What if you're wrong?

mmh i would say, Well get out of my way man, you dont exist. i KNOW it.
 
It is pretty widely accepted that a thread on this topic will provoke more joke answers
than real answers, so I'll have a go.

What will I say to the real God? "You're more pink and more invisible than I could have ever imagined."
 
You will not post anything that is considered pornographic, obscene, or contains excessive reference to violence and/or explicit sexual acts.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Lisa Simpson
 
Last edited by a moderator:
If some doofus presents himself to me as a divine being, I'll simply ask: "Evidence?"

If he has no better arguments than kk, yrreG, and DOC, I'm going to kick him in the low hanging fruit.
 
Just a nitpick, an entity able to create the universe would not necessary be smart, only have the correct tool, the will to do it, and a big but finite amount of energy. I never understood why people keep ascribing it the tag "smart" as there is no display of smartness involved. It could be pure reflex or instinct without even a single drop of intelligence involved.

For what it matters, it could be that you meet after death a completely retard idiot god, dancing at the sound of an insane flute music(i.e. Azatoth).

Hehe, I would pay good money to see the fundies faces when they saw that :D

Perhaps god is a giant blob that just creates universes when it farts.
 
A religious person would say that they took a chance. They believed in one god and if they were wrong then they're no worse off than an atheist. But if they're right then they win big.

Basically they'd use Pascal's Wager.
 
So, to the religious folk who frequent this forum and believe atheists and agnostics will go to hell once they die:

What if you're wrong? What will you say to the real god when you face him/her/it in the after-life?
Let's see, if it's Allah, my comment might be: "Sorry I don't speak Arabic. I am up for some virgins if you are feeling ever merciful, as your Faithful tell me you are."

If it's Vishnu: "Which of your hands do I shake?"

If I am standing in line for my appointment with one of Lucifer's minions, i'd say" "Yeah, it really does remind me of a Texas Driver's License waiting line when the AC breaks down."

If it's a Wiccan deal, I'll point out that my visit to Stonehenge was a profound personal experience, and that I think Getafix was a better character than either Asterix or Obelix.

If I am facing Cthuthlu, I'm dinner, and my fate is to become cosmic fewments.

Facing Athena? "Sorry for the instant erection, most astute and glorious daughter of Zeus (and hotter than Aphrodite) but smart, pretty ladies in togas get my blood boiling. Please get that spear out of me arse and get that owl to stop crapping on my head."
 
Last edited:
Although, I was expecting a majority of joke responses (which I enjoy reading), I was hoping to get at least one or two serious answers. Where are kurious_kathy and yrreg when you actually want to hear what they have to say?


A religious person would say that they took a chance. They believed in one god and if they were wrong then they're no worse off than an atheist. But if they're right then they win big.

Basically they'd use Pascal's Wager.


And, so, choosing correctly becomes a game of lottery. Choosing the correct number may win you millions of dollars or not win you anything at all, since you're buying your lottery ticket not knowing whether the prize money actually exists. On the other hand, not buying a lottery ticket certainly won't win you millions of dollars, but it may get you burned at the stake.

Even if you buy a lottery ticket, the correct number may be outside the range of the lottery numbers available for selection. You can choose between numbers 1 and 45, but God may be number 777.

How is eternal punishment fair or just in choosing poorly in such a ridiculous gamble?

kurious_kathy, yrreg, DOC, hello...?
 
They are consulting with their respective Gods for the proper response ;)
 
In any 'larger-than-life' wildlife encounters i've had, it feels like a meeting with a divine entity.
If god is anything like that, expect to crap your pants.
 
A religious person would say that they took a chance. They believed in one god and if they were wrong then they're no worse off than an atheist. But if they're right then they win big.

Then again, maybe God doesn't reward gamblers? Or people who abandon the gifts of logic and reason "just to be on the safe side"? Maybe I die and God says, "Congratulations, you passed the test. You used the brains I gave you the right way. Personally, I thought it was obvious that it was all nonsense, but those believers, nothing you could do could change their blinkin minds."

Even if there IS a God, there is no reason to think that he would reward "faith." Or be anything like the God described in the bible.

Finally, to add my usual explanation: If God exists, he created me as a thinking being and gave me the gift of reason and rational thought. Meanwhile, he did not provide any evidence for his existence, which means that in order to believe in him, I would have to not use my god-given gift and resort to faith. However, not using my god-given gift would be an affront to my creator, and would be a sin. Thus, I conclude (and no one has yet challenged this) that, if God exists, it would be a sin for me to believe in him.
 
In any 'larger-than-life' wildlife encounters i've had, it feels like a meeting with a divine entity.
If god is anything like that, expect to crap your pants.

Those of us who are raptured will not be wearing any pants, so it'll be "Look out below!"
 
Then again, maybe God doesn't reward gamblers? Or people who abandon the gifts of logic and reason "just to be on the safe side"? Maybe I die and God says, "Congratulations, you passed the test. You used the brains I gave you the right way. Personally, I thought it was obvious that it was all nonsense, but those believers, nothing you could do could change their blinkin minds."

Even if there IS a God, there is no reason to think that he would reward "faith." Or be anything like the God described in the bible.

Finally, to add my usual explanation: If God exists, he created me as a thinking being and gave me the gift of reason and rational thought. Meanwhile, he did not provide any evidence for his existence, which means that in order to believe in him, I would have to not use my god-given gift and resort to faith. However, not using my god-given gift would be an affront to my creator, and would be a sin. Thus, I conclude (and no one has yet challenged this) that, if God exists, it would be a sin for me to believe in him.

Nicely put!

The 'gamble' I have heard said IRL, mainly as a way to stop discussion, 'well if I'm wrong, so be it, no harm done'.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom