Who Says American Kids Aren't Ambitious?

Mephisto

Philosopher
Joined
Apr 10, 2005
Messages
6,064
This has GOT to be a first in American History - a boy this young hospitalizing a homeless veteran. I say incarcerate him until he's 18, then put him in the Marines. ;)

Boy, 10, guilty of beating homeless Army veteran

POSTED: 10:34 a.m. EDT, May 11, 2007

DAYTONA, Florida (AP) -- A 10-year-old boy was convicted Thursday in the beating of a homeless Army veteran that left the man so severely injured he required reconstructive surgery.

Prosecutors say the boy, another 10-year-old and Jeremy Woods, 17, ganged up on John D'Amico, 58, as he and a friend walked through a Daytona Beach neighborhood on March 27. The older man was beaten and stoned with a concrete block.

Circuit Judge John Watson found the boy guilty of aggravated battery and set sentencing for May 24. (Watch the boy stand in an oversize jumpsuit and shackles )

The boy could be held in the juvenile system until he turns 21 if the judge considers him a habitual offender, or he could be given probation or counseling.

D'Amico, who still has a bandage over his left eye, testified that he never provoked the boys as they claimed.

http://www.cnn.com/2007/LAW/05/10/homeless.beating.ap/index.html


Can you spell W-A-R C-R-I-M-E-S?
 
This has GOT to be a first in American History - a boy this young hospitalizing a homeless veteran. I say incarcerate him until he's 18, then put him in the Marines. ;)

If they'll have the little ****.

A military-style prison/school would be good for him, too. Is there such a thing? There should be.
 
If they'll have the little ****.

A military-style prison/school would be good for him, too. Is there such a thing? There should be.

Who knows, but I would certainly have him serve some time at a VA hospital treating veteran amputees - maybe have him sit and listen to children his age who've lost a father in Iraq or Afghanistan. I say he got off pretty lucky by choosing a homeless vet with a conscience. Choosing the wrong homeless veteran could have gotten him dead, and considering the damage he and his buddy did, I'm sure the self-defense plea would have stood up in court.
 
It sounds like the 17 year old is mostly responsible, I find it hard to imagine a 10 year old doing this without peer pressure
 
It sounds like the 17 year old is mostly responsible, I find it hard to imagine a 10 year old doing this without peer pressure

I agree and would have had his 17 year old friend serving amputees alongside him - peer pressure can work both ways.
 
This has GOT to be a first in American History - a boy this young hospitalizing a homeless veteran. I say incarcerate him until he's 18, then put him in the Marines. ;)




Can you spell W-A-R C-R-I-M-E-S?

So we automatically believe the drunken derelict over the boys?:confused:
 
I've read the article twice and I can't seem to find any references to anyone drinking or being drunk at the time of the incident.

I take it that you're of the opinion homeless military veterans are by definition alcoholics?
 
Ok, then we automatically believe the not drunken derelict over the boys?

What part of . . .

A 10-year-old boy was convicted Thursday in the beating of a homeless Army veteran

. . . did you NOT understand? Apparently the jury believed the testimony, do you know something they do not? Didn't think so.

a G5Macdad
 
What part of . . .



. . . did you NOT understand? Apparently the jury believed the testimony, do you know something they do not? Didn't think so.

a G5Macdad

All of your comments are YOUR suggestions of punishments. What do they have to do with what the JURY believed? I asked if YOU automatically believe his testimony, not the jury.

With all due respect G5.
 
Last edited:
I'm not sure a jury had anything to do with this. The article left me with the impression both these kids pleaded no contest and the judge found them guilty.

I most certainly don't "automatically" believe anyone's testimony; but it seems even the kids' attorneys thought the homeless man (and his doctors, the police, etc) had such a good case it wasn't worth taking to trial.
 
I'm not sure a jury had anything to do with this. The article left me with the impression both these kids pleaded no contest and the judge found them guilty.

I most certainly don't "automatically" believe anyone's testimony; but it seems even the kids' attorneys thought the homeless man (and his doctors, the police, etc) had such a good case it wasn't worth taking to trial.

BS flag on this one.
 
Well you can disagree all you want; the kids have already been found guilty and they're going to jail. The little punks.
 
All of your comments are YOUR suggestions of punishments. What do they have to do with what the JURY believed? I asked if YOU automatically believe his testimony, not the jury.

With all due respect G5.

With all due respect, why would one of the 10 year old boys plead "no contest" if he didn't have knowledge of the event?

I'm certain it was an extreme case of peer pressure and I fail to see how one boy could plead no contest and the other, who obviously knew of the crime, wasn't also aware of the actions of the boys. If you're with two friends and they attack someone and injure them severely and you DON'T notify the authorities, aren't you by law an accomplice?

The other 10-year-old pleaded no contest to misdemeanor battery . . .

It's clear they were advised by their lawyer to plead no contest to escape a civil lawsuit by the veteran.

I will, however, admit to an emotional appeal in my suggestions for these little bastard's punishment - but then I'm a disabled veteran myself and feel that these little punks could use a lesson in respect. A homeless man is STILL a man and worse yet, a man who fought for the freedom of these ungrateful little malcontents.
 
Last edited:
With all due respect, why would one of the 10 year old boys plead "no contest" if he didn't have knowledge of the event?

I'm certain it was an extreme case of peer pressure and I fail to see how one boy could plead no contest and the other, who obviously knew of the crime, wasn't also aware of the actions of the boys. If you're with two friends and they attack someone and injure them severely and you DON'T notify the authorities, aren't you by law an accomplice?



It's clear they were advised by their lawyer to plead no contest to escape a civil lawsuit by the veteran.

I will, however, admit to an emotional appeal in my suggestions for these little bastard's punishment - but then I'm a disabled veteran myself and feel that these little punks could use a lesson in respect. A homeless man is STILL a man and worse yet, a man who fought for the freedom of these ungrateful little malcontents.

I can defend myself thank you very much.

Don't tell ME what I owe you. I will tell YOU.

A complete coward hides behind a gun. The fact that he got a full beat down by some kids says a lot about the man.

A MAN stands on his own.
 
Last edited:
I can defend myself thank you very much.

Don't tell ME what I owe you. I will tell YOU.

A complete coward hides behind a gun. The fact that he got a full beat down by some kids says a lot about the man.

A MAN stands on his own.

Huh?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom