Where can I 'own' land?

Rolfe- You got me curious about this feu business. It seems similar to the covenants that any previous owner can impose in Eng & Wales, where if you sell your idyllic Cotswold Cott. (3 up,3dn All md cons) you can set conditions on the buyer- eg no running a business, no late parties-often previously agreed with the local Residents Association Einsatzgruppe- and if the prospective purchasers are desperate enough to sign, they're stuffed.
Seems there can be an endless series of superiors, starting with whoever sold it to you .
I'd think the quarry group who owned the land would have researched this thoroughly and ensured they held the feu superiority. Might be worth asking them if they mind you putting a new window in.
Here's an interesting spin off of the 2004 Abolition ob Feudal Tenure Act.
It seems by removing the right of the feudal superior to set conditions, Holyrood have accidentally yielded those same powers to neighbours in some cases.
Have a read of this.
http://www.shepwedd.co.uk/knowledge...firms-bad-news-for-developers/archive/?page=2

There are a number of links via the Pairliament site, one of which refers to a person who had to pay 3 levels of superiors to install a loo in his own house!
My pad is freehold, I'm happy to say. Viva el Peoples Republic del South Lanarkshire!
 
In exchange for property taxes you do get certain benefits. Maybe you don't think those benefits are worth it, but that's a separate matter. For example, if you want to have illegal squatters evicted you would call the police. If a burgler tries to rob your house, you can call the police to have him arrested. The county clerk (or some such person) has a copy of your deed on record in case somebody claims the land actually belongs to them. So you have legal protection.

If there was a place without any property tax, you would probably have to provide all these services by yourself or pay for them.
 
Ehhh ... you win a million dollar home, the taxes are about $10,000 a year, you try to keep it and live in it but go bankrupt?

How come they didn't, on the brink of bankrupcy, let me see, I have it: Sell the home for what they could get for it? Half a million, maybe?

Even if you couldn't pay the taxes at all, the house would probably be auctioned away and I cannot see how it could possibly sell for less than the accumulated taxes.

I don't believe the story is true.

:cool:


Actually.. You win a million dollar home. You have to pay the taxes on what the house is WORTH, right away. No idea how much, it may vary, but it could be 30-40%. Its like winning the lottery. You pay taxes on your winnings.
 
We do have a property tax in Scotland, based on a crude banding system. Mine seems to be about 0.5% of the value of the property.

People have refused to pay this tax (or rather its predecessor) in the past, on the grounds of principle. They were pursued vigorously and some of them ended up in jail. However, taking away the property wasn't possible.

Actually, it's not really a property tax as such, because the person liable to pay is the occupier, not the owner. It's to pay for services, therefore the person receiving the service is liable to pay.

There is currently a furious debate raging about abolishing the tax entirely, and replacing it with a graduated income tax. The government wants to do that, but as they are a minority administration the opposition can block them and they are doing that. Just this morning, as I was putting my socks on, I heard the leader of the opposition explaining how at the moment no, he didn't have an alternative replacement for the council tax, but trust him, once they finally figure something out, it will definitely be better than the government's proposal which they are voting down. :boggled:

Rolfe.

Here's an interesting idea: People who don't want the services can 'opt out,' but if they are visited by burglers or squatters, they get no help from the police. If their house is on fire, they get no fire extinguishing service. I wonder how many people would choose to 'opt out'?

:degrin:
 
If there was a place without any property tax, you would probably have to provide all these services by yourself or pay for them.
More than that: you'd have to pay for them twice.

You see, the portion of the property tax that falls on land reduces the sale price correspondingly; if you did away with the property tax an instituted, say, an income tax, the result would be that property values would rise. So a prospective buyer would have to pay more for his land, and in addition, he'd pay more income tax. Effectively, you'd pay twice for the same services you now pay for once.
 
Here's an interesting idea: People who don't want the services can 'opt out,' but if they are visited by burglers or squatters, they get no help from the police. If their house is on fire, they get no fire extinguishing service. I wonder how many people would choose to 'opt out'?

:degrin:


Excuse me, but in what way is that a reasonable answer to my description of the debate on whether local authority finance should be raised by a property tax or an income tax?

Soapy Sam had a very reasonable objection to the proposed switch to an income-based tax. It would be interesting to hear the government's response to his concerns.

Suggesting that people could simply opt out of taxes and services is about as hepful as - oh I don't know, suggesting that you might opt out of any contributions to other people's healthcare and then be left to die on the street when you get sick yourself.

Oh, wait....

Rolfe.
 
Excuse me, but in what way is that a reasonable answer to my description of the debate on whether local authority finance should be raised by a property tax or an income tax?

Soapy Sam had a very reasonable objection to the proposed switch to an income-based tax. It would be interesting to hear the government's response to his concerns.

Suggesting that people could simply opt out of taxes and services is about as hepful as - oh I don't know, suggesting that you might opt out of any contributions to other people's healthcare and then be left to die on the street when you get sick yourself.

Oh, wait....

Rolfe.

This is for the hardcore libertarians to make them happy. It's not "helpful" other than that.
Are there not some people who would choose that if given the option?
I wouldn't choose it myself.
 
Actually.. You win a million dollar home. You have to pay the taxes on what the house is WORTH, right away. No idea how much, it may vary, but it could be 30-40%. Its like winning the lottery. You pay taxes on your winnings.


Yeah, we have been throught that - but winning a million dollar home still won't make you bankrupt.
 
I presume the tax authorities will give you some time to pay? Even of you put the house on the market the minute you have the keys, it will take a few months before you actually have $300,000 or $400,000 to give them.

It does seem a very mean thing to do to people, all in the name of a TV show.

Rolfe.
 
I presume the tax authorities will give you some time to pay? Even of you put the house on the market the minute you have the keys, it will take a few months before you actually have $300,000 or $400,000 to give them.

It does seem a very mean thing to do to people, all in the name of a TV show.

Rolfe.


I don't think it is a mean thing to do to people and I would really, really appreciate it if the winner would back out and say "I'll let Bjorn have it, it's going to ruin me". :cool:

Imagine that the tax athorities want their money right away. While the winner lists that house for sale, the authorities are going through the long procedure to put a lien on your new property, starting the collection process, finally ending up auctioning the house at the steps of the courthouse.

Unless we believe that it will be sold for less than a third of the "real value", the winner still makes money - and the auction price would be a good starting point for arguing what the real value of your price was in the first place.

I simply cannot see how the winner can turn into a loser.

If I win the California lottery on a good jackpot day I will win a hundred million dollars. If I take the cash payment I will get paid about fifty million dollars cash, and the tax is about one third of that - I end up with thirty million dollars and change.

I'm not bankrupt, I am still a winner.
 
I presume the tax authorities will give you some time to pay? Even of you put the house on the market the minute you have the keys, it will take a few months before you actually have $300,000 or $400,000 to give them.

It does seem a very mean thing to do to people, all in the name of a TV show.

Rolfe.


I think that the tax wouldn't come due until the following filing date (15 April). Worst case scenario, you could use the property as collateral on a secured loan for the taxes owed (plus a bit extra for loan payments until it sells) which would give you even more time to get the best price possible.
 
Yeah, I thought it would work like that.

I still think it's a mean thing to do to people. The house is an object of desire. It's not just a wodge of money the show is dangling in front of people, it's a dream of a lifestyle and a habitat and indeed, a home.

A dream that can never be. If all the contestants are there in the hard-headed knowledge that the house is simply an asset to be sold and capitalised on, then fine, but I'll just bet they aren't. To win your dream like that, then understand that it can never be yours - what's the point? Why not simply award a cash prize, or find some way to award a more modest but still comfortable house that the contestants can actually call home?

Yeah, I know. Not such good TV. I still think it's mean.

And lottery and gambling winnings in this country are not taxed. Even Premium Bond prizes are tax-free.

Rolfe.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom