Which of These 12 Facts About Jesus Do You Believe Are True?

Name the most likely one.
I'm not qualified to say which is most likely, I can only give you an opinion. And my opinion is that the Gospels were written down so long after the events that they purport to describe that it is pretty much inevitable that there was a certain amount of embellishment of the original oral history. That's what humans do - just ask any folklorist. Legends may well be based on actual events, but they almost never report them 100% accurately.

I think it's quite possible that an itinterant street preacher annoyed the wrong people and was executed by the Romans. I think it's also quite possible that the stories that have been built up around his divinity are greatly exaggerated.
 
Hey, I'll play this game. I'll be super generous and accept ALL of your premises to be true. So?
 
Is that genuinely what you believe?
Not one bit but why does it matter? You were trying to make some sort of point but are unwilling to be honest and instead play this game instead.

So let's not play this little dishonest game. I'll accept your premises. Now what?
 
So did they make up the story about seeing Jesus alive from the dead?
Did who make up the story? There's no evidence that either Jesus or the disciples existed.

How would Paul genuinely convert to the faith if he didn't lie?
By believing in something without any evidence.

This has been known to happen.
 
Gospels were written down so long after the events that they purport to describe
I have 3 points:

1) Paul died in the Neronian persecution in 64-65 AD. Luke set forth the biography of Paul in Acts, his mission activities. But at the end of the book, Paul had not yet died. So Acts had to have been written before his death. Had he died the author would have mentioned it. Death is important in a biography. Luke is part one of Acts and is stated as such. In the book of Acts the writer says, "The former treatise I presented to you Theophilus." That's Luke. So Luke was written prior to Acts. But Luke used Mark. Now you are moving back from 64-65, and Jesus died 33 AD. That places all this stuff within a decade or two.

2) Paul said in Gal. 1 & 2 he met James and Peter a few years after the cross as indicated in 1 Cor. 15 in which he is delivering what he received from them. Scholars place his conversion 2 years after the cross, then Galatians says it was "3 years" after his conversion he met James and Peter, so that's 5 years after the cross he met the original eyewitness apostles.

3) To the best of my knowledge, there is nothing recorded in antiquity so close to the events that happened. Therefore, it is holding the highest of standards of historical record.
 
Last edited:
I have 3 points:

1) Paul died in the Neronian persecution in 64-65 AD. Luke set forth the biography of Paul in Acts, his mission activities. But at the end of the book, Paul had not yet died. So Acts had to have been written before his death. Had he died the author would have mentioned it. Death is important in a biography. Luke is part one of Acts and is stated as such. In the book of Acts the writer says, "The former treatise I presented to you Theophilus." That's Luke. So Luke was written prior to Acts. But Luke used Mark. Now you are moving back from 64-65, and Jesus died 33 AD. That places all this stuff within a decade or two.

2) Paul said in Gal. 1 & 2 he met James and Peter a few years after after the cross as indicated in 1 Cor. 15 in which he is delivering what he received from them. Scholars place his conversion 2 years after the cross, then Galations says it was "3 years" after his conversion he met James and Peter, so that's 5 years after the cross he met the original eyewitness apostles.

3) To the best of my knowledge, there is nothing recorded in antiquity so close to the events that happened. Therefore, it is holding the highest of standards of historical record.


Except for the fact that Acts sharply contradicts Paul's epistles in several places.

Oopsie.
 
What would you need as more evidence than already exists?

We need to ask some questions.
  1. Are there alternative explanations for the existence of the claims? Yes.
  2. Do the claims fit with what we know about the laws of physics and the natural world? No.
Stories documented long after the fact are too easily mis-rememberd, embelished or misheard. Of course there are alternative explanations. People lie and or are sincerly deluded or simply mistaken. There are examples all around us and throughout history.

Some day people might legitimatly argue that Paul Bunyan had a giant blue ox.

If thousands of people sincerly believe that they saw the sun dance in the sky but that doesn't fit the laws of physics and the natural world then we have reason enough to dismiss it without better evidence.

Eyewitness testiomny is poor evidence. Third hand eyewitness testimony is piss-poor to say the least.

The amazing thing about human nature is that anyone would believe in the claims giving all of what we know about people and thier ability to turn mythology and oral tradition into rock solid beliefs.
 
Biblo, you kicked off this thread with a title which prevents, as has already been demonstrated by the responses so far, a fruitful discussion. Let's take a look at your title and explore its implications.

Which of These 12 Facts About Jesus Do You Believe Are True?

First, your 12 "Facts" are not all facts. Thus, you start with some presumptions that we do not buy into yet you call them facts. You'd be better off starting with "12 hypotheses" or something like that. Then we could have a good discussion about those hypotheses.

Secondly, people do not "believe" facts. "Facts" are, by definition, not subject to belief. Obama is President of the USA. California is one of the 50 states. Those are "facts" which is not subject to belief. You would be well advised to understand the difference between facts and beliefs.

Finally, please explain how a "fact" could not be "true". Is there an alternative?

IOW, you need to sharpen the focus of your OP if you wish to have any useful discussion of whatever topic it is that you want to explore.
 
when they are all FACTS like claimed in the OP. why should we not belive them?
all you need i s credible evidence and not hearsay.
 
I have 3 points:

1) Paul died in the Neronian persecution in 64-65 AD. Luke set forth the biography of Paul in Acts, his mission activities. But at the end of the book, Paul had not yet died. So Acts had to have been written before his death. Had he died the author would have mentioned it. Death is important in a biography. Luke is part one of Acts and is stated as such. In the book of Acts the writer says, "The former treatise I presented to you Theophilus." That's Luke. So Luke was written prior to Acts. But Luke used Mark. Now you are moving back from 64-65, and Jesus died 33 AD. That places all this stuff within a decade or two.

2) Paul said in Gal. 1 & 2 he met James and Peter a few years after after the cross as indicated in 1 Cor. 15 in which he is delivering what he received from them. Scholars place his conversion 2 years after the cross, then Galations says it was "3 years" after his conversion he met James and Peter, so that's 5 years after the cross he met the original eyewitness apostles.

3) To the best of my knowledge, there is nothing recorded in antiquity so close to the events that happened. Therefore, it is holding the highest of standards of historical record.
  1. We don't have originals.
  2. We have interpretations of interpretations.
  3. We know that there are contradictions between versions.
  4. We know that there were different mindsets and motivations of the authors to convey different and conflicting messages.
3 years is a long, long time and that's generous to give you that. In the end we can't prove when it was written. There's no forensic data. Your argument is circular. You are dating the text based on the text as if someone couldn't possibly lie or make a mistake.

That said, your argument is silly, even if it were all true and I'm confident that much of it is wrong it isn't the highest standard of anything.

Bart Ehrman started out trying to prove that the NT was an historical account of the life of Jesus. He come to the conclusion (he understood the facts) that there are significant differences in the different manuscripts and those differences reveal the motivation of the authors and the blatant inventions to satisfy their own world view of this new interest in an aleged guy named Jesus.

Then again, Obi Wan was either a lunatic or he had the force. You decide.
 
3) To the best of my knowledge, there is nothing recorded in antiquity so close to the events that happened. Therefore, it is holding the highest of standards of historical record.
Then you need more knowledge. If you accept the Roman Republic and Empire as "antiquity" (and it appears you do) we have a huge number of contemporary, first-hand accounts of events of all sorts.
 
1. Jesus died by crucifixion.
2. He was buried.
3. His death caused the disciples to despair and lose hope.
4. The tomb was empty (the most contested).
5. The disciples had experiences which they believed were literal appearances of the risen Jesus (the most important proof).
6. The disciples were transformed from doubters to bold proclaimers.
7. The resurrection was the central message.
8. They preached the message of Jesus’ resurrection in Jerusalem.
9. The Church was born and grew.
10. Orthodox Jews who believed in Christ made Sunday their primary day of worship.
11. James was converted to the faith when he saw the resurrected Jesus (James was a family skeptic).
12. Paul was converted to the faith (Paul was an outsider skeptic).
You sure have a twisted definition of fact.
 
If they believed in Christ, wouldn't they be Christians and not Orthodox Jews?
If they were baptized they would be considered christians. If they aren't, I have personally heard a rabbi say they were still jews, just bad ones but still jews.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom