angrysoba
Philosophile
Thanks, Pacal, for your response.
I take it that the later writings you are talking about are the Letters of a Regicide Peace. I haven’t read them yet, but O’Brien and others do indeed say that he notched up his rhetoric to a shrill pitch in those writings. I don’t know what it was that he said about Voltaire, although Voltaire has certainly had his principles questioned by those other than Burke for being a bit of a suck-up to the very establishment he made a living mocking. I am not sure if that is the charge Burke made about him. Others such as Rousseau, whose Social Contract I mean to read soon, have also had their moral stature questioned for acting rather selfishly and ungratefully in their private lives while being publicly famous for writing treatises of magnanimous government. Burke certainly pours scorn on the philosophes of the encyclopedie in his Reflections.
But it is difficult to understand how much of that is relevant in terms of who got the French Revolution right. If Burke failed to distinguish between moderate and radical revolutionaries, of what significance is that? It was the radicals who insisted on chopping off the heads of the King and the aristocracy who were then followed to the guillotine by the moderates. Burke thought that such chaotic events naturally followed from a complete extirpation of the French government. And yes, after the King was executed, Burke insisted no peace be made with the revolutionaries. He feared the spread of revolutionary ideas to England in particular through the back channel of Ireland, and in that he wasn’t far wrong given that Napoleon’s forces did indeed try a revolt in Ireland with Wolfe-Tone. This all happened later, of course, but according to Hitchens’ book, Paine was still cheering on Napoleon in a half-hearted way. By this time Paine had also completely lost the plot and seemed to be in la-la land thinking that Napoleon himself could somehow spread revolutionary ideas.
I think it was more of a case of two competing ideas of treason clashing.
I have seen it written somewhere that Burke saw the Revolution as a “conspiracy” but where does he say this in the Reflections? I think instead he did know that there was “mob” support but he was contemptuous of mobs and says as much using the example of the Gordon Riots – which Paine somewhat acknowledges. Paine does also agree with you that Burke had thought a revolution unlikely until it happened but I am not so much interested in the causes but the effects.
Are you talking about the English Civil War of the mid-17th Century? I think you may have been right to say that when Charles II came back to the throne that there was some implied or perhaps explicit demands that he accept a reduction of power and allow parliament more authority. But Burke says in his Reflections that the English government had a system of checks and balances which meant that it could alter those parts that were defective. On the other hand, the French Revolution sought to sweep EVERYTHING away. The National Assembly which replaced the acien regime was from its beginning an institution for centralized rule. Paine can’t understand the problem Burke has with a one-chamber parliament and asked what good it does to have two chambers which in Paine’s mind only increases the chance of error. The point though, as Paine was to find out, was that having a National Assembly with nothing to check it meant that when passions ran high there was no restraint. Such was what happened.
You are right, of course, about both English upheavals having a Vendee in Ireland, with Cromwell sacking Drogedha and King Billy at the Battle of the Boyne. Again, I don’t think Burke looked on those incidents with favour – but I could be wrong; I am new to this.
I’ll try to get round to replying to the rest of your post when I can.
I myself cannot take Burke too seriously. His overall predictions about the French Revolution turned out to be more or less correct but that is not because Burke saw and analysed the French Revolution with great accuracy. Burke's explanation for the French Revolution was that a bunch of philosophical dilletentes had taken over the French State by means of a sort of conspiracy. Burke flavoured his tirades, which as he got older got increasingly unhinged, with hateful lies. He for example called Voltaire a man without conscience. He also increasingly characterized the French supporters of the revolution, increasingly has a almost demonic force out to destroy civilization. He made virtually no effort to distinguish between moderate and radical revolutionaries, lumping them both together as evil. Burke utterly rejected any notion of a compromise with the Revolution which he regarded as an unmitigated evil and would continue to support in many of his writings the utterly untenable position of a full restoration of the old regime.
I take it that the later writings you are talking about are the Letters of a Regicide Peace. I haven’t read them yet, but O’Brien and others do indeed say that he notched up his rhetoric to a shrill pitch in those writings. I don’t know what it was that he said about Voltaire, although Voltaire has certainly had his principles questioned by those other than Burke for being a bit of a suck-up to the very establishment he made a living mocking. I am not sure if that is the charge Burke made about him. Others such as Rousseau, whose Social Contract I mean to read soon, have also had their moral stature questioned for acting rather selfishly and ungratefully in their private lives while being publicly famous for writing treatises of magnanimous government. Burke certainly pours scorn on the philosophes of the encyclopedie in his Reflections.
But it is difficult to understand how much of that is relevant in terms of who got the French Revolution right. If Burke failed to distinguish between moderate and radical revolutionaries, of what significance is that? It was the radicals who insisted on chopping off the heads of the King and the aristocracy who were then followed to the guillotine by the moderates. Burke thought that such chaotic events naturally followed from a complete extirpation of the French government. And yes, after the King was executed, Burke insisted no peace be made with the revolutionaries. He feared the spread of revolutionary ideas to England in particular through the back channel of Ireland, and in that he wasn’t far wrong given that Napoleon’s forces did indeed try a revolt in Ireland with Wolfe-Tone. This all happened later, of course, but according to Hitchens’ book, Paine was still cheering on Napoleon in a half-hearted way. By this time Paine had also completely lost the plot and seemed to be in la-la land thinking that Napoleon himself could somehow spread revolutionary ideas.
For all of his hysterical protests about the violence to the Royal family he seems to forget that Louis XVI and Marie Antoinette not only worked against the changes brought by the revolution but actively engaged in what can only be described as treason. Not surprisingly they got executed.
I think it was more of a case of two competing ideas of treason clashing.
Since Burke's understanding of why the Revolution happened is stunningly defective and amounts to a conspiracy by intellectuals. Oh and before it happened Burke didn't think anything like that would happen in France. Burke never seemed to have got the idea that the French Revolution had deep causes. Further in the early years when Burke wrote his Reflections... the Revolution had from all appearances overwhelming popular support. As the revolution got more extreme for various reasons things began to fall apart. But the reasons for that are complicated and not just that it was inevitable.
I have seen it written somewhere that Burke saw the Revolution as a “conspiracy” but where does he say this in the Reflections? I think instead he did know that there was “mob” support but he was contemptuous of mobs and says as much using the example of the Gordon Riots – which Paine somewhat acknowledges. Paine does also agree with you that Burke had thought a revolution unlikely until it happened but I am not so much interested in the causes but the effects.
Burke also down plays, when he doesn't ignore, that the many French Revolutionaries greatly admired the British system of government and wanted to establish something like that in Britain. But of course Burke made mighty efforts to explain away the unpalatable fact that the British system of government he so admired was to a large extent the product of the English Revolution of the mid 16th century which proportionally was more destructive and violent than the internal insurrections that occurred during the French Revolution in France. The Glorious Revolution of 1688 was accomplished by a foreign army and accompanied by much repression. I further note that both revolutions had their own Vendee in Ireland, with massive violence, dispossession and atrocities. I could add that Scotland also experienced revolutionary repression at this time. Burke more or less glides over this rather violent history.
Are you talking about the English Civil War of the mid-17th Century? I think you may have been right to say that when Charles II came back to the throne that there was some implied or perhaps explicit demands that he accept a reduction of power and allow parliament more authority. But Burke says in his Reflections that the English government had a system of checks and balances which meant that it could alter those parts that were defective. On the other hand, the French Revolution sought to sweep EVERYTHING away. The National Assembly which replaced the acien regime was from its beginning an institution for centralized rule. Paine can’t understand the problem Burke has with a one-chamber parliament and asked what good it does to have two chambers which in Paine’s mind only increases the chance of error. The point though, as Paine was to find out, was that having a National Assembly with nothing to check it meant that when passions ran high there was no restraint. Such was what happened.
You are right, of course, about both English upheavals having a Vendee in Ireland, with Cromwell sacking Drogedha and King Billy at the Battle of the Boyne. Again, I don’t think Burke looked on those incidents with favour – but I could be wrong; I am new to this.
I’ll try to get round to replying to the rest of your post when I can.