Who Armed Saddam?

That was my shortcomings regarding bear spares and my inability to differentiate financial aid from them.

I was referring to Capitalistholocaust and Mr1001nights with regards to the evey single death claims.
 
That was my shortcomings regarding bear spares and my inability to differentiate financial aid from them.

I was referring to Capitalistholocaust and Mr1001nights with regards to the evey single death claims.

Now where were these claims made?
 
That was my shortcomings regarding bear spares and my inability to differentiate financial aid from them.

I was referring to Capitalistholocaust and Mr1001nights with regards to the evey single death claims.


Okaaayyy.

Well, you can certainly understand my confusion when you responded to my post with this ...

<snip>

You try to make it sound like the US was responsible for every single death in the Iran-Iraq war.


Note the word I highlighted.

I'm not sure who these other entities you are referring to might be, but you weren't very clear that you were addressing them in that post.

Or you are lying.
 
Sorry about the Ad hom. mr1001nights was the last person i heard go on about the America Armed Saddam canard and blamed the US for every war since its inception.

I stand corrected on many things today.
 
I think the interesting question is whether it was OK to fund Saddam as an annoyance to Iran. Was it OK to aid the mujahadeen in Afghanistan? At one point we considered those men as heroes and allies. Now they are terrorists.

Personally, I think it may be OK to play at that type of politics, but the blowback can be horrible, as we have seen.
 
I think the interesting question is whether it was OK to fund Saddam as an annoyance to Iran. Was it OK to aid the mujahadeen in Afghanistan? At one point we considered those men as heroes and allies. Now they are terrorists.

Personally, I think it may be OK to play at that type of politics, but the blowback can be horrible, as we have seen.

Well that's just it. The idea was that playing with the enemy of my enemy is that it is a distasteful thing that must be done to further the national interest.

But what we have seen is that the national interest was usually pursued with a short-term view. The blowback came to damage the national interest in the long term.

So yes, it may be "ok" but I think the biggest problem was being short-sighted, and things like say, supporting the Shah of Iran or the Mujahadeen in Afghanistan had long-term negative consequences that may very well outweigh the short-term benefits accrued earlier on.
 
Well that's just it. The idea was that playing with the enemy of my enemy is that it is a distasteful thing that must be done to further the national interest.

But what we have seen is that the national interest was usually pursued with a short-term view. The blowback came to damage the national interest in the long term.

So yes, it may be "ok" but I think the biggest problem was being short-sighted, and things like say, supporting the Shah of Iran or the Mujahadeen in Afghanistan had long-term negative consequences that may very well outweigh the short-term benefits accrued earlier on.

The long term negative consequences of backing Saddam against Iran was the invasion of Kuwait which we had the capacity to deal with.
 
The long term negative consequences of backing Saddam against Iran was the invasion of Kuwait which we had the capacity to deal with.

Sure, but then American troops were stationed to monitor the no-fly zones, and in Saudi Arabia - which turned into a major OBL irritant. Keeping Saddam contained meant standing aside and letting the Shiites get murdered in the thousands to keep the status quo unperturbed when they rose up - the bitter fruit of which came home to roost in the early days of the occupation.

Just saying that as much as it makes short-term sense to do something we have a few examples, like supporting the Shah in a coup and supporting OBL that didn't work out so well.

Hindsight is also 20/20 and all that but one would hope that American planners have learned something from the blowback and will be more careful when such gamesmanship is considered in the future. I should also state that even though I'm lefty peacenik in my heart I'm a realist in my brain of the Neibhur variety and so can understand that balance of power will dictate working with the "enemy of my enemy" - just saying that sometimes doing that will potentially harm the balance of power in the future if not carefully managed.
 
Last edited:
Sure, but then American troops were stationed to monitor the no-fly zones, and in Saudi Arabia - which turned into a major OBL irritant.

Neither of those were really required. Post gulf war Saddam was weakened enough that Saudi Arabia could defend itself. The Kurds as always were expendable.

Keeping Saddam contained meant standing aside and letting the Shiites get murdered in the thousands to keep the status quo unperturbed when they rose up - the bitter fruit of which came home to roost in the early days of the occupation.

Only a problem when we chose to occupy the place. We didn't have to.
 
Just saying that as much as it makes short-term sense to do something we have a few examples, like supporting the Shah in a coup and supporting OBL that didn't work out so well.
Did it work out better than if either of the other 2 likely possibilities had happened - either Iran becomes a client state of the USSR (the KGB was also trying to implement a power play of their own) or the Islamists gained power 25 years earlier than they did?

Iran wasn't about to transform into Denmark.
 
Last edited:
My answer to that, with the benefit of hindsight, is no. I think not installing the Shah would have worked out a lot better, even if that meant the soviets had more influence in Iran.
 
Well, the geopolitical ramifications of a Soviet Iran would have been immense, with Containment broken down.

The Soviets, exploiting the hole in the net, would have then expanded through the middle east and caused a lot more damage than Ajax.
 
Sure, but then American troops were stationed to monitor the no-fly zones, and in Saudi Arabia - which turned into a major OBL irritant. Keeping Saddam contained meant standing aside and letting the Shiites get murdered in the thousands to keep the status quo unperturbed when they rose up - the bitter fruit of which came home to roost in the early days of the occupation.

Just saying that as much as it makes short-term sense to do something we have a few examples, like supporting the Shah in a coup and supporting OBL that didn't work out so well.

Hindsight is also 20/20 and all that but one would hope that American planners have learned something from the blowback and will be more careful when such gamesmanship is considered in the future. I should also state that even though I'm lefty peacenik in my heart I'm a realist in my brain of the Neibhur variety and so can understand that balance of power will dictate working with the "enemy of my enemy" - just saying that sometimes doing that will potentially harm the balance of power in the future if not carefully managed.

The US never supported OBL.
 
The US never supported OBL.


During the days of Maktab al-Khidamat when they were both opposing the Soviet invasion of Afghanistan, the CIA had a program 'Operation Cyclone' to finance Afghan resistance groups through the Pakistani secret service.


Which seems quite indirect, but, heh, that sort of was the point.
 
Last edited:
During the days of Maktab al-Khidamat when they were both opposing the Soviet invasion of Afghanistan, the CIA had a program 'Operation Cyclone' to finance Afghan resistance groups through the Pakistani secret service.


Which seems quite indirect, but, heh, that sort of was the point.

Exactly, Afghan resistance - meaning Gulbuddin Hekmatyar, because he was the ISI's boy. And to a lesser degree Dostum (and a much lesser degree to Massoud). Remember the ISI was playing a double-game. Getting the USSR out of Afghanistan was only half of it. The other half was putting a pro-Islamabad government in Kabul (hence Hekmatyar and later the Taliban) to turn that country into a strategic-withdrawal point for Pakistan in case of a major war with India.

The Arabs who went to Afghanistan were financed by Arabs - who matched the $2 billion the US gave, dollar for dollar. That money went to OBL and others like him, directly, or went to the ISI to fund those already mentioned. Frankly, OBL wouldn't have taken American money even then.
 
My answer to that, with the benefit of hindsight, is no. I think not installing the Shah would have worked out a lot better, even if that meant the soviets had more influence in Iran.

I agree. The Soviets would have probably have had free elections and a moderate government would have been formed. And they all lived happily ever after.
 
During the days of Maktab al-Khidamat when they were both opposing the Soviet invasion of Afghanistan, the CIA had a program 'Operation Cyclone' to finance Afghan resistance groups through the Pakistani secret service.


Which seems quite indirect, but, heh, that sort of was the point.
Out of curiosity, what was sort of the point?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom