersey City and use to take the path train from exchange place to under the towers.
 
I posted the one quote wrong. It's not a quote from FEMA. It read as the following on http://911research.wtc7.net/mirrors/guardian2/wtc/how-hot.htm

"In the mid-1990s British Steel and the Building Research Establishment performed a series of six experiments at Cardington to investigate the behavior of steel frame buildings. These experiments were conducted in a simulated, eight-story building. Secondary steel beams were not protected. Despite the temperature of the steel beams reaching 800-900° C (1,500-1,700° F) in three of the tests (well above the traditionally assumed critical temperature of 600° C (1,100° F), no collapse was observed in any of the six experiments."


Nice cherry picking. Now how about reading the rest of the Appendix, or better yet the NIST reports, and come back to us with several differences as to why British Steel's experiment is not the same as what took place in the WTC.

Hint: Its not just the heat that's a factor.
 
I posted the one quote wrong. It's not a quote from FEMA. It read as the following on http://911research.wtc7.net/mirrors/guardian2/wtc/how-hot.htm

"In the mid-1990s British Steel and the Building Research Establishment performed a series of six experiments at Cardington to investigate the behavior of steel frame buildings. These experiments were conducted in a simulated, eight-story building. Secondary steel beams were not protected. Despite the temperature of the steel beams reaching 800-900° C (1,500-1,700° F) in three of the tests (well above the traditionally assumed critical temperature of 600° C (1,100° F), no collapse was observed in any of the six experiments."

Quote from the FEMA report (Appendix A).

Recalling that the North Tower suffered no major structural damage from the intense office fire of February 23, 1975, we can conclude that the ensuing office fires of September 11, 2001, also did little extra damage to the towers.


Q1. What level of redundancy was built into said building in the british tests, and how does this level compare to the WTC?

Q2. Were any (and if so, how many) of the external columns or core columns split/cracked off in the British 8 storey building?

Q3. It says SECONDARY STEEL BEAMS were not protected, but what of the PRIMARY ONES?

Q4. Though no collapse occured, what was the state in terms of bending, buckling etc, of the beams exposed to said temperatures in the British study?

Q5. What was the make up of the floor structures in the british example, and how does this compare to the WTCs?

Q6. How many of the floor assemblys were physically damaged prior to, or during the british experiments? How does this compare to similar damage to the floors of impact in the WTC case?

TAM:)
 
Last edited:
no one ever proved all the fire proofing came off. Not even NIST when they fired a shotgun at it.

Uh, yes they did. The shotgun pellets had the same approximate energy as the debris from the plane. The debris had much greater surface area, however, and so would have knocked a large amount, if not all of the fireproofing off.
 
Q1. What level of redundancy was built into said building in the british tests, and how does this level compare to the WTC?

Q2. Were any (and if so, how many) of the external columns or core columns split/cracked off in the British 8 storey building?

Q3. It says SECONDARY STEEL BEAMS were not protected, but what of the PRIMARY ONES?

Q4. Though no collapse occured, what was the state in terms of bending, buckling etc, of the beams exposed to said temperatures in the British study?

TAM:)

There's also the fact that its a system with a maximum of an 8 story load (vs. 30 or so for the towers) and I seriously doubt it had a truss system like the Towers did.
 
So there weren't any firefighters that were looking at it from outside and could see the big picture?

Yes there were, and the order to evacuate WTC 2 was given, unfortunately not in enough time to do it (it was done about a minute before the building collapsed.) More unfortunately the radio communications (a problem they'd noted back in 1993 and asked the city to fix, and it hadn't been) was so patchy and unreliable that only a few heard the call inside WTC 1. They evacuated and the ones that got out lived (a few that didn't get out did too.) The ones that didn't hear the orders died.
 
but the rest is true am I not correct?
No I find it hard to believe that someone like Jerome Hauer had the whole official version down moments after it happen but hundreds of firefighters had no idea it was going to collapse on them.

It doesn't add up.

Dan Rather: Based on what you know, and I recognize we’re dealing with so few facts, is it possible that just a plane crash could have collapsed these buildings, or would it have required the, sort of, prior positioning of other explosives in the, uh, in the buildings? I mean, what do you think?

Jerome Hauer: No, I, uh, my sense is just the velocity of the plane and the fact that you have a plane filled with fuel hitting that building, uh, that burned, uh, the velocity of that plane, uh, certainly, uh, uh, had an impact on the structure itself, and then the fact that it burned and you had that intense heat, uh, probably weakened the structure as well, uh, and I think it, uh, was, uh, simply the, uh, the planes hitting the buildings, and, and causing the collapse.

Dan Rather: What perspective can you give us? I mean, there have been these repeated reports that, well, yes, Osama Bin Laden, but some think he’s been over-emphasized as, as responsible for these kinds of events. I know many intelligence, uh, people at very high levels who say, listen, you can’t have these kinds of attacks without having some state, Iraq, Iran, Libya, Syria, somebody involved. Put that into perspective for us.

Jerome Hauer: Yeah, well I’m not sure I agree that, umm, this is necessarily state-sponsored. Umm, it, as I mentioned earlier, certainly has, umm, the, uh, fingerprints of somebody like Bin Laden.

Then that afternoon he knew something else before everyone else...

On September 11, 2001, Jerome Hauer advised the White House to begin taking Cipro, an antibiotic which is effective against anthrax.

Mr. Hauer's advice was not made public. Its value may have been underestimated at the time, but it was clearly demonstrated a week later, when the first anthrax letters appeared, and again three weeks after that, when anthrax appeared in letters to Democratic Senators Daschle and Leahy.

Jerome Hauer also held a job at Kroll who did security for the towers. They access to the WTC complex to do whatever they wanted.

This is all coincidence though right? That’s what I love about you GT’s. Your ability for suspension of disbelief.
 
Factors: Planes impact damage to outter & inner columns, fires on several floors, time & gravity.

And who says explosives could do all that? I mean really! :rolleyes:
 
No I find it hard to believe that someone like Jerome Hauer had the whole official version down moments after it happen but hundreds of firefighters had no idea it was going to collapse on them.

It doesn't add up.

Dan Rather: Based on what you know, and I recognize we’re dealing with so few facts, is it possible that just a plane crash could have collapsed these buildings, or would it have required the, sort of, prior positioning of other explosives in the, uh, in the buildings? I mean, what do you think?

Jerome Hauer: No, I, uh, my sense is just the velocity of the plane and the fact that you have a plane filled with fuel hitting that building, uh, that burned, uh, the velocity of that plane, uh, certainly, uh, uh, had an impact on the structure itself, and then the fact that it burned and you had that intense heat, uh, probably weakened the structure as well, uh, and I think it, uh, was, uh, simply the, uh, the planes hitting the buildings, and, and causing the collapse.

Dan Rather: What perspective can you give us? I mean, there have been these repeated reports that, well, yes, Osama Bin Laden, but some think he’s been over-emphasized as, as responsible for these kinds of events. I know many intelligence, uh, people at very high levels who say, listen, you can’t have these kinds of attacks without having some state, Iraq, Iran, Libya, Syria, somebody involved. Put that into perspective for us.

Jerome Hauer: Yeah, well I’m not sure I agree that, umm, this is necessarily state-sponsored. Umm, it, as I mentioned earlier, certainly has, umm, the, uh, fingerprints of somebody like Bin Laden.

Then that afternoon he knew something else before everyone else...

On September 11, 2001, Jerome Hauer advised the White House to begin taking Cipro, an antibiotic which is effective against anthrax.

Mr. Hauer's advice was not made public. Its value may have been underestimated at the time, but it was clearly demonstrated a week later, when the first anthrax letters appeared, and again three weeks after that, when anthrax appeared in letters to Democratic Senators Daschle and Leahy.

Jerome Hauer also held a job at Kroll who did security for the towers. They access to the WTC complex to do whatever they wanted.

This is all coincidence though right? That’s what I love about you GT’s. Your ability for suspension of disbelief.


1. His comments on the collapse sounds like what anyone would say, and translates to roughly...Big plane going fast hit building, causing damage and fire...building came down...how is this evidence of foreknowledge???

2. got a source besides PP or AFP to give us on the last statements about all the CIPRO/ANTHRAX stuff?

TAM:)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom