Who was right about the French Revolution? Burke, Paine or someone else?

Who was right about the French Revolution? Burke, Paine or someone else?

  • Edmund Burke, the arch-reactionary/reformist liberal got it right

    Votes: 9 36.0%
  • Thomas Paine, the radical liberal/godless drunk got it right

    Votes: 13 52.0%
  • Zhou Enlai, the evil Commie would have got it right if he had said what he didn't

    Votes: 1 4.0%
  • La Planète Autre: Please say more if you choose this one...

    Votes: 2 8.0%

  • Total voters
    25
Thanks, Pacal, for your response.

I myself cannot take Burke too seriously. His overall predictions about the French Revolution turned out to be more or less correct but that is not because Burke saw and analysed the French Revolution with great accuracy. Burke's explanation for the French Revolution was that a bunch of philosophical dilletentes had taken over the French State by means of a sort of conspiracy. Burke flavoured his tirades, which as he got older got increasingly unhinged, with hateful lies. He for example called Voltaire a man without conscience. He also increasingly characterized the French supporters of the revolution, increasingly has a almost demonic force out to destroy civilization. He made virtually no effort to distinguish between moderate and radical revolutionaries, lumping them both together as evil. Burke utterly rejected any notion of a compromise with the Revolution which he regarded as an unmitigated evil and would continue to support in many of his writings the utterly untenable position of a full restoration of the old regime.

I take it that the later writings you are talking about are the Letters of a Regicide Peace. I haven’t read them yet, but O’Brien and others do indeed say that he notched up his rhetoric to a shrill pitch in those writings. I don’t know what it was that he said about Voltaire, although Voltaire has certainly had his principles questioned by those other than Burke for being a bit of a suck-up to the very establishment he made a living mocking. I am not sure if that is the charge Burke made about him. Others such as Rousseau, whose Social Contract I mean to read soon, have also had their moral stature questioned for acting rather selfishly and ungratefully in their private lives while being publicly famous for writing treatises of magnanimous government. Burke certainly pours scorn on the philosophes of the encyclopedie in his Reflections.

But it is difficult to understand how much of that is relevant in terms of who got the French Revolution right. If Burke failed to distinguish between moderate and radical revolutionaries, of what significance is that? It was the radicals who insisted on chopping off the heads of the King and the aristocracy who were then followed to the guillotine by the moderates. Burke thought that such chaotic events naturally followed from a complete extirpation of the French government. And yes, after the King was executed, Burke insisted no peace be made with the revolutionaries. He feared the spread of revolutionary ideas to England in particular through the back channel of Ireland, and in that he wasn’t far wrong given that Napoleon’s forces did indeed try a revolt in Ireland with Wolfe-Tone. This all happened later, of course, but according to Hitchens’ book, Paine was still cheering on Napoleon in a half-hearted way. By this time Paine had also completely lost the plot and seemed to be in la-la land thinking that Napoleon himself could somehow spread revolutionary ideas.

For all of his hysterical protests about the violence to the Royal family he seems to forget that Louis XVI and Marie Antoinette not only worked against the changes brought by the revolution but actively engaged in what can only be described as treason. Not surprisingly they got executed.

I think it was more of a case of two competing ideas of treason clashing.

Since Burke's understanding of why the Revolution happened is stunningly defective and amounts to a conspiracy by intellectuals. Oh and before it happened Burke didn't think anything like that would happen in France. Burke never seemed to have got the idea that the French Revolution had deep causes. Further in the early years when Burke wrote his Reflections... the Revolution had from all appearances overwhelming popular support. As the revolution got more extreme for various reasons things began to fall apart. But the reasons for that are complicated and not just that it was inevitable.

I have seen it written somewhere that Burke saw the Revolution as a “conspiracy” but where does he say this in the Reflections? I think instead he did know that there was “mob” support but he was contemptuous of mobs and says as much using the example of the Gordon Riots – which Paine somewhat acknowledges. Paine does also agree with you that Burke had thought a revolution unlikely until it happened but I am not so much interested in the causes but the effects.

Burke also down plays, when he doesn't ignore, that the many French Revolutionaries greatly admired the British system of government and wanted to establish something like that in Britain. But of course Burke made mighty efforts to explain away the unpalatable fact that the British system of government he so admired was to a large extent the product of the English Revolution of the mid 16th century which proportionally was more destructive and violent than the internal insurrections that occurred during the French Revolution in France. The Glorious Revolution of 1688 was accomplished by a foreign army and accompanied by much repression. I further note that both revolutions had their own Vendee in Ireland, with massive violence, dispossession and atrocities. I could add that Scotland also experienced revolutionary repression at this time. Burke more or less glides over this rather violent history.

Are you talking about the English Civil War of the mid-17th Century? I think you may have been right to say that when Charles II came back to the throne that there was some implied or perhaps explicit demands that he accept a reduction of power and allow parliament more authority. But Burke says in his Reflections that the English government had a system of checks and balances which meant that it could alter those parts that were defective. On the other hand, the French Revolution sought to sweep EVERYTHING away. The National Assembly which replaced the acien regime was from its beginning an institution for centralized rule. Paine can’t understand the problem Burke has with a one-chamber parliament and asked what good it does to have two chambers which in Paine’s mind only increases the chance of error. The point though, as Paine was to find out, was that having a National Assembly with nothing to check it meant that when passions ran high there was no restraint. Such was what happened.

You are right, of course, about both English upheavals having a Vendee in Ireland, with Cromwell sacking Drogedha and King Billy at the Battle of the Boyne. Again, I don’t think Burke looked on those incidents with favour – but I could be wrong; I am new to this.

I’ll try to get round to replying to the rest of your post when I can.
 
One of the few who got the French Revolution right was Napoleon Bonaparte.
 
Reply to Pacal Part Deux

One of the things that bothered Burke to no end was that in the French Revolution low class people were, horror of horrors, involved in government. He thought such people has wig makers etc., should have no involvement in government that was reserved for "gentlemen".

Well, indeed, but this is to mix up two distinct things. I am not asking which of the two had the nicer principles or whose ideas about government you most agreed with but who was right about the French Revolution. Burke was, no doubt, a shameless elitist who thought that some people were of professions unfit for government. Even if we assumed this was an indefensibly discriminatory thing to say (and I don’t think it is indefensible as even Paine would no doubt agree), it doesn’t get us much further unless of course wig makers etc… were instrumental in restraining or in propelling the September massacres and the Terror.

Towards the end of his life Burke got increasingly rabid, seeing the contest with the revolution and the "Rights of Man", as a Manichean struggle between the forces of light and darkness and increasingly demanding the utter expiration of the revolution. In particularly incredible open letter Burke talks about how the revolutionaries get into the homes of aristocrats so that they can seduce aristocratic daughters and wives and thus establish "the rights of man" on a sure foundation.

Yes, there was no doubt some very lurid bits of counter-revolutionary propaganda and Burke himself was something of a knowing propagandist. It may be that he was not concerned with whether or not the stories were all completely true but thought that lying in the service of the counter-revolution was justified.

Burke accused the revolutionaries of destroying love and the family. Sounds woefully familiar.

True enough, but then so did Year One come to sound woefully familiar in later times. And those movements, often taking their cue from the French Revolution, did indeed want to destroy love and the family.

Burke showed very little understanding of the causes of the French revolution and his Manichean view of it was no help in containing its excesses and his preferred solution a return to the old regime, completely useless. Also his characterization of all the revolutionaries as the same simply wrong. This of course leaves the question of why did his prophecies to a large part come true. Well aside from also being prophesied for the English Revolution, these are the all too common tropes of revolutions. One should not neglect the role of Louis XVI. Marie Antoinette and those around them in trying to reverse the changes and hence playing into the hands of the extremists. It is possible the Revolution could have been consolidated in 1790-1791 as a Constitutional monarchy, which I should point out was the goal of virtually all revolutionaries for the first two years of the revolution. How things got out of control would require hundreds of pages of analysis and review rather than Burke's simple minded tale of philosophical fanatics hijacking a state.

I have already conceded the point that Burke didn’t expect the French Revolution and was therefore unable to understand the causes very clearly. But I have already countered the point of Burke seeing all revolutionaries as the same: in the end it made no difference how sensitive to the differences between the revolutionaries and it was the moderates such as Paine himself (and his pal Cloots) who paid the price for underestimating the zeal of the radicals. Elsewhere, some writers have suggested that many of the revolutionaries tried to ride whichever wave seemed the biggest at the time; Danton would be a good example of one of these opportunists.

Finally Burke's prediction that the survival of the French Revolution would destroy "civilization" etc., turned out to be false.

My understanding is that Burke thought the Revolution could have destroyed civilization, not necessarily that it would. In fact, if he had believed the revolution to have been inevitable then he would have considered his own rantings to be pointless. My understanding is that his Letters of a Regicide Peace were propaganda to demand steel in the spine of those such as Pitt who might underestimate the danger of the revolution.

As it happens though, we cannot say with any certainty that Burke’s prediction [if he made it: I haven’t read Letters of a Regicide Peace] that the survival of the French Revolution would mean the end of civilization would come true (it seems doubtful and hyperbolic in a way that is consistent with the idea that it was just propaganda) because the French Revolution was snuffed out by a combination of forces including foreign intervention, which Burke campaigned for, the rise of Napoleon, the restoration of the monarchy and various troubles since then.
 
*Necro thread warning!!!*

I found this thread in a tag search for "french revolution", having recently started reading the book, The French Revolution: From Enlightenment to Tyranny by Ian Davidson.

I was wondering if anyone had read the book. I couldn't find mention of the author in any of the "what book are you reading" threads.
 
And having read this thread, I think I notice a bit of Recency Bias. The most recently read or discussed book seems to be the OP's favourite at any one time. I do that a bit myself sometimes.
 
Thanks for the bump, this thread must have predated me or some of my current thoughts on the matter.

Anyone voting for Paine over Burke has to explain why Burke was generally in favor of the American cause and not the French. And he was basically right about the French; it went through violence and resulted in the Army taking over in the form of Napolean then took around 100 years to settle into a more or less stable republic.

Calling Burke an arch reactionary is dubious. As noted by others, he was generally in favor of Catholic rights and the American cause, an arch reactionary Englishman (protestant anglo-Irishman) would not have if they were actually arch reactionaries.
 
I was quite ignorant about the French Revolution so I decided to do a bit of reading on the subject. First of all I read a simple history called “The French Revolution” by Christopher Hibbert in which he states clearly, at the beginning that he has no interest in examining the ideas of the revolutionaries or counter-revolutionaries but rather concentrating on the people themselves.

Although I had known about the storming of the Bastille, the flight to Varennes and of course, the Terror, I hadn’t known about the September Massacres or even that much about many of the protagonists of the revolution. Although ostensibly neutral, Hibbert’s dislike of the revolutionaries seems particularly clear with his constant references to them being ugly and relishing blood. There’s lots of hacking off of genitals, frenzied slayings of nobles, parading of heads on pikes, the guillotine, even cannibalism while the King and Queen go to their deaths in relative dignity.

But I have just finished Edmund Burke’s Reflections on the Revolution in France and am now reading Thomas Paine’s spirited rebuttal of Burke and defence of the French Revolution, Rights of Man.

I can’t help thinking that while Paine’s principles are those I am more in favour of that Burke is the more clear-eyed of the two and on balance seems to have got the revolution right. In fact, he seemed to be even more prescient than even he would have expected given that he wrote his Reflections in 1790 before the September massacres, the Terror, the execution of the King; the very early days which even most liberal interpreters of the French Revolution think was a good period.

Burke’s argument is that the wisdom of the ages is a far better guide to good governance than some metaphysical musings by “doctors of philosophy” and he makes lots of sarcastic comments on the abilities of such people. Paine seems incredulous that Burke, who championed the American revolution (or war of secession) could talk this way and gives a litany of what seems like patent injustices that Burke is prepared to tolerate and a list of the great thinkers and principles which gestated for years before the Revolution itself. Nevertheless, Burke is unpersuaded that “rights of man” is any kind of consolation for a dysfunctional state and goes on to predict massacres, famine, increased radicalism and disorder in the country.

But, although he didn’t seem to have predicted the execution of the king – and Paine assured him it wouldn’t happen – maybe one of the most astounding things Burke wrote was the following passage on the nature of the new revolutionary army. I expect it is famous but I hadn’t heard about it before I read it the other day:



Taking the long view, was the French Revolution a good thing or a bad thing? Who was ultimately correct about the Revolution or should we take the words of Zhou Enlai, who probably did not say of the French Revolution, that it is too soon to tell?

If you think there have been other, far more incisive commentators on the French Revolution or know of any must-reads then please also let me know.
The thing about Burke is that his political philosophy read more as a defence of conservatism and an excuse of its abuses than a perscription to make things better. Hence why he only ever became a darling to the non-underpants changing right.

Oops, sorry I didn't realise I was replying to a near 15 year old post.
 
Last edited:
After one day, two posters have said that Tom Paine was right. I find that a perfectly acceptable answer although it would be more interesting if those people explained why.
Because Tommy P was da ◊◊◊◊◊◊◊ Man. *drops mic*
 
If you think there have been other, far more incisive commentators on the French Revolution or know of any must-reads then please also let me know.
Re-bumping this thread because I don't think you saw my earlier post about the Ian Davidson book. Just wondering if you've read it.
 
Re-bumping this thread because I don't think you saw my earlier post about the Ian Davidson book. Just wondering if you've read it.
Thanks. Sorry, I haven’t read the book but I had a look at the blurb. It does seem very relevant because, if the blurb is accurate, it argues that the ideas of the French Revolution were great but that it was hijacked by people like Robespierre etc…

Yet the interesting thing about Burke and Paine’s arguments was that they were written right at the beginning of the French Revolution and Burke foresaw the hijacking as he believed that the ideas were less important than the legitimacy with which people in France would see the new rulers. He thought that it was impossible to impose such legitimacy which is how he managed to contrast it with the Glorious Revolution of Britain or the American Revolution, the latter of which aimed to be a reassertion of English liberty essentially moulded from the English Bill of Rights that followed on from the Glorious Revolution.
 
Given that Paine was tossed in prison by the very Revolutionary goverment he supported....

Fact is both had very flawed views of the French Revolution. If Burke was too hostile; Paine was very naive about ti;.
Irony of course, is that the French Revolution, in the end, did not produce Liberty Equality and Fraternity ( which are sort of conflicitng elements anyway) but A Military Dictator in Napoleon.
 
"The Revolution had been prepared by the most civilised classes of the nation and carried out by the the most uncivilised and the roughest of people." - Alexis de Tocqueville.

Thought this was a quotable quote I read in the Ian Davidson book.
 
It is a common belief that Burke was right about the French Revolution because he predicted that it would lead to war and a military despotism. Why it led to a military despotism interested him more or less not at all.

His prediction is less impressive when you realize that what he was in fact doing was simply projecting the English Revolution of the 17th century on to the French Revolution. So not so impressive. What is also fascinating is how Burke danced around the fact that the English Political structure he so admired was the product of the English Revolution.

In his Reflections on the Revolution in France Burke, for example stated over and over again that the State's General in 1789 should have been the same as in the last time it was called (1614), otherwise it was a horrible breach of tradition. Further that the powers claimed by the Estates General were untraditional and violated tradition such as becoming the National Assembly. Why just like the Parliament of 1641 and later. Whose claims were in fact revolutionary and "extreme" and helped to set up the English system Burke so admired. Parliament ignored tradition and made claims to power that violated tradition quite explicitly.

The English Civil War was proportionally more deadly that the French Revolution in France and has for Vendee, that happened in Ireland. And of course a King was executed. And the Revolution ended up with a military despotism and lots of foreign wars.

After the restoration (1660) the old regime in England was not restored fully but only partly. In 1688 a foreign invasion (William and Mary), overthrew the King (James II), and installed a new regime and completed the establishment of Parliamentary supremacy, (Various acts, The Bill of Rights etc.). This was accompanied by much repression, foreign troops, and another bloody Vendee in Ireland. But the end result of all this was the Parliamentary system Burke so admired. Created by a great deal of violence, ignoring tradition etc.

It is amusing that Burke in his various writings was very well aware that most of the "Revolutionaries" early on simply wanted to create in France a system of government similar to that of Britain - Constitutional Monarchy. Why that wasn't achieved is an interesting question but not one Burke was interested in very much. Instead Burke said over and over again you can't have what we have because what we have emerged from tradition not revolution. Which was at least partly a lie.

The fact there had been no Estates General since 1614 and things had changed in the meanwhile cut no ice with Burke it had to be exactly the same because tradition. (The English Parliament of 1641 didn't think that way.)

Burke's understanding of the French Revolution was seriously marred by the fact his understanding of it's causes was bluntly idiotic. Before the revolution happened Burke seemed to have no idea that it was possible and thought France socially etc., was stable. This was utter rot. The serious financial, social and other problems in France were getting more and more serious. By 1782 it was painfully obvious that some sort of truly serious change was necessary. I won't go into the details of the unfolding crisis but by early 1789 it was disastrous.

Having little to no understanding of the causes of the French Revolution Burke instead conjured up a conspiracy theory, in which various intellectuals conspired to destroy the old regime, by trickery and deception and that right from the beginning they aimed at the annihilation of "civilization" etc. For decades before the Revolution these evil intellectuals had plotted, conspired to corrupt, French Society, destroy the basis of "civilization" to spread their evil beliefs throughout France and bring about the annihilation of "civilization". And of course all the so-called Revolutionaries were the same there were no distinctions between them in terms of wickedness and evil. Burke went so far as to say that these evil men sought to be tutors and teachers to the wealthy, worthy Aristocrats so that they could get into bed with their wives and daughters and corrupt them with their inferior, evil blood. At times Burke was positively foaming at the mouth.

And what was Burke's solution to the violence and excesses of the Revolution or in fact to the Revolution altogether? Why a complete and total restoration of the old regime, no compromises, no negotiation war to the max. A war of extermination, and everything about the Revolution to be annihilated. The Manichean dualism of Burke's thinking is obvious. In 1791, even before France was at war with anyone Burke was shrieking hysterically for a war with no limits to wipe out the thoroughly evil Revolution. No quarter to be given.

Burke never accepted the fact, and it is a fact, that the Revolution, in it's earlier phases had overwhelming popular support. It was always a group of evil secret conspirators who for decades had been planning this and they had duped people.

In his Reflections on the Revolution in France Burke has a interesting description of Marie Antoinette, it has to be read to be believed. In it Burke celebrates, how pretty, delicate, well mannered Marie Antoinette was when he saw her years earlier and he celebrates her graciousness and how "civilized" she is. The passage lends itself to satire, because what Burke seems to admire is so superficial and basically how airheaded Marie Antoinette seemed to be. To Burke the summit of the "civilization" of the old regime and in effect civilization itself is a seemly empty headed superficial person. Whatever. The actual Marie Antoinette is far more interesting than that.

Of course Burke waxed hysterical over the executions of Marie Antoinette and Louis XVI. We now know that both of them were passing military secrets to France's enemies during wartime so perhaps the hysteria is not warranted. Interestingly Burke didn't seem to be much bothered by Cromwell's execution of Charles I.

Burke like a lot of thinkers had views that changed over time. Towards the end of his life he became more and more Manichean and more and more the arch reactionary. He began to champion the "virtues" of "prejudice" over "reason". The very thought that "wigmakers" and other riff - raff would have any part of government drove him up the wall towards the end. To Burke it appears that Democracy was barbarism by definition if it interfered with the right of "Gentlemen" to rule.

Burke's understanding of the French Revolution was seriously flawed.
 
Last edited:
It is a common belief that Burke was right about the French Revolution because he predicted that it would lead to war and a military despotism. Why it led to a military despotism interested him more or less not at all.

His prediction is less impressive when you realize that what he was in fact doing was simply projecting the English Revolution of the 17th century on to the French Revolution. So not so impressive. What is also fascinating is how Burke danced around the fact that the English Political structure he so admired was the product of the English Revolution.

In his Reflections on the Revolution in France Burke, for example stated over and over again that the State's General in 1789 should have been the same as in the last time it was called (1614), otherwise it was a horrible breach of tradition. Further that the powers claimed by the Estates General were untraditional and violated tradition such as becoming the National Assembly. Why just like the Parliament of 1641 and later. Whose claims were in fact revolutionary and "extreme" and helped to set up the English system Burke so admired. Parliament ignored tradition and made claims to power that violated tradition quite explicitly.

The English Civil War was proportionally more deadly that the French Revolution in France and has for Vendee, that happened in Ireland. And of course a King was executed. And the Revolution ended up with a military despotism and lots of foreign wars.

After the restoration (1660) the old regime in England was not restored fully but only partly. In 1688 a foreign invasion (William and Mary), overthrew the King (James II), and installed a new regime and completed the establishment of Parliamentary supremacy, (Various acts, The Bill of Rights etc.). This was accompanied by much repression, foreign troops, and another bloody Vendee in Ireland. But the end result of all this was the Parliamentary system Burke so admired. Created by a great deal of violence, ignoring tradition etc.

It is amusing that Burke in his various writings was very well aware that most of the "Revolutionaries" early on simply wanted to create in France a system of government similar to that of Britain - Constitutional Monarchy. Why that wasn't achieved is an interesting question but not one Burke was interested in very much. Instead Burke said over and over again you can't have what we have because what we have emerged from tradition not revolution. Which was at least partly a lie.

The fact there had been no Estates General since 1614 and things had changed in the meanwhile cut no ice with Burke it had to be exactly the same because tradition. (The English Parliament of 1641 didn't think that way.)

Burke's understanding of the French Revolution was seriously marred by the fact his understanding of it's causes was bluntly idiotic. Before the revolution happened Burke seemed to have no idea that it was possible and thought France socially etc., was stable. This was utter rot. The serious financial, social and other problems in France were getting more and more serious. By 1782 it was painfully obvious that some sort of truly serious change was necessary. I won't go into the details of the unfolding crisis but by early 1789 it was disastrous.

Having little to no understanding of the causes of the French Revolution Burke instead conjured up a conspiracy theory, in which various intellectuals conspired to destroy the old regime, by trickery and deception and that right from the beginning they aimed at the annihilation of "civilization" etc. For decades before the Revolution these evil intellectuals had plotted, conspired to corrupt, French Society, destroy the basis of "civilization" to spread their evil beliefs throughout France and bring about the annihilation of "civilization". And of course all the so-called Revolutionaries were the same there were no distinctions between them in terms of wickedness and evil. Burke went so far as to say that these evil men sought to be tutors and teachers to the wealthy, worthy Aristocrats so that they could get into bed with their wives and daughters and corrupt them with their inferior, evil blood. At times Burke was positively foaming at the mouth.

And what was Burke's solution to the violence and excesses of the Revolution or in fact to the Revolution altogether? Why a complete and total restoration of the old regime, no compromises, no negotiation war to the max. A war of extermination, and everything about the Revolution to be annihilated. The Manichean dualism of Burke's thinking is obvious. In 1791, even before France was at war with anyone Burke was shrieking hysterically for a war with no limits to wipe out the thoroughly evil Revolution. No quarter to be given.

Burke never accepted the fact, and it is a fact, that the Revolution, in it's earlier phases had overwhelming popular support. It was always a group of evil secret conspirators who for decades had been planning this and they had duped people.

In his Reflections on the Revolution in France Burke has a interesting description of Marie Antoinette, it has to be read to be believed. In it Burke celebrates, how pretty, delicate, well mannered Marie Antoinette was when he saw her years earlier and he celebrates her graciousness and how "civilized" she is. The passage lends itself to satire, because what Burke seems to admire is so superficial and basically how airheaded Marie Antoinette seemed to be. To Burke the summit of the "civilization" of the old regime and in effect civilization itself is a seemly empty headed superficial person. Whatever. The actual Marie Antoinette is far more interesting than that.

Of course Burke waxed hysterical over the executions of Marie Antoinette and Louis XVI. We now know that both of them were passing military secrets to France's enemies during wartime so perhaps the hysteria is not warranted. Interestingly Burke didn't seem to be much bothered by Cromwell's execution of Charles I.

Burke like a lot of thinkers had views that changed over time. Towards the end of his life he became more and more Manichean and more and more the arch reactionary. He began to champion the "virtues" of "prejudice" over "reason". The very thought that "wigmakers" and other riff - raff would have any part of government drove him up the wall towards the end. To Burke it appears that Democracy was barbarism by definition if it interfered with the right of "Gentlemen" to rule.

Burke's understanding of the French Revolution was seriously flawed.
True, but so was Paine's. Both has very flawed views of the French Revolution.
I think the guy who might have come close to what happened in the French Revolution, and why it turned ou the way it did, was CHarles Dickens in A Tale Of Two Cities. The tyranny of the Old Regime created Madame Defrage;s who became as bad as the Old Regime.
 
Last edited:
I have to point out that even before the rise of Bonaparte, the French Revolution has turned bad with coming to power of the Jacobins and rule of the Commitee of Public Safety. If anything, the reign of terror was worse then anything that Bonaparte did when in power. Not excusing Napoleon, who a ruthless military dictator, but he was not quite as crazy as Robespierre and company got.
 
I have to point out that even before the rise of Bonaparte, the French Revolution has turned bad with coming to power of the Jacobins and rule of the Commitee of Public Safety. If anything, the reign of terror was worse then anything that Bonaparte did when in power. Not excusing Napoleon, who a ruthless military dictator, but he was not quite as crazy as Robespierre and company got.
You shouldn't have to point that out. Sure, neither Burke nor Paine were exactly right about the Revolution. Seems pretty clear Burke was closer.

It always makes me wonder about Jacobin magazine. Can't they find someone else to name themselves after that isn't more famous for the reign of terror than their political principles?
 
You shouldn't have to point that out. Sure, neither Burke nor Paine were exactly right about the Revolution. Seems pretty clear Burke was closer.

It always makes me wonder about Jacobin magazine. Can't they find someone else to name themselves after that isn't more famous for the reign of terror than their political principles?
Of course, but they did don't want to. The Magazine is ran by some pretty radical people on the left. They actually like what the Jacovins did.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom