Why I am an apathetic about athe... never mind

If you really cared that much about it, you'd join a nudist colony. Of course, if you really cared that much, I'd kick you out of this thread.

If I really cared that much.

Marquis -- Are you flirting? That's kinda unapathetic. Nice, but not apathetic. Or am I supposed to be bored?

Oh, wait! I remember, I'm supposed to act bored, except that I look out from behind my fan and flutter my eyelashes. (Boy, it's been a while.)
 
Are you using the term apathetic in it's weak or strong sense? I think it's important we consider the definition. The English apathetic derives from the seventeenth century French apathie, in turn from the Latin apathīa, which seems to have entered the tongue from the Greek apátheia. Now of course this means we have to understand the use of ἀπάθεια in Greek philosophy, where it roughly can be described as "peace of mind", or a state of emotional detachment arrived at by letting go of worldly problems. It is in fact in it's original sense as seen in the Stoic usage a positive rather than a negative state - rather than a state arrived at by passivity, as in "Am I bothered?" it is perhaps closer to the Buddhist notion of release from worldly desires, and something achieved by heroic effort...

As such I think we must concede that most modern Apatheists are in fact not at all apathetic - they are merely uncommitted. This can be described as weak apatheism, as opposed who actually embrace Stoicism, and practice strong apatheism.
 
Last edited:
Also, let us consider the valuable insights to be found in
Like a Rock or like God? The Concept of apatheia in the monastic Theology of Evagrius of Pontus by: Bocher Rasmussen, Mette Sophia
Studia Theologica, Vol. 59, No. 2. (December 2005), pp. 147-162.

Abstract said:
Abstract

This article is an attempt to clarify the concept of apatheia as it appears in the Praktikos of Evagrius of Pontus. The condition (katastasis) of apatheia is central to the Evagrian understanding of the goal of monastic life, and the Praktikos is the treatise in the writings of Evagrius which deals most thoroughly with apatheia. The thesis of the article is that apatheia should be understood in terms of the Platonic distinction between stability and movement, and apatheia, thus, appears to be two different kinds of conditions, namely imperfect apatheia, related to the daily ascetic struggle of the monks against the demons and the thoughts, and perfect apatheia, related to the peaceful condition of undisturbed prayer, in which the mind contemplates the holy Trinity.

I think that this neatly illustrates the distinction between my proposed categories of weak and strong apatheism in the 4th century Hellenistic mindset: here of course the authors are examining the ideas central to the Greek ascetic corpus. I'd really like to drone on about this for about thirty pages, especially with reference to the dismal lack of faith healing training among British lollipop ladies, and the international aspects of road safety statistics with particular reference to the self-referential issues raised by an idealist philosophical stance on this important matter -- unfortunately I lack the will (from the Old High German wellan) to do so, so I won't...

cj x
 
Last edited:
I'm not asleep. I'm just resting my eyes.

Wake me up when the thread finishes.
 
Now of course this means we have to understand the use of ἀπάθεια in Greek philosophy, where it roughly can be described as "peace of mind", or a state of emotional detachment arrived at by letting go of worldly problems. It is in fact in it's original sense as seen in the Stoic usage a positive rather than a negative state - rather than a state arrived at by passivity, as in "Am I bothered?" it is perhaps closer to the Buddhist notion of release from worldly desires, and something achieved by heroic effort...

I'm glad you posted this, cj.23. Until now I couldn't be bothered to post in this thread, because it seemed too much effort to think of anything to say that wouldn't, by virtue of my actually taking the trouble to say it, be off-topic. I can now remain in keeping with the topic by making an heroic effort to post and say that I am entirely at peace with my apathy, and desire nothing more in the context of this thread.

Unfortunately, that rather closes the door on posting in it a second time. But I feel at peace with that too.

Dave
 
Excellent Dave is the first strong apatheist! Apathy in the UK!

cj x
 
I'm pathier than Hokulele, but cj has way too much energy for this thread.

meh...
 
I wish somebody on this thread would complete what they star
 
What difference does it make?

What will any of this matter a hundred years from now?

Entropy always wins; resistance is futile.
 
I, too, like monkeys and situps and stuff.


spell-check doesn't like situps.




come back Piggy.


This is why I'm, like, all apathetic n' ****. Piggy, he gone.:(
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom