Why do extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence?

I apologize as I am too tired to read this thread in its entirety atm, however I did want to toss in Hume's quote as I feel it is relevant:
"The plain consequence is (and it is a general maxim worthy of our attention), "That no testimony is sufficient to establish a miracle, unless the testimony be of such a kind, that its falsehood would be more miraculous, than the fact, which it endeavours to establish; and even in that case there is a mutual destruction of arguments, and the superior only gives us an assurance suitable to that degree of force, which remains, after deducting the inferior.""


Yes, it was thinking about Hume which first made me question this. I think that may only make sense if we also accept what I believe Hume's definition of a miracle was " a contravention of natural law" - a supernatural claim, not necessarily a naturalistic one outside our current understanding - what I call "paranormal" and Dawkins calls perinormal.

Relativity and the Big Bang are pretty miraculous to me - but not in Hume's sense. Hell, childbirth and rainbows, puppy dogs and starry nights - all seem miraculous. Are the explanations really more wonderful than the outcome? I dunno.

Thanks for the answer though - it was helpful, and i will think more on that!

cj x
 
I believe Sagan was making a metaphor to this metaphysical question:

Why do naughty women need to be spanked?


Er, OK, Senex. I'm English, so (consensual, adult) spanking of women is the cultural default - l'vice anglais. I am still not sure of your analogy, but you made me laugh!

Thanks to everyone for their comments and useful views, and yes they were all useful to me. Three things spring to mind ---

1. I sometimes wonder if we dos scepticism a disservice by making it sound somehow different to the usual scientific method. Now I might various describe myself as a "ghosthunter" , or "theologian" so I am in no position to be picky - but I can't see any real difference between scepticism as expressed on this forum, and rational normal scientific reasoning? Sometimes I wonder if the use of the word sceptical could be better replaced with scientific - as in CSI(COP). Is there any difference between scepticism as process, and the philosophical predicates underlying most normal scientific enquiry? In trying to understand scepticism however I hit a brick wall with "extraordinary claims" -- because to me the evidence required is quite normal evidence (by as very rightly pointed out, scientific standards.) Hence my confusion.

2. It's a bloody shame Carl Sagan is not here to explain himself, and what, twenty years on, his legacy and vision remain strong. He is sadly missed - and Marcello Truzzi as well, who I believe died last year, and may have originated the phrase, unless I am misled. Zetetic, or Sceptic, we need more thinkers like them.

3. There is no firm agreement as to what the phrase means - we feel it is correct intuitively, and it is useful, but it is hard to pin down. Is that fair?

oh and ...

4. I still have no idea what Senex is on about, but it sounds fun!

cj x
 
Now I might various describe myself as a "ghosthunter" , or "theologian" so I am in no position to be picky - but I can't see any real difference between scepticism as expressed on this forum, and rational normal scientific reasoning?

I think the key is that skepticism is the application of scientific reasoning to our daily lives. Many otherwise rational thinkers leave science in a drawer when they leave the lab.
 
Er, OK, Senex. I'm English, so (consensual, adult) spanking of women is the cultural default - l'vice anglais. I am still not sure of your analogy, but you made me laugh!

The story of my life. Yes, I'm American and living in the wrong culture.

4. I still have no idea what Senex is on about, but it sounds fun!

cj x

hehehe... the pond isn't that large. I could explain more to you on-line, but that would only make it worse for you ;)
 
Senex, I'm male, but there are plenty of sites that support your interests -- I just hesitate to list any in this forum! Hope you have lots of fun mate!

cj x
 
I think it;s a testament to the non-dogmatic non-ideological basis of the JREF and modern scepticism that one can challenge a much loved "motto" or "dogma" and inspire little more than a mild debate followed by a discussion of, er, other stuff!!!

cj x
 
Indeed! I've been tellinhg Mrs H that I spend so much time on the net because I'm having intellectual discussions.

So is it possible to have an intellectual discussion about spanking?
 
God, why is everyone having such a hard time with this?

It's simple: any claim needs evidence to be proven but for an extraordinary claim (9/11 conspiracies, UFOs, the paranormal, the innocence of O.J. Simpson, my father's cooking abilities) the evidence would have to be proportional to the claim- extraordinary as well.

It's said because people unfamiliar with the scientific method and the way science works don't get this.

Take Feng Shui, for example. If it were true, it would revolutionize all science. It would overturn everything we knew about the natural world. Since Feng Shui is claimed to be a science, we would need incredible scientific evidence to accept it (a brand new Nobel Prize to the first person to present it! Come and get it!), not the word of a middle-aged New Ager in California that since she moved her furniture around, she's been having more luck at work.
 
It's still possible, just a little less likely after the day Carl Sagan passed away. He was severe yet fair (so I heard) :)

As a sceptic, I must point out that that is anecdotal evidence!:D

Anyway, maybe we should drop this subject before we get reported for trolling.
 
It's said because people unfamiliar with the scientific method and the way science works don't get this.

Take Feng Shui, for example. If it were true, it would revolutionize all science. It would overturn everything we knew about the natural world. Since Feng Shui is claimed to be a science, we would need incredible scientific evidence to accept it (a brand new Nobel Prize to the first person to present it! Come and get it!), not the word of a middle-aged New Ager in California that since she moved her furniture around, she's been having more luck at work.

OK take dowsing. If I could demonstrate, 20 times out of twenty, the ability to show which underground pipe water was flowing through, out of ten possible pipes, I'd say that was evidence for dowsing being true. Perfectly normal evidence though? This my point - extraordinary evidence suggest some higher quality of proof than that usually required - and that I don't think is required, no matter how many other knock on issues there are. Heliocentrism was eventually knocked out by quite ordinary proof, unless the sheer quantity of proof is what makes it extraordinary? Quite ordinary mathematics demonstrated Relativity, and the experiments which went on to provide the evidence were surely not extraordinary?

cj x

cj x
 
I see what you're saying but I'd think dowsing would have much bigger implications if it were true. A practical test would be ordinary but perfectly sufficient evidence but there would be much more amazing evidence as well.

Like falling on my face is ordinary evidence of gravity but Newtonian physics are much more extraordinary evidence of the same thing.
 
Consider an ordinary claim such as "It's raining in Seattle" and an extraordinary one like "I've invented a perpetual motion machine".

CJs point seems to me that as far as truth value is concerned, the same degree of evidence is required to support either claim. The first claim doesn't require overhauling the entirety of physics to be true though, and frankly, it's such a trivial claim that I wouldn't even bother to doubt it.

Also, in woo-ish claims, it seems that they want to do the exact opposite. Rigorous, double-blind, controlled testing for drugs is fine, but my magic potion does fine with a few anecdotes and repeating the mantra "it works!"
 
Yeah, that's what I'm saying. To believe either one you need evidence but the evidence for each (by its nature) would have to be proportional to the claim.

Feng Shui, to be true, would have to overhaul the entirety of physics. So would dowsing and all of the other examples cited. Overhauling physics is extraordinary evidence. There could be ordinary evidence in favor of it as well, though.
 
When asked what evidence would make me believe in miracles, my answer is usually to hold out a key or pencil and say "If this floats in the air for ten seconds, I'm a believer." (Actually , two seconds would do.)

This sort of astoundingly simple evidence would convince me that I was at least wrong to rely totally on my existing world view and would force me to reassess many aspects of life.

After a few days with no repetition though, I suspect I would backslide . I'd wonder which was more likely- are the laws of physics subject to loopholes, or did I hallucinate? Was I hypnotised? Dreaming? Is my memory playing tricks?

Rolfe famously told a story here in which either she had a glimpse of the future, or her memory is wrong. The fact that this is a very sharp person with an excellent memory makes me reluctant to say she misremembered, but her evidence is not enough for me to accept precognition. How much harder for the witness her / himself to say- "this has to be wrong. My memory or perception must be faulty."
It is hard to distrust your own senses, especially when the experience seems very real.
That is what Sagan wrote about in "Contact". Ellie is absolutely sure she went to the alien world and met her dead father. She accepts that her father was an artifact- an avatar created by alien tech, but she is convinced her personal experience of that tech was real, though the flight recorders are blank. You might say she trusts her own inner conviction- which is a rather religious POV- but she did have the evidence of the signal and the device built from the signal. Sagan was being rather playful in that book.
The one-liner about demanding extraordinary evidence to me applies on several levels.
If told a bus just passed, I require no evidence at all, because it really doen't matter. If told a bus just went past upside down, I'd like to see a photo. If told it was being held in a tractor beam below a flying saucer, I am unlikely to believe anything short of seeing it myself- but am I hallucinating?
 
I admire Sagan greatly, but I really don't understand the point he is making here. Can anyone put it in context or explain how it works?

It's really very simple. Here's Sagan's own explanation:

The stakes are so high on whether it's true or false, that we must demand the more rigorous standards of evidence. Precisely because it's so exciting. That's the circumstance in which our hopes may dominate our skeptical scrutiny of the data. So, we have to be very careful.

The more important a proposition may be or the more emotionally involved we may be, the more careful we must be about evaluating it. That's all.
 
It's really very simple. Here's Sagan's own explanation...


Interesting, and sensible. Goes well with you admirable motto --

The more important a proposition may be or the more emotionally involved we may be, the more careful we must be about evaluating it. That's all.


Once again, thanks to everyone. I really do ask lots of questions! Apologies for that, as I am sure this has all been discussed many times before - it's just the search function turned up so many hits for extraordinary +Sagan I just gave up looking!

cj x
 
I'll sum it up this way. The kinds and quality of evidence passed off for UFOs might be sufficient if you are a birdwatcher because as long as the claimed birds thrive in that area, it doesn't take much more than a photograph to prove that you saw what you thought you saw and it isn't that big of a leap to think you saw that bird. However, the existence of alien UFOs has never been established so all the pictures in the world are wholly insufficient to prove their existence. Since the claim of extraterrestrial intelligent life coming here in a spaceship is so utterly extreme, it would require a lot to prove. Perhaps close footage of a landed craft, footage of the extraterrestrials exiting the craft, footage of human-extraterrestrial contact, samples of the biology of the extraterrestrials.
 
Several people have mentioned this, but I'll reply with my own take.

You have to consider that scientific knowledge is built layer upon layer on knowledge attained by earlier scientists. Even the smartest ever human being could not individually come up with the most brilliant insights without ever having read the works of earlier thinkers.

So as this body of knowledge is built up, brick by brick, over the years and generations, some claims that are contrary to this slowly building tower of knowledge will be rightly considered 'extraordinary'. That doesn't mean the claims shouldn't be considered, just that they need to come with extraordinary evidence to refute the shape of the tower of knowledge that has been created over the generations before.

Or another angle on it, if you prefer, is that there is literally an infinite number of potential extraordinary claims, and a finite amount of evidence, extraordinary or otherwise.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom