Why are guns made to kill?

You can... buuuuuut it's sort of in the same vein as attaching antlers to a field mouse for a live broadcast of a Christmas Carol.

I once saw a mint Canadian Beaver in camo at an NRA convention (National Rodent Association). I would have loved to own one myself but apparently it requires a Class III Omnivore permit and there's a three month waiting period...
 
I own a yodeling moose which illegal to own in most countries.
There is no reason for a civilian to ever own a yodeling moose.
 
I own a yodeling moose which illegal to own in most countries.
There is no reason for a civilian to ever own a yodeling moose.
I don't necessarily WANT a yodeling moose, but damnit I sure as fire don't want a bunch of peaceniks to take away my right to own one.

You know, just in case we ever have to rise up against the freestyle jazz musk oxen... whether they invade from outside our shores or have gained power within our own government.
 
Last edited:
God let's not get started on owning fanciful animals. Every time my girlfriend sees practically any animal at all she exclaims "It's so cute, I want one". The only thing stopping me from currently being waist deep in exotic animals is the fact that having them as pets is illegal.
 
God let's not get started on owning fanciful animals. Every time my girlfriend sees practically any animal at all she exclaims "It's so cute, I want one". The only thing stopping me from currently being waist deep in exotic animals is the fact that having them as pets is illegal.

Well, if she ever wants a yodeling moose I have a connection if you don't mind where it comes from.
Don't worry the serial numbers are filed off.

The moose was none too happy.
 
Last edited:
Try fitting one with a silencer sometime.

I still have the scars. :(

On which end did you put on?

There is a right end and a wrong end.






Come to think of it, there is no wrong end on a yodeling moose.
 
I see this statement all the time here. "Guns are made to kill." Why do you think this is true or not? While some firearms are clearly intended to be used to kill humans (M-16's, AK-47's), others (electric free pistols, silhouette pistols, target rifles) are clearly intended for sport shooting only.

Why isn't it possible that a gun can be made for something other than killing? Thanks.
??
"Sport shooting" usually means killing animals vs humans. I know some use guns to shoot targets, but by and large that is not why guns are made.

Keep in mind "guns" is a broad statement - but on the whole, yes of course guns are made to kill.
 
Last edited:
I do not care to provide any information to you to support your claims. You think your claims are self evident, anything I say will be meaningless to you.

You really do not believe that there is more than one way to calculate efficiency? Given almost any two data points, efficiency can be calculated. The numbers game can be very big, isn't this self evident? Or are only your claims self evident? If you make a claim of efficiency, why do you care what I think about it?

Ranb

What claim.? You might actually post what claims I have not supported.

It is actually up to you to support your claims, not me, not the tooth fairy. You made the claim about ways to calculate efficiency. Despite me asking you to provide some examples on a number of occasions you have failed to front up with a single one of those methods. You even tried to claim that you didn't make any claims about efficiency.

Ant time you're ready to support your claims.
 
If it was evident that someone was in the process of stealing firearms, I feel that the employment of the threat of deadly force, or deadly force if necessary would be morally justifiable, albeit illegal in Canada...
And you are able to pronounce judgement and carry out the death penalty for attempted gun stealing on whose authority?
 
Of course there are no, nor have there even been, any "guarantee". People have murdered with guns, knives, cars, golf clubs, baseball bats or even bare hands. The type of "guarantee" that you are looking for would require laws making it illegal for anyone to get out bed in the morning...

As there is absolutely no guarantee that you will not go mad and decide to shoot people I do not want you to be allowed near a gun. Sorry, not prepared to take the risk. I am prepared to take the risk with other not so lethal everyday objects. A gun is simply not an everyday object.
 
Where ever the law permits the use of deadly force, there are also laws that are designed to prevent "people from being indiscriminately executed on the whim of gun toters". I wasn't aware that you were unaware of this...

So you're not saying I was whining?

By then of course it is much too late. You have already allowed the gun toters to be judge jury and executioner.

As far as I can tell you want the right to apply deadly force on your own say so. By definition you want to act as judge, jury and executioner when you want. Sorry, but I don't trust your judgement, especially as you have never shown me that you can be trusted with a firearm or are not at present clinically insane.

The police go through extensive psychological examinations and are extremely higghly trained in the UK before they are allowed to carry a gun and we still cannot guarantee that they will not throw a wobbly.

I do not know what tests have been carried out on your sanity and in principle consider that the desire to tote a gun for deadly threat reasons, by definition, disqualifies that person as a fit and proper individual to be allowed near a gun.
 
As an example, at least here in Canada and the States, the armed forces are authorised to employ the threat of deadly force, or deadly force if necessary, for the protection of military assets (property). Actually, I have seen warning signs posted on airfields advertising that "DEADLY FORCE IS AUTHORIZED" for the protection of aircraft. Do they not do this in the U.K. or is such policy considered "murderous"???

The policy would indeed be considered murderous. Thank goodness there has to be a better reason to murder people in this country. People aren't considered so expendable over here.

The good citizens of the UK tend to object a smidgeon when the fuzz/military cull citizens for stupid reasons, such as getting their 'intelligence' wrong. For some reason we get a tad uptight at such culls. We don't tend to give up our lives as willingly it seems as other countries expect their citizenry to.
 
I carry one every day. Did they change the definition of everyday object?


That is why you would not be welcome in my vicinity. I couldn't trust you not to throw a wobbly and start culling some citizens.

I should have clarified that they are not considered everyday objects in states such as the UK where the government has a decent gun control policy following some 'legitimate' gun holders killing many children and other citizens. I accept that they are considered everyday objects in places like the USA where there are regular culls of children at schools and colleges.
 
I accept that they are considered everyday objects in places like the USA where there are regular culls of children at schools and colleges.
Yeah, that's why we have them. Snotty brats with their video games and skateboards and hippity hop music. They need the herd thinned every now and again.
 
Non sequiter.

If a gun is moderately more efficient than a knife, it is still more efficient than a knife. Therefore, it would make sense for armies to use guns considerably more often than knives.

Because, you know - they're more efficient.

Sorry, don't agree.

The fact is that guns are used significantly more than knives in regular battle against numerous opponents is because of their significantly greater killing efficiency in those and many other circumstances.
 
Point of information. Have we seen more than one? In my memory, there is only one, Thomas Hamilton in Dunblane. The only other similar case was Michael Ryan in Hungerford, but so far as I know he shot at random on the street and most if not all of his victims were adults.

Is there a case I've omitted?

What I found sickening after Dunblane was the glee shown by some US commentators. Clearly, since this had happened, nobody could continue to claim that strict gun controls prevent such incidents. Isn't that just great!

This is in fact a powerful argument in favour of gun control. Where access to guns is so much more restricted, the number of incidents is much fewer. We've had nothing since Dunblane in 1996. We have never, ever had an indicent of a disaffected youth taking a gun to an educational establishment and shooting up people.

Why not? Not because we lack disaffected youth, I'm sure. But disaffected youth lack access to guns.

There was a specious argument a few pages back that there was no point in restricting guns because the nutters would just use something else. Like knives. I pointed out that we don't have disaffected nutters massacreing at random with knives or bombs or anything else. These people must know it can be done (using bombs) because it has been done by terrorists and the methods have been quite well publicised. But it doesn't happen.

We've had two actual attempts at massacre by sword/machete. Total fatalities in both incidents was a big round zero. So much for these methods being as effective as guns.

Listening to the scary rhetoric around here, I can't help but agree the problem is not the guns it's the people. The very people who shouldn't have them (Americans with their primitive macho attitudes) are the ones clinging on to them. OK so far. But the presence of the guns reinforces the attitude. You'll never change the attitude while the guns are still available to be the objects of worship I'm afraid.

Rolfe.
You're right. I was thinking of both of them and got my multiple adjective/adverb wrong.

I'm not sure what it is but some people seem to think that they are the 'good' guys as if by some god-given right. The regular occurances of 'good' guys, like the manchester school teacher, losing their mind even momentarily seems to elude them. Luckily she only had access to an air gun.

I shudder to think what the murder rate would be if guns were as readily available in the UK as the USA especially as we agree that we don't lack disaffected youths.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom